Puppeteer vs BAS for CTR bot

XRumer only wins if most of those sites share supported CMS + you accept footprint risk, it’s fast but dumb. Zennoposter or code gives you flexibility but you’re basically building 3100 mini workflows,
This is 100% not true. You do not need to build 3100 workflows. The same way Xrumer works by posting to CMS is exactly how you should make the workflows in Zennoposter. Why would you believe that? Is it because you are copy pasting out of ai without any real experience?
 
All of this you are talking about is built into zennoposter and yes it has a real antidetect browser built in with browser profiles you can save, reuse, and rotate through. Browser automation is not out of reach if you don’t know how to code, and many of us don’t care to spend a bunch of time learning to tinker with python when this won’t be the main source of our income.

ZP also emulates mobile devices very well. It’s your proxies that will tell on you because of TCP/IP fingerprint.
fair take - ZP lowered the barrier a lot, no argument there. My point wasn’t “ZP can’t do it”, it’s that scale + heterogenous platforms still means logic debt, you pay it either in code or in visual spaghetti. Proxies + network layer burn accounts faster than browser flags anyway, so people expecting any tool to be plug and play at 3k sites are setting themselves up for pain.
 
fair take - ZP lowered the barrier a lot, no argument there. My point wasn’t “ZP can’t do it”, it’s that scale + heterogenous platforms still means logic debt, you pay it either in code or in visual spaghetti. Proxies + network layer burn accounts faster than browser flags anyway, so people expecting any tool to be plug and play at 3k sites are setting themselves up for pain.
This is ai copy paste. The member likely has little to no experience with browser automation, browser fingerprinting, etc
 
This is ai copy paste. The member likely has little to no experience with browser automation, browser fingerprinting, etc
relax with the AI accusations - been running browser automation + posting stacks longer than most people here have accounts. Nothing I said conflicts with ZP capabilities

Im talking ops reality - CMS templates still drift, JS changes, rate limits, per-site quirks, thats logic debt whether you script it or drag blocks. ZP lowers friction, it doesn’t delete entropy, and pretending 3k mixed platforms is fire-and-forget is how people burn weeks troubleshooting. But whateva o_O
 
@sebastien350 real answer - there is no single tool that will cleanly autopost across 3100 random platforms without custom work. XRumer only wins if most of those sites share supported CMS + you accept footprint risk, it’s fast but dumb. Zennoposter or code gives you flexibility but you’re basically building 3100 mini workflows, so ROI depends on how many sites actually convert, most won’t. I’d segment first, forums on one stack, classifieds another, socials manual or semi-auto, otherwise you’ll spend more time fixing bots than posting.
Im doing this because I'm so tired of spend thousands of dollars on paid ads on facebook, Instagram, google ads, reddit ads, etc that barely convert in sales.
SEO I tried through last years and only attract Indian/African traffic that obviosly because are poor countries never convert into sales..

So I want to build a genuine relationship with my audience and make them purchase my products.

BTW my business is basically selling car parts and accessories for cars, to europe and North america.
 
Last edited:
Im doing this because I'm so tired of spend thousands of dollars on paid ads on facebook, Instagram, google ads, reddit ads, etc that barely convert in sales.
SEO I tried through last years and only attract Indian/African traffic that obviosly because it's poor countries never convert into sales...

So I want to build a genuine relationship with my audience and make them purchase my products.

BTW my business is basically selling car parts and accessories for cars, to europe and North america.
makes sense but CTR bots aren’t gonna fix that problem - they just juice signals, they don’t create demand or trust. If you’re selling car parts to EU + NA, the bottleneck is intent + audience quality, not clicks

\Paid ads burn because targeting is broad + cold, SEO burns because you’re ranking informational junk with zero buyer intent

What actually works here is hybrid - money pages optimized for high intent queries, then traffic layering. Real users from geo-matched sources, forums, niche communities, YouTube shorts, TikTok , then light CTR reinforcement so Google sees engagement consistency. Bots alone without real humans just create noise + risk, especially in ecom

If you want relationship + conversions, build content where car guys already hang out, pull them to owned assets, then use automation only to stabilize rankings, not fake a business model. CTR is seasoning, not the meal
 
This is ai copy paste. The member likely has little to no experience with browser automation, browser fingerprinting, etc
Yes I haven't much experience on it. I just want to save more time on posting my content to the websites I'm already member for few years.
I already post manually to 7000 websites before, 3900 banned me for spam and 3100 not.
The results were positive. I sold products regarding my business (car parts and accessories) which I reach $8500 in sales with this free method.
So because it works and I have some good reputation on many websites, I just want automate this process to make free campaigns in across this 3100 websites and potentially keep selling like I did, in other previous campains.
 
puppeteer is the best program for this kind of things
 
makes sense but CTR bots aren’t gonna fix that problem - they just juice signals, they don’t create demand or trust. If you’re selling car parts to EU + NA, the bottleneck is intent + audience quality, not clicks

\Paid ads burn because targeting is broad + cold, SEO burns because you’re ranking informational junk with zero buyer intent

What actually works here is hybrid - money pages optimized for high intent queries, then traffic layering. Real users from geo-matched sources, forums, niche communities, YouTube shorts, TikTok , then light CTR reinforcement so Google sees engagement consistency. Bots alone without real humans just create noise + risk, especially in ecom

If you want relationship + conversions, build content where car guys already hang out, pull them to owned assets, then use automation only to stabilize rankings, not fake a business model. CTR is seasoning, not the meal
Ok thanks. Clearly you have good aknoledge about this matter and I thank you for explaining me.
What you recommend me to do specifically in more detail? I mean what kind of approach in order to attract quality traffic and potential buyers should I have?
I appreciate your help if you don't mind.
 
Yes I haven't much experience on it. I just want to save more time on posting my content to the websites I'm already member for few years.
I already post manually to 7000 websites before, 3900 banned me for spam and 3100 not.
The results were positive. I sold products regarding my business (car parts and accessories) which I reach $8500 in sales with this free method.
So because it works and I have some good reputation on many websites, I just want automate this process to make free campaigns in across this 3100 websites and potentially keep selling like I did, in other previous campains.
I wasn’t talking about you I was talking about the guy copying and pasting ai responses that don’t reflect real experience or even reality. Bad advice, wrong advice, about how zennoposter works and browser automation in general.
 
I wasn’t talking about you I was talking about the guy copying and pasting ai responses that don’t reflect real experience or even reality. Bad advice, wrong advice, about how zennoposter works and browser automation in general.
so Should I use all the 3 software we talked about (bas ,, zennoposter and Xrumer) in order to try to automatize all my 3100 and making this type of "no cost posting campaigns"?
 
so Should I use all the 3 software we talked about (bas ,, zennoposter and Xrumer) in order to try to automatize all my 3100 and making this type of "no cost posting campaigns"?
As mentioned earlier no one will be able to tell you what software to use because we don’t know what CMS is involved. I cannot answer the question with any level of certainty because of that.
 
As mentioned earlier no one will be able to tell you what software to use because we don’t know what CMS is involved. I cannot answer the question with any level of certainty because of that.
Yes I understand.
Paid ads are getting a more and more risky strategy nowdays. Fucking investments in paid ads in Facebook, Instagram, Google, Reddit, Native ads, etc often end up in ROI below 100%. I rarely reach ROI above 100%, and even with very very great designed verticals and multiple variations which I created in multiple social platforms, 60 different ads which specific GEO's and intrests that would be very likely to convert, even those rarery reach positive ROI.

I'm fucking tired of the conservative mentality, a fearful attitude towards everything that comes along.. What a shitty mentality that most people in the world have nowdays. Unbelivable the current times.
 
As mentioned earlier no one will be able to tell you what software to use because we don’t know what CMS is involved. I cannot answer the question with any level of certainty because of that.
Manual posting strategy works very well but it takes me 9-10 days..
I usually got $8k - $10k average profit..

For me isn’t much..
 
Browser Automation Studio is a no code option that’s handy for quick tasks, Playwright/Puppeteer give more control and reliability for devs.
I haven't any knowledge about coding. I just want to create simple tasks for 3100 sites in order to avoid spend straight, 9, 10, days and more days, doing manual posting that is extremely boring and it make me do a giant sacrifice in terms of time used..


You only recommended BAS software or u recommended any other tools?..
 
Last edited:
fair take - ZP lowered the barrier a lot, no argument there. My point wasn’t “ZP can’t do it”, it’s that scale + heterogenous platforms still means logic debt, you pay it either in code or in visual spaghetti. Proxies + network layer burn accounts faster than browser flags anyway, so people expecting any tool to be plug and play at 3k sites are setting themselves up for pain.
Trueplayer is someone who should be listened too. I do anti detect bots with proxy layers and all that and you shouldn't even share proxy pools on an anti detect layer, let alone any Saas platform.

Do it right, run your own, it's extremly naive to use shared proxy pools, there's a few days worth reading to do about how proxies work, what is dns and how to check them before starting any operation.

Proxy providers are the biggest scammers and liars by omission in this whole field, they are literally recycling rubbishware.

People think residential proxies with rotation are somehow a good thing, when it's an extremly end user hostile practice and a simple money grab which contaminates the pools at a velocity that's incredible.

The anti fraud tools, if a website uses them will know within seconds.

Residential proxies are nowadays required for scraping the golden era is long gone, they can't be used for serious operations.

Which brings us to static isp, which have a limited, but better life time of beand new and the asn and subnet isn't marked as "bad neighborhood".

The people are quick to blame anti detects which they do not really understand to set up either, but the worst offender and pitfall is always the proxies.

I was asked to rest some provider and they had internal dns leaks.

Some providers assign the same ssl cert to tens of thousands of ips.

Mobile proxies kinda require a mobile interface emulator, which are brittle. What ifnthe website tries to trigger open web console, what if Google asks you to open an app on your "phone" etcetera.
 
I've also had mixed experiences with BAS, and I agree that the quality of proxies and fingerprints plays a crucial role in its performance. However, I've found that Zennoposter is indeed a more reliable option, especially when it comes to CTR manipulation and emulating real browser behavior. Can anyone share their experience with setting up Zennoposter for large-scale email registration, and what kind of success rates they've achieved with it? Additionally, what are some good sources for high-quality proxies that can help improve the performance of these bots?
 
Trueplayer is someone who should be listened too. I do anti detect bots with proxy layers and all that and you shouldn't even share proxy pools on an anti detect layer, let alone any Saas platform.

Do it right, run your own, it's extremly naive to use shared proxy pools, there's a few days worth reading to do about how proxies work, what is dns and how to check them before starting any operation.

Proxy providers are the biggest scammers and liars by omission in this whole field, they are literally recycling rubbishware.

People think residential proxies with rotation are somehow a good thing, when it's an extremly end user hostile practice and a simple money grab which contaminates the pools at a velocity that's incredible.

The anti fraud tools, if a website uses them will know within seconds.

Residential proxies are nowadays required for scraping the golden era is long gone, they can't be used for serious operations.

Which brings us to static isp, which have a limited, but better life time of beand new and the asn and subnet isn't marked as "bad neighborhood".

The people are quick to blame anti detects which they do not really understand to set up either, but the worst offender and pitfall is always the proxies.

I was asked to rest some provider and they had internal dns leaks.

Some providers assign the same ssl cert to tens of thousands of ips.

Mobile proxies kinda require a mobile interface emulator, which are brittle. What ifnthe website tries to trigger open web console, what if Google asks you to open an app on your "phone" etcetera.
Thanks for your explanation. But for users like me that haven't any knowledge in coding , the BAS is the best option to create auto posting tasks in forums and community websites?
 
Thanks for your explanation. But for users like me that haven't any knowledge in coding , the BAS is the best option to create auto posting tasks in forums and community websites?
Yes mate, it's your best bet , unless you want to hire someone to build such a bot, which is tedious and might end up a bit expensive, relatively. But sooner or later it'll all be dedicated bots by necessity, the websites have pretty good tools available, most just don't have the time or expertise to integrate after going live as these thjngs are better done right away.
 
Yes mate, it's your best bet , unless you want to hire someone to build such a bot, which is tedious and might end up a bit expensive, relatively. But sooner or later it'll all be dedicated bots by necessity, the websites have pretty good tools available, most just don't have the time or expertise to integrate after going live as these thjngs are better done right away.
yes I will look into it. Thanks.
In my case the results were positive after almost 2 weeks posting manually and building few parasite websites and ranking them, to then after few work, send addicional Tier 1 traffic .

2 month ago I sold products regarding my business (car parts and accessories) which I reach in total, $8500 in sales with this free method.

It works well but it's very time consuming.
 
Back
Top