Website rankings are improving but traffic is not growing. Why?

Advertise on BHW
Yeah, I've seen this happen too. Sometimes you're ranking for keywords that barely get any searches. You might be moving up in Google, but if nobody's searching for those terms, the traffic won't really change much.
 
This is a good question, and I think the gap often comes from what is actually being ranked. If the gains are on keywords with very little search demand, or on pages that show up in features where people get the answer without clicking, the ranking chart can look better while visits stay flat. I would compare the queries that moved up with the ones that normally bring clicks, and also check whether titles and descriptions are giving people a clear reason to click. That check usually shows whether it is a traffic problem or just a measurement problem.
 
there are multiple causes of this.

the ranking went up but not far enough to get clicks. 45 to 14 sounds great but page 2 gets almost no clicks. most clicks go to the top 5. search console is averaged over every query a page shows up for. so u can rank #2 for a term that no one searches for and #99 for the one that matters but still report a nice looking average score.

search intent mismatch. some pages are for sales, some for research. or some queries are looking for competitors or specific brand.
 
Good point, xavierfok. The jump from 45 to 14 does look big on paper, but as you said, page 2 still gets very little traffic. That average position point is also worth checking, since one strong term can hide weaker ones. Thanks for adding that detail.
Regards
 
Could just be the SERP layout pushing you down. Even if you rank top 3, if there are four sponsored ads, an AI overview, and a massive PAA box above you, nobody is scrolling far enough to click.
 
This can happen if you are targeting low volume keywords or your titles aren’t enticing enough you can look at google search console to see where your issue is look at impressions CTR and search intent
 
WHITE CAT SEO said:
I have been seen websites improve their keyword positions without getting much organic traffic. What could be the main reason for this? Is it related to search intent, keyword selection, CTR or something else? I would like to hear how others have handled this issue.
Click to expand...
check which pages are improving their rankings and not the overall average of ur website. uhh could be rising in rankings on terms that doess not generate any revenue for your site.
 
Mostly because they might be low search volume keywords with low keyword difficulty. If this happens even they ranked those keywords there won't be enough visitors search for those keywords.
 
WHITE CAT SEO said:
I have been seen websites improve their keyword positions without getting much organic traffic. What could be the main reason for this? Is it related to search intent, keyword selection, CTR or something else? I would like to hear how others have handled this issue.
Click to expand...
sometimes the ranking of websites gets better on the desktop end but the reality is that the users searching through their smart phones will have a different search engine results page. before I mess with the content i would compare Google Search console data on how many clicks my website got via each device.
 
I think, The reason for this is targeting keywords based on ranking potential rather than actual search demand.
If impressions are increasing but clicks are not, then the title and meta description may need to be improved.
 
keyword selection and search intent are two big factors here. You can improve rankings for keywords that have very little search volume or don’t bring the right audience. CTR also matters.
 
WHITE CAT SEO said:
I have been seen websites improve their keyword positions without getting much organic traffic. What could be the main reason for this? Is it related to search intent, keyword selection, CTR or something else? I would like to hear how others have handled this issue.
Click to expand...
Check impressions and CTR independently. Should impressions be growing but clicks unchanged, assess the title and meta description. In the case of poor impressions consider search demand and keyword selection.
 
I think it could be a mix of things. Some keywords might be ranking better but don't get much search traffic, or they might not match what people are actually looking for. I'd also check impressions and CTR. Getting higher rankings is great, but it's just as important to target keywords that bring in the right audience.
 
WHITE CAT SEO said:
I have been seen websites improve their keyword positions without getting much organic traffic. What could be the main reason for this? Is it related to search intent, keyword selection, CTR or something else? I would like to hear how others have handled this issue.
Click to expand...
In my personal experience, it often comes down to choosing the right keywords and their intent.

Improvements in ranking do not necessarily equate to increases in traffic, particularly when you consider keywords that receive low volume and have low search intent.

I would also consider looking into the number of impressions, click-through rate (CTR), presence in SERPs, and if the keywords target the right people.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top