Puppeteer vs BAS for CTR bot

[Rashmar]

I really regret not learning playwright. They say it is better in terms of being undetectable. For those who are interested in both Playwright and BAS engine, you can also check this repo on github, Seems like it is still on the demo versions but usable.

https://github.com/sergerdn/vuetify-electron-starter

 

[V]

I really regret not learning playwright. They say it is better in terms of being undetectable. For those who are interested in both Playwright and BAS engine, you can also check this repo on github, Seems like it is still on the demo versions but usable.

https://github.com/sergerdn/vuetify-electron-starter

Playwright is simple af. Maybe I feel so because I've been using Selenium for a long time. But you should definitely give it a try.

 

[Deleted member 731332]

Playwright is simple af. Maybe I feel so because I've been using Selenium for a long time. But you should definitely give it a try.

I stopped using selenium because the webdriver is, or at least was, easily detected by Google, Reddit, Facebook, instagram etc. Has that improved?

 

[jackreather]

zenoposter may work better. Why you try your setup?

 

[sebastien350]

It has a very good built in antidetect browser. It also has great documentation. Anyone interested I highly suggest reading the new documentation.

They do have a standalone antidetect browser called zennobrowser. It’s still in beta but you can sign up and use it with zennoposter. I haven’t tried it yet so I can’t comment.

The stuff about BAS having more features is total BS. I’m putting that one on ignore.

Hi. In your opinion To auto post the same content in thousands of forums and community boards, which one could work better? Zennoposter or XRumer?

 

[Seonetworkuk]

Hello guys. trying to create a simple bot for my own website to visit and perform some actions. However, I'm a little confused about Browser Automation Studio form bablosoft. I'm going to use my own proxies alongside Fingerprint Switcher.

Is BAS only for non-programmers and shouldn't be used if you can get your hands on puppeteer or it has some better features for anti-detection? Does BAS use puppeteer itself? If so, would the result be the same in my case?

BAS is mainly a visual tool aimed at non-programmers and doesn’t give any special anti-detection advantage by itself. If you’re comfortable coding, Puppeteer or Playwright will give you more control and flexibility, and BAS doesn’t simply run Puppeteer under the hood.

 

[sebastien350]

BAS is mainly a visual tool aimed at non-programmers and doesn’t give any special anti-detection advantage by itself. If you’re comfortable coding, Puppeteer or Playwright will give you more control and flexibility, and BAS doesn’t simply run Puppeteer under the hood.

In your opinion To auto post the same content in thousands of forums and community boards, which one could work better? Zennoposter or XRumer?

 

[Deleted member 731332]

Hi. In your opinion To auto post the same content in thousands of forums and community boards, which one could work better? Zennoposter or XRumer?

Zennoposter is better in the end for several reasons. Xrumer accounts are easy to spot. They all have a footprint. But with zennoposter you have to develop registration and posting etc. So if you don’t have any experience in programming you’re going to want something that does it for you.

 

[sebastien350]

Zennoposter is better in the end for several reasons. Xrumer accounts are easy to spot. They all have a footprint. But with zennoposter you have to develop registration and posting etc. So if you don’t have any experience in programming you’re going to want something that does it for you.

The thing is I have a huge list with 3100 websites which I'm a registered member, such as (forums, community boards, social networks, descentralized sites, press releases, classified sites , etc) so I can post in all of them to generate free traffic. I already post in 500 forums + Few Sub-Reddits , and I got succesfully generate dozens of sales on my new website.
What I'm concerned is if using Xrumer I would be able to automatize autoposting in all my 3100 websites in order to generate a lot of quality traffic and more sales.
(I don't like to invest in paid ads to be honest. Too much money for nothing).....

So because of this , I'm in doubt and consider which option should be the best in order to automatize my 3100 sites which I'm already member.

So probably I have to do more analysis in order to make a decision. What you suggest me to do in this case?

I just don't want to waste money in softwares that doesn't work..

 

[Deleted member 731332]

The thing is I have a huge list with 3100 websites which I'm a registered member, such as (forums, community boards, social networks, descentralized sites, press releases, classified sites , etc) so I can post in all of them to generate free traffic. I already post in 500 forums + Few Sub-Reddits , and I got succesfully generate dozens of sales on my new website.
What I'm concerned is if using Xrumer I would be able to automatize autoposting in all my 3100 websites in order to generate a lot of quality traffic and more sales.
(I don't like to invest in paid ads to be honest. Too much money for nothing).....

So because of this , I'm in doubt and consider which option should be the best in order to automatize my 3100 sites which I'm already member.

So probably I have to do more analysis in order to make a decision. What you suggest me to do in this case?

I just don't want to waste money in softwares that doesn't work..

Xrumer can post to several forum CMS. It can post to all the most common forum cms like IPB, xenforo, and the common open source forums. If your login credentials were registered on forums made with the CMS’ Xrumer is programmed to post to then yes it can.

 

[sebastien350]

Xrumer can post to several forum CMS. It can post to all the most common forum cms like IPB, xenforo, and the common open source forums. If your login credentials were registered on forums made with the CMS’ Xrumer is programmed to post to then yes it can.

Ok thanks.
Zennoposter isn’t also a good software to auto posting in forums , community boards and multiple social network as well?

 

[Deleted member 731332]

Ok thanks.
Zennoposter isn’t also a good software to auto posting in forums , community boards and multiple social network as well?

You have to build that functionality into zennoposter but the fact that it has an antidetect browser built in and you can customize every aspect of the operations makes it substantially better than anything you can buy premade. If you are not using a browser by now for registration and posting then you won’t have great results. Xrumer doesn’t use a browser. It uses get/post.

Zennoposter does not come with premade registration or posting bots. You make them. Totally custom.

So like I said previously if you don’t have programming experience, if you don’t know how browser fingerprinting works, and especially if you don’t know anything about html, css, or JavaScript, hire someone that does or buy premade like Xrumer

Xrumer still has a learning curve and it’s not a simple one.

 

[SirPrompt]

zennoposter - there is not a single user on the Russian forum who will give at least a minimal guarantee that zenposter will create, even minimally, conditionally anonymous profiles, it burns almost 100% of the time and, for example, it is absolutely unsuitable for Reddit
on bas, you can try to work with Reddit, but also conditionally

Xrumer IS DESIGNED FOR COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TASKS.

I am writing this as the owner of all of the above products for many years.

zennoposter is convenient as routine automation

 

[Deleted member 731332]

zennoposter - there is not a single user on the Russian forum who will give at least a minimal guarantee that zenposter will create, even minimally, conditionally anonymous profiles, it burns almost 100% of the time and, for example, it is absolutely unsuitable for Reddit
on bas, you can try to work with Reddit, but also conditionally

Xrumer IS DESIGNED FOR COMPLETELY DIFFERENT TASKS.

I am writing this as the owner of all of the above products for many years.

zennoposter is convenient as routine automation

Why are you commenting trying to confuse people?

In this conversation, if you had read anything, one member was asking if zennoposter or Xrumer would be better to comment on forum websites. Both Zennoposter and Xrumer can comment on forum websites if you have made that engine in Zennoposter.

No, the softwares are not for different tasks. Xrumer is specifically made to post and comment on forums. Zennoposter can be made to post and comment on forums. Obviously Zennoposter can be used for far more applications but it is incorrect to say Xrumer is made for something different when in the context of the conversation it is absolutely not.

 

[SirPrompt]

Why are you commenting trying to confuse people?

In this conversation, if you had read anything, one member was asking if zennoposter or Xrumer would be better to comment on forum websites. Both Zennoposter and Xrumer can comment on forum websites if you have made that engine in Zennoposter.

No, the softwares are not for different tasks. Xrumer is specifically made to post and comment on forums. Zennoposter can be made to post and comment on forums. Obviously Zennoposter can be used for far more applications but it is incorrect to say Xrumer is made for something different when in the context of the conversation it is absolutely not.

https://www.blackhatworld.com/seo/xrumer-can-you-make-good-money-from-it.1751428/post-20302874

a seller of Russian software?

>> >>
zenposter will not give anonymous deep browser fingerprints, BAS is more interesting in this regard, zenposter has other advantages and they are unconditional, but it is NOT an anti-detector, even with the new zen browser

It would be better to comment on the solution compiled through the AI API, and today we are at this starting point.

 

[trueplayer]

@Rashmar if you can code, skip BAS entirely - it’s a convenience layer not a magic antidetect. Puppeteer is fine but Playwright is cleaner for this use case, better control over contexts, permissions, mobile emu + less jank with Chromium updates. Real detection comes from how you handle fingerprint, timing, navigation, scroll + SERP behavior, not the tool - bad logic on Playwright still burns just as fast as BAS. For CTR specifically you want full control over page lifecycle + events, that’s where code wins every time.

 

[sebastien350]

@Rashmar if you can code, skip BAS entirely - it’s a convenience layer not a magic antidetect. Puppeteer is fine but Playwright is cleaner for this use case, better control over contexts, permissions, mobile emu + less jank with Chromium updates. Real detection comes from how you handle fingerprint, timing, navigation, scroll + SERP behavior, not the tool - bad logic on Playwright still burns just as fast as BAS. For CTR specifically you want full control over page lifecycle + events, that’s where code wins every time.

Ok I understand your point.
But for example: In my case I'm a already registered member in around 3100 websites in the last years, in websites like: forums, social networks, descentralized sites, classified ads sites, press releases, files sharing sites, multiple community websites like quora and slack, and many other types of websites, and I would like to post my content , in all of those 3100 websites.

What I want to do is repeated tasks, doing just copy/paste the title, content and tags on all those 3100 sites instead of spending long days posting manually in all of them.

Which one of the tools you guys mentioned is the best for automated posting in different types of websites like the ones I mentioned?.
The best option is the Zennoposter, BAS or Xrumer for this kind of task?

 

[Deleted member 731332]

Ok I understand your point.
But for example: In my case I'm a already registered member in around 3100 websites in the last years, in websites like: forums, social networks, descentralized sites, classified ads sites, press releases, files sharing sites, multiple community websites like quora and slack, and many other types of websites, and I would like to post my content , in all of those 3100 websites.

What I want to do is repeated tasks, doing just copy/paste the title, content and tags on all those 3100 sites instead of spending long days posting manually in all of them.

Which one of the tools you guys mentioned is the best for automated posting in different types of websites like the ones I mentioned?.
The best option is the Zennoposter, BAS or Xrumer for this kind of task?

You’re going to have to figure out what’s best for you. You have many peoples experience with the tools in question to help you decide. We don’t know what websites you’re talking about, we don’t know what CMS are part of it. No single person is going to be able to point at a tool for you and say “that’s the best”

 

[trueplayer]

Ok I understand your point.
But for example: In my case I'm a already registered member in around 3100 websites in the last years, in websites like: forums, social networks, descentralized sites, classified ads sites, press releases, files sharing sites, multiple community websites like quora and slack, and many other types of websites, and I would like to post my content , in all of those 3100 websites.

What I want to do is repeated tasks, doing just copy/paste the title, content and tags on all those 3100 sites instead of spending long days posting manually in all of them.

Which one of the tools you guys mentioned is the best for automated posting in different types of websites like the ones I mentioned?.
The best option is the Zennoposter, BAS or Xrumer for this kind of task?

@sebastien350 real answer - there is no single tool that will cleanly autopost across 3100 random platforms without custom work. XRumer only wins if most of those sites share supported CMS + you accept footprint risk, it’s fast but dumb. Zennoposter or code gives you flexibility but you’re basically building 3100 mini workflows, so ROI depends on how many sites actually convert, most won’t. I’d segment first, forums on one stack, classifieds another, socials manual or semi-auto, otherwise you’ll spend more time fixing bots than posting.

 

[Deleted member 731332]

@Rashmar if you can code, skip BAS entirely - it’s a convenience layer not a magic antidetect. Puppeteer is fine but Playwright is cleaner for this use case, better control over contexts, permissions, mobile emu + less jank with Chromium updates. Real detection comes from how you handle fingerprint, timing, navigation, scroll + SERP behavior, not the tool - bad logic on Playwright still burns just as fast as BAS. For CTR specifically you want full control over page lifecycle + events, that’s where code wins every time.

All of this you are talking about is built into zennoposter and yes it has a real antidetect browser built in with browser profiles you can save, reuse, and rotate through. Browser automation is not out of reach if you don’t know how to code, and many of us don’t care to spend a bunch of time learning to tinker with python when this won’t be the main source of our income.

ZP also emulates mobile devices very well. It’s your proxies that will tell on you because of TCP/IP fingerprint.