Being a software developer too, I'd like to offer my 2c. I did not purchase YT Massacre because I have my own bot for this but here are a few general thoughts:
First, refunds are not an option. Especially with all the bhtters around here who'd have no moral issues with requesting a refund for a perfectly good product.
However, timely upgrades and thorough beta testing are a must, especially if you're gonna sell software for around $150. Microsoft has been known to sell buggy software, but at least the core features work. From what I gather here this is not the case.
Third, Executive VIPs should be protecting the integrity of the forum, not defending its senior members at all costs when those members (Bo & Freq) should have clearly responded to the thread sooner and indicated what course of action they were planning on taking to resolve all the issues. It's nice you look out for each other, guys, but if you want to kill the BST section there's no better way. Might as well start offering paid reviews.
Bickering apart, here is what I would do if I was Bo&Freq:
1) Stop selling the software until the bugs are fixed
2) Notify everyone who has purchased the software that you are aware of the bugs and are working actively to fix them. Give them a tentative timeframe for the fix and stick to it.
3) Notify mods when the bugs are fixed so they can close this thread ASAP.
Anyway, good luck to Bo&Freq, when the bugs are fixed this should be a great piece of software.
Good points headspin, but just to be clear, I'm not defending them because they're VIPs. I'm defending the concept of not just coughing up a refund because it's demanded.
I'm not a coder myself, but I am a systems analyst. I gather requirements, create usage scenarios and do basic design of GUIs working with a team of 3 developers. To create even a "simple" program like this that works takes time and resources and there are always bugs and glitches. I helped develop a system for our recruiting department, which had an existing pen and paper system. It took 6 weeks of discovery and testing to create a workable model. Another 6 weeks to develop it and we're now in month 6 and v2.2 of the final application and STILL find little bugs and crashes as users add weird shit to their system.
I've seen crashes caused by google toolbar, screensavers, changing the way our corporate internet filters work, a timing issue where the date/time stamp in the database was parsing out the milliseconds and one user just happened to hit save at exactly the same time that another did which attempted to force a duplicate record into the database.
My point is that even with the resources we have available, crashed happen. Even though the team I work with are full time, paid employees, delays in support happen as other projects take precedence for a few hours or a few days.
The MAJORITY of buyers of the product seem to be satisfied and stopping sales of a functional product where most buyers are satisfied, and/or rushing out a patch for a problem that in the case the user wouldn't even fully document isn't the best solution. It's bad business.
I've never bought any of Bo and Freq's projects to date. I probably will, but that's not the issue.
The issue is simply that I know exactly how hard it is to satisfy everyone and I'm trying to help those who are dissatisfied understand the behind the scenes workings a bit better to either help them find a little peace about it now, or if nothing else, let them decide with better information whether or not to buy future products.
Someone above said that customer service makes or breaks a business and it's true. If Bo and Freq piss off enough customers, they'll lose business. that's the nature of business and if it happens, so be it; maybe they'll learn something too.
But please don't accuse me of blindly backing this because it assumes I have no experience here and no desire to help either the buyers or the forum. I wouldn't BE an exec VIP if I hadn't committed myself to helping the members of this forum, VIP all the way to 1 post newbie.
Thanks for your insight and comments.
-scuba