2captcha vs Xevil vs GSA CB vs Capmonster vs Captcha Sniper

The problem starts a bit with the recaptcha V2, it needs good private/dedicated proxies otherwise it gets hit with Google ban.

Capmonster has that problem also. So you pay 10 usd uor xevil monthly and probably another 30/50 USD for decent proxies every month... So it becomes cost effective if you do some decent amount of submissions every day.

Is xevil stable on desktop or do you use vps ? @ngocthang26

Each software has its own advantages and disadvantages. I think captcha and recaptcha then Xevil processing is best

I use Desktop ( Core I7, Ram 16GB ) but so hard use many thread because don't many proxy
 
What kind of experience have you got with RankerX + CapMonster? I can not afford to buy Xevil right now.
 
What kind of experience have you got with RankerX + CapMonster? I can not afford to buy Xevil right now.

I have Capmonster. Bought it about 10 months ago, when I've decide to give seo spam a second chance and needed a good solver for Recaptchav2. I also have Captcha breaker.
I think Capmonster is above Captcha Breaker for regular captchas.

Xrumer/Xevil will take a lot of hardware resources, so if you don't have enough money for Xevil, your next best choice is Capmonster (5 threads).
You need dedicated proxies as well, or rotating residential proxies - t hat's another expense. Don't bother with public proxies, they simply do not work.

Captcha Breaker might be good, but every time I tried it, it just missed. It still very good for some types of captchas and also is very fast.

Why I will always choose Capmonster? Because there's a community of developers that really listens. Unlike Xevil, you will have a forum for support. There were two times last year when Google made changes in Recaptcha and solving went down a lot, and they fixed it in maximum 5-10 days with a new version. Take that into account, support and continuous development is always a decisive factor when buying something.

Take a look at my stats (I usually reset them after 2-3 days). First Capmonster is for Recaptcha, GSA Captcha Breaker was not used because I rarely use it, second Capmonster is for normal captchas:

e4TxMsh


For those who say Capmonster is not good with normal captcha, try using the Universal Module for solving all captcha.
 
I have Capmonster. Bought it about 10 months ago, when I've decide to give seo spam a second chance and needed a good solver for Recaptchav2. I also have Captcha breaker.
I think Capmonster is above Captcha Breaker for regular captchas.

Xrumer/Xevil will take a lot of hardware resources, so if you don't have enough money for Xevil, your next best choice is Capmonster (5 threads).
You need dedicated proxies as well, or rotating residential proxies - t hat's another expense. Don't bother with public proxies, they simply do not work.

Captcha Breaker might be good, but every time I tried it, it just missed. It still very good for some types of captchas and also is very fast.

Why I will always choose Capmonster? Because there's a community of developers that really listens. Unlike Xevil, you will have a forum for support. There were two times last year when Google made changes in Recaptcha and solving went down a lot, and they fixed it in maximum 5-10 days with a new version. Take that into account, support and continuous development is always a decisive factor when buying something.

Take a look at my stats (I usually reset them after 2-3 days). First Capmonster is for Recaptcha, GSA Captcha Breaker was not used because I rarely use it, second Capmonster is for normal captchas:

e4TxMsh


For those who say Capmonster is not good with normal captcha, try using the Universal Module for solving all captcha.


could you pm me if you can or post here where you get those proxies? I don't get more than 40% success rate with capmonster and buyproxies.org dedicated proxies.
 
could you pm me if you can or post here where you get those proxies? I don't get more than 40% success rate with capmonster and buyproxies.org dedicated proxies.

It looks like we have the same provider :) My success rate is well above 60%, but I run GSA SER with very few threads (sometimes less than 10) if I know I will have to solve many recaptchas. For blog posts, I just disable it - you lose around 10% of links, no big deal.

So it's not about Capmonster, but the speed of GSA -> lower the threads in GSA, use the proxies in Capmonster (not in GSA). Capmonster will rotate them efficiently. I think one proxy can solve around 20-30 recaptchas until it gets banned, but if you go slow, it can make a big difference.
Edit: a banned proxy will recover in time (minutes or hours). If you have enough proxies and rotate them, you will have very few banned proxies in 24h.

Of course, if you have hundreds of dedicated proxies, you can run GSA at a very nice speed.
 
Last edited:
It looks like we have the same provider :) My success rate is well above 60%, but I run GSA SER with very few threads (sometimes less than 10) if I know I will have to solve many recaptchas. For blog posts, I just disable it - you lose around 10% of links, no big deal.

So it's not about Capmonster, but the speed of GSA -> lower the threads in GSA, use the proxies in Capmonster (not in GSA). Capmonster will rotate them efficiently. I think one proxy can solve around 20-30 recaptchas until it gets banned, but if you go slow, it can make a big difference.
Edit: a banned proxy will recover in time (minutes or hours). If you have enough proxies and rotate them, you will have very few banned proxies in 24h.

Of course, if you have hundreds of dedicated proxies, you can run GSA at a very nice speed.


Yes you are on point. The threads are a killer. So what I did was :

1. Load 30 proxies into ranker X (or GSA)
2. Put the threads on 10.. so a ratio of 3:1 which is pretty generous I would think
3. Increase overal timeouts in capmonster by around 50%.. you know like waiting to click etc
4. Load the same proxies into capmonster and let capmonster use those

it's very slow off course but I wanted to see what the maximum result would be..... I have not tried it with GSA yet but Rankerx has a lot of Recaptchas... I mean average campaign it runs around 3000 recaptchas and 1200 normal captchas.... I'm now trying capmonster cloud which does have a good successrate of around 80% but still after X amount of campaigns.. it is cheaper to just purchase the siteaddon and run it yourself with proxies.... but only if the successrate is at least 80% or something... would you be willing to share your capmonster settings?
 
Sure, my Capmonster settings are simply the default ones. No kidding. And I would advise against changing them unless you are pretty sure it will work better, otherwise it can do more harm. I did it and it was worse. All I had to "fine tune" is the number of proxies and GSA threads.

I guess 99% of RankerX's sites have Recaptcha. In this case, you should run on minimal threads and try with 30 proxies. If it's not OK, then buy more proxies. Run with 1-2 threads only?

Yes, submitting can be painfully slow while trying to keep the proxies alive, but hundreds of dedicated proxies are not worth it for me at this point. On Capmonster's forum you can ask for proxies, maybe you'll get a good deal.
 
Sure, my Capmonster settings are simply the default ones. No kidding. And I would advise against changing them unless you are pretty sure it will work better, otherwise it can do more harm. I did it and it was worse. All I had to "fine tune" is the number of proxies and GSA threads.

I guess 99% of RankerX's sites have Recaptcha. In this case, you should run on minimal threads and try with 30 proxies. If it's not OK, then buy more proxies. Run with 1-2 threads only?

Yes, submitting can be painfully slow while trying to keep the proxies alive, but hundreds of dedicated proxies are not worth it for me at this point. On Capmonster's forum you can ask for proxies, maybe you'll get a good deal.


Alright i will give the defaults a go! what is your thread to proxies ratios for it? good to know buyproxies is good enough for it !
 
Alright i will give the defaults a go! what is your thread to proxies ratios for it? good to know buyproxies is good enough for it !

I tried a lot before settling to buyproxies :)

It's hard to figure out the ratio for you. For me, if I use blog comments I just disable it, unless it's edu/gov from all around the world. If I solve 2-3 at the same time, I decrease the speed a little. If I have forums, I go with 8 threads in GSA, but not all forums have Recaptcha - maybe 40%? Joomla K2 engines have a lot of old Recaptcha code, not updated, they generate a lot of timeouts since it cannot get the token. So you would think it's Capmonster or the proxies, but it's the site itself.

If I see 5-6-7 Recaptchas solved at the same time (with 30 proxies, let's say), and if this will be the trend, I'll get banned pretty fast. This problem is solved with a much larger proxy pool or by decreasing threads.

You need to play with it for a while to find the sweet spot :)
 
I have Capmonster. Bought it about 10 months ago, when I've decide to give seo spam a second chance and needed a good solver for Recaptchav2. I also have Captcha breaker.
I think Capmonster is above Captcha Breaker for regular captchas.

Xrumer/Xevil will take a lot of hardware resources, so if you don't have enough money for Xevil, your next best choice is Capmonster (5 threads).
You need dedicated proxies as well, or rotating residential proxies - t hat's another expense. Don't bother with public proxies, they simply do not work.

Captcha Breaker might be good, but every time I tried it, it just missed. It still very good for some types of captchas and also is very fast.

Why I will always choose Capmonster? Because there's a community of developers that really listens. Unlike Xevil, you will have a forum for support. There were two times last year when Google made changes in Recaptcha and solving went down a lot, and they fixed it in maximum 5-10 days with a new version. Take that into account, support and continuous development is always a decisive factor when buying something.

Take a look at my stats (I usually reset them after 2-3 days). First Capmonster is for Recaptcha, GSA Captcha Breaker was not used because I rarely use it, second Capmonster is for normal captchas:

e4TxMsh


For those who say Capmonster is not good with normal captcha, try using the Universal Module for solving all captcha.
Thank you for sharing. I tried RankerX + Capmonster (5 threads). It's really working fine. I'm also using XEvil to save the my costs. Both are good for me
 
I tried a lot before settling to buyproxies :)

It's hard to figure out the ratio for you. For me, if I use blog comments I just disable it, unless it's edu/gov from all around the world. If I solve 2-3 at the same time, I decrease the speed a little. If I have forums, I go with 8 threads in GSA, but not all forums have Recaptcha - maybe 40%? Joomla K2 engines have a lot of old Recaptcha code, not updated, they generate a lot of timeouts since it cannot get the token. So you would think it's Capmonster or the proxies, but it's the site itself.

If I see 5-6-7 Recaptchas solved at the same time (with 30 proxies, let's say), and if this will be the trend, I'll get banned pretty fast. This problem is solved with a much larger proxy pool or by decreasing threads.

You need to play with it for a while to find the sweet spot :)


even with 30 dedi and 5 threads only 40% success.. better than nothing i guess haha
 
even with 30 dedi and 5 threads only 40% success.. better than nothing i guess haha

You sure you did the basic steps with the proxies? For Capmonster to work, you need to strip them to ip: port and use IP authorization. Don't use proxies with passwords directly in Capmonster, from my experience they do not work that way.

Did you also check this?
gCyTAbL


Not sure how you set it up, but a workaround would be this:
- do the steps mentioned above, if you didn't.
- insert all your dedi proxies in Capmonster.
- put how many proxies you wish in RankerX (30,15, 10), according to your needs OR use a good VPN for RankerX, so the proxies will be assigned only for solving RV2.
- run a campaign again and see what happens.

40% success is very low, it should be around 70% (with a mix of banned ips or bad ips - bad ip is either the proxy or the website).

How many Recaptchas are being solved at the same time before you see the proxies are starting to get burned (banned)? Maybe you are building up a huge queue...
 
You sure you did the basic steps with the proxies? For Capmonster to work, you need to strip them to ip: port and use IP authorization. Don't use proxies with passwords directly in Capmonster, from my experience they do not work that way.

Did you also check this?
gCyTAbL


Not sure how you set it up, but a workaround would be this:
- do the steps mentioned above, if you didn't.
- insert all your dedi proxies in Capmonster.
- put how many proxies you wish in RankerX (30,15, 10), according to your needs OR use a good VPN for RankerX, so the proxies will be assigned only for solving RV2.
- run a campaign again and see what happens.

40% success is very low, it should be around 70% (with a mix of banned ips or bad ips - bad ip is either the proxy or the website).

How many Recaptchas are being solved at the same time before you see the proxies are starting to get burned (banned)? Maybe you are building up a huge queue...


I did the ip:port setup however... that screenshot with the text on changing interval right about the checkbox... i don't have that... I do have that checkbox and it is enabled... i got capmonster version V2.10.16.1

with regards to the vpn that might be interesting idea, I got windscribe premium that would do the job I think ? just put it on VPN in your country to have fast VPN speed and use it for rankerx... would that not mess up the whole ip authentication process in capmonster when you run the vpn ? or do you mean run the VPN in the browser when rankerx is loaded at the localhost:8080 ?
 
"Update proxy from source" is not important in this case.

If you decide to use VPN, you need first to authorize the proxies via your new VPN ip. That might be a problem if the VPN automatically switches ips after a number of minutes. If not, there can be an additional problem if the VPN disconnects (usually it blocks the internet connection).

However, I haven't used Capmonster with RankerX. My setup works with GSA, but you really should have a much bigger success rate.

What is the main problem when solving? Bad Ip or Banned Ip? How many Recaptcha threads are running at the same time, usually?
 
"Update proxy from source" is not important in this case.

If you decide to use VPN, you need first to authorize the proxies via your new VPN ip. That might be a problem if the VPN automatically switches ips after a number of minutes. If not, there can be an additional problem if the VPN disconnects (usually it blocks the internet connection).

However, I haven't used Capmonster with RankerX. My setup works with GSA, but you really should have a much bigger success rate.

What is the main problem when solving? Bad Ip or Banned Ip? How many Recaptcha threads are running at the same time, usually?


So I put the thread on rankerx on 5. and loaded 30 dedicated proxies in both rankerx and capmonster. I started a new campaign and running it now... it started at 100% it is now slowly going down but this time due to bad ip. you know that stupid erro " timeout for loading element exceeded " . I am happy that the change of the way the proxies are loaded has seemingly reduced the amount of banned ip for some reason... do you also get heavy fluctuation in your graphs captchas/min or it stays stable with yours?

At the time of writing:
capmonsterscreen.png




Rankerx setting
rankerx setting.jpg


I can see now the issue with the banned ip has been reduced to zero which is great off course and thanks for that! but how would I reduce the bad ip part? I would guess increase the timeout overall ?

BTW my internet speed is around 100mb/s I would this is more than enough for this + regular internet stuff surfing
 
Last edited:
That fluctuation is simply the number of images processed. It's not important to watch it closely, unless your Capmonster threads are full.

More important in your case is to lower the "Banned Ip" to, let's say, 10% or less.

"Bad Ip" is because of proxy speed or the site has a problem in the Recaptcha code. I doubt that RankerX sites have broken Recaptcha codes.

So if you can't solve your problem with 30 proxies, you might be able to solve it with 60 proxies :D

Btw, there's a browser feature in Capmonster, don't remember where, but you can see the browser as the RV2 is solved. This will probably give you a better idea about "Bad Ip" error.
 
That fluctuation is simply the number of images processed. It's not important to watch it closely, unless your Capmonster threads are full.

More important in your case is to lower the "Banned Ip" to, let's say, 10% or less.

"Bad Ip" is because of proxy speed or the site has a problem in the Recaptcha code. I doubt that RankerX sites have broken Recaptcha codes.

So if you can't solve your problem with 30 proxies, you might be able to solve it with 60 proxies :D

Btw, there's a browser feature in Capmonster, don't remember where, but you can see the browser as the RV2 is solved. This will probably give you a better idea about "Bad Ip" error.


I can't seem to find that browser feature either, and not in their documentation also haha.

update for now;;;;;;

success rate is 56%
banned ip is 1%
bad ip is 41%

a huge improvement as before which is great thanks! but the bad ip still sits heavy on the stomach.
I asked buyproxies support on their advice...and they gave me a good and quite logical advice... increase the timeout lol.... most pages take more than 2 sec to load and take in calculation the proxy time and own internet and some delay.... might be best to have it on at least 2.5 seconds i think.

When i tested the proxies it varies between 0.6 and 1 sec. add the same delay for my own internet and then the loading of that site... then yes... you might get close to 3 seconds right
 
Back
Top