I fully agree that you can agree to disagree.
In my place, and it is on the other side of the planet if you're in US -- has already stopped selling pirated DVDs since about 6 months back. They had to after some sellers got fined in lakhs of Indian Rupees for keeping / renting 'copies' of latest blockbuster Bollywood movies. They are shit scared now -- all of them. The entertainment piracy, offline at least, is dead in my region. And of course, the Multiplex theaters here are running full houses now, almost all shows and most of the time. College students are bunking classes and are seen in theaters

, that reminds me of my own college days!
Online piracy of movies is going to stop soon at least in my land and the Bollywood industry is working hard on achieving it; what with your IP and MAC addresses are being logged and registered for near-future appropriate use by authorities... people who know these things aren't downloading as much and like as before... AND that's a FACT!
What's happening is good for some, bad for some...
Again, just my thoughts.
P.S.:
One more thing, students are buying the legal DVDs, only one piece and are then either circulating that DVD or are distributing home-made copies among themselves. So there are going to be smarter people around all the time.