Does high karma still matter on Reddit today ?

Matchaaaaa said:
Reddit's risk engine got a massive update recently. It cares infinitely more about subreddit-specific authority and your session health. If you take a 5-year-old account with 100k karma that used to post memes, and suddenly try to drop serious marketing content in a niche business sub, the algorithm silently kills your reach.
Click to expand...
did u find a way to how work with that? They basically made impossible to do any commenting marketing ...
 
Advertise on BHW
I'm going to run a live test for you guys. Split test.

Results will be shared on another post. Stay tuned.
 
A test that shows the different resutls of High Karma aged accounts vs Low Karma Aged Accounts
And a super active account

Activity + karma + age = the best.
 
lifehacker24 said:
did u find a way to how work with that? They basically made impossible to do any commenting marketing ...
Click to expand...
Commenting marketing isn't dead; the brute-force method of it is. You bypass this by building micro-authority. Instead of blasting comments across 50 different subreddits with one purchased account, you must dedicate one perfectly cloaked profile to one specific niche.
 
Matchaaaaa said:
Commenting marketing isn't dead; the brute-force method of it is. You bypass this by building micro-authority. Instead of blasting comments across 50 different subreddits with one purchased account, you must dedicate one perfectly cloaked profile to one specific niche.
Click to expand...
it doesn't work either, we tried to warm up for specific subreddits
 
lifehacker24 said:
it doesn't work either, we tried to warm up for specific subreddits
Click to expand...
Then your execution was flawed, not the strategy. The vast majority of operators fail the warm-up phase because their behavioral velocity still reeks of marketing intent. Dropping generic, low-effort agreements or artificially pacing your replies triggers the automated spam filters almost instantly.
 
I think Reddit has become more focused on engagement and relevance rather than just account age or karma. If the content triggers discussion, it tends to do better now.
 
In my opinion, a high karma score is one of the most valuable aspects of a Reddit account. It boosts your credibility and makes it easier to engage with larger and more active communities across Reddit.
 
Yes, high Reddit karma still matters, but it's no longer the biggest ranking factor.
 
Karma is more like a trust signal. It helps with restrictions, better account credibility, and smoother participation, but the actual engagement usually comes from content quality, subreddit fit, posting habits, and how well you interact with people. i have also noticed that accounts actively participate in discussions build better visibility over time. Reddit users are good at recognizing accounts that are there only for self-promotion.
 
Yes I think it does, also more importantly the age of the account. Reputation matters and you can have more authority in some subreddits by having more karma
 
Karma is useful for getting past some subreddit restrictions, especially for newer accounts.
 
IndexSmith said:
Karma is useful for getting past some subreddit restrictions, especially for newer accounts.
Click to expand...

You mean all the best subs pretty much

Everybody's tight on karma farming and bots now

And those without rules, ifyou post with a new accont and get karma, you'll get banned lol

It's a clusterfuck
 
I think the quality of your contributions matters more than the exact karma number. Helpful comments usually build a better reputation.
 
I think reddit engagement depends on several things, including timming, content quality, subreddit activity, and how people respond to the post.
 
Karma is probably important too... in my opinion... and right now it's important CQS for trust from reddit...
 
Church Priest said:
Hi everyone,

I always believed that once a Reddit account builds high karma, it automatically gets better reach and engagement on posts. But recently, I have started noticing something different.

Some newer accounts are getting more comments and upvotes compared to older accounts with much higher karma. This makes me fee like Reddit might now be focusing more on other factors like content quality, activity level and how relevant the post is to the subreddit.

Has anyone else noticed this shift or is it just my experience ?
Click to expand...
From what I've seen, high karma is still useful, but I don't think it's the biggest ranking factor anymore. It helps establish credibility and can get you past posting restrictions in many subreddits, but it doesn't guarantee that your posts will perform well.

In my experience, relevance to the specific subreddit, posting at the right time, and writing something that encourages discussion have a much bigger impact on engagement. I've also seen newer accounts do very well because they shared content that matched what the community wanted to see.

I think karma should be viewed as a trust signal rather than a growth strategy. A high-karma account can still receive very little engagement if the post isn't interesting or doesn't fit the subreddit, while a newer account can perform surprisingly well with the right content.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top