Youtube - Comment SPAM detection - How does it work?

[Vagr]

I'm doing youtube CPA. I write 2-4 quality manual (but similar) comments per day, on some popular videos in a certain niche and then send likes to them.

People are most likely reporting my comments quite a lot which then marks them as spam. So when I make another comment, it shows up on the newest comments but when I send likes to it, it never shows up on top comments, no matter how far down I scroll.

The problem is that now, no matter how I spin the comment, what changes I make, youtube always detects it as spam. It doesn't matter what account I use, if I use a link or not, they always detect it.

I was able to earn decent money doing this, last week hitting a personal record of $400. But now I'm unable to make any more comments which means no money.

So because of that I ask - Does anyone know and is willing to share, how the youtube comment SPAM detection works? Are there any ways to game it?

 

[B1TCS]

It's simple, this method got patched long time ago

 

[hieu230592]

$400/day from comment spamming? You might be the highest earner using this dead method lol.

 

[Vagr]

$400/day from comment spamming? You might be the highest earner using this dead method lol.

Nah, I wish. I meant $400 for the whole week.

 

[hieu230592]

Nah, I wish. I meant $400 for the whole week.

last time I tried this method few months ago, $15/day and so headache managing multi accounts. My upvote accounts got banned almost all. I quit.
For your problem, you can change the accounts, or buy multi channel account. I think it will be solved.

 

[Vagr]

last time I tried this method few months ago, $15/day and so headache managing multi accounts. My upvote accounts got banned almost all. I quit.
For your problem, you can change the accounts, or buy multi channel account. I think it will be solved.

I tried changing accounts multiple times but it seems that these comments are basically banned from showing up on top comments, no matter what account makes them.

Btw, I'm using an SMM panel for upvoting my comments, not my own accounts.

 

[lacifitra]

YouTube commenting isn't really dead, but it's barely worth it these days unless you're some kind of creative mastermind that can bypass their antispam system.

I tried changing accounts multiple times but it seems that these comments are basically banned from showing up on top comments, no matter what account makes them.

Btw, I'm using an SMM panel for upvoting my comments, not my own accounts.

Have you been shadowbanned? Did you use the same IP?
I'd advise you to look for a new method, you're probably on their list now anyway.

 

[dekadent30]

Their antispam system is very advanced, those who can beat it can make thousends

 

[Vagr]

YouTube commenting isn't really dead, but it's barely worth it these days unless you're some kind of creative mastermind that can bypass their antispam system.

Have you been shadowbanned? Did you use the same IP?
I'd advise you to look for a new method, you're probably on their list now anyway.

I use 1 IP for every account. I haven't been shadowbanned. When I make a normal comment on any of my accounts it shows up normally on top comments when upvoted. But when I make my call to action comment, even if I make pretty big changes, it doesn't show up on top comments.

 

[lacifitra]

I use 1 IP for every account. I haven't been shadowbanned. When I make a normal comment on any of my accounts it shows up normally on top comments when upvoted. But when I make my call to action comment, even if I make pretty big changes, it doesn't show up on top comments.

Change it up, then.
Seems like something about your call to action comment is fishy to YouTube's spam detection.

 

[Vagr]

Change it up, then.
Seems like something about your call to action comment is fishy to YouTube's spam detection.

I do change it up but there is only so many changes I can do until I completely butcher it and it will become useless. For now I managed to make a new comment that ranked but it's already less effective and it's only a matter of time until that one gets banned as well.

 

[adesinaabolaji]

It could be the domain you're using has been marked as spam. You might consider changing that

 

[sizz0]

Have you tried sending the traffic to a snapchat account or instagram account? From there you can direct the traffic to whatever website you want.

 

[Vagr]

It could be the domain you're using has been marked as spam. You might consider changing that

Have you tried sending the traffic to a snapchat account or instagram account? From there you can direct the traffic to whatever website you want.

I do most of my comments with a dead link meaning I write it like domain . com instead of domain.com. But still, even my live link works and is able to get to top comments as long as the rest of the comment is fine.

 

[Captain_Nothing]

YouTube will shadow ban domains names. Try to put in a random comment with a random url and send likes to it and see if it can rank.

 

[alexa_s]

I suggest you read this post. Youtube doesn't like spam. You have to leave legit comments that get naturally upvoted and they can't contain any sort of links, domains, or phrases like "just google it".

People saying the spam detection of youtube is so advanced and smart, when in fact any moron out there can design it. A Youtube account that has never watched more than 2 minutes total of videos leaving 5 comments a day, all containing links? Doesn't really take a state-of-the-art AI to figure that this is spam, does it?

 

[MaBank]

This method was patched a while ago by youtube surprised you have been able to keep this up for so long. After enough reports someone from youtube is bound to manual investigate these reports. Id say they finally caught on to call to action key words.

 

[adesinaabolaji]

Well, you may not exactly put your CTA in the comment. You might tell them to click on your profile where you have made a video video containing the call to action

 

[amalkan]

I saw several people using other and unusual characters and other fonts letters in order to avoid the spam filter