What is truly white hat?

I have a question, and I wrote it out the way I want but i couldn't post... lol, so i'll just bluntly say it, do big brand websites do black hat?

It depends.. some does but only a little. I have been doing SEO for a few big brand communications service providers so I can say many of them are doing blackhat. However, it depends on what you really mean because some of them pay for a few links here and there while some go out extreme blackhatting.

As for popular companies/people, most usually don't because they get natural links all the time. They just post a blog post and it will take care of itself.
 
To be honest, the only thing that is truly white hat is writing good content, not KW rich and not KW researched.... not very profitable :P
 
Any link building is search engine manipulation and therefore not whitehat! The only thing that is whitehat is building quality content on your website. Unfortunately if that is all you did, you're not going to get good search engine results.... hence the blackhat stuff
 
Interesting. Care to share what you did for link building?
 
why are you asking about white hat then asking about backlinks that are whitehat - backlinking purposely does not exist in whitehat anything to do with shortcuts or things done un-naturally are considered blackhat
 
I think the idea with writing content is your writing for people. Not for search engines.
 
According to Google all link building is black hat... You simply cannot rely upon their Guidelines. The only way you're going to rank your eCommerce site is with grey/black hat.

The only white hat thing you could really do is guest posting... This of course is extremely costly, difficult, and you can't count on people to keep up your links.

white hat is not an easy way :(
 
Everyone talks about getting "quality" links to their sites but what exactly does that mean?

I mean specifically for an ecomerce site in a high competition field what can you do that G will see as white hat link building?

I'm looking for a list of specifics, build quality links doesn't mean anything. It's pretty much impossible to get a link from an authority site(for one because they don't really exist in this field) and I'm left with web 2.0 blog style links, profile links, social bookmarks and forum posts... but ALL of that stuff is blackhat or at the very best case scenario grey hat.

Can anyone post a list of specific link types and ideas that they consider 100% white hat?

The reason I'm asking is that I am about to launch SEO services and while this sounds like a question a person in this field shouldn't be asking, I'm after some second opinions. Call me a pessimist but the moment anyone starts doing offpage SEO/link building, in my eyes it's against google guidelines as you're not actually supposed to build any links to your sites but rather "motivate" people to build "natural" links to you instead. In that sense the moment anyone builds any link to their site themselves it's grey/black hat...

I am quoting you just because I would like to refresh the subject to those who are reading and following this thread. I have not seen a single reply to your post that answered more than just the post title. You are sincerely asking for opinions on a matter that is quite significant in IM.

White hat = natural (or what Big G would consider the natural flow of traffic, visitor interaction, and linking over time).

Next question you asked was about what getting 'quality' links means. This just means to get as natural a link as possible from the most AUTHORITATIVE source possible. This link may be created in a Black Hat fashion, but if it looks entirely natural (how Big G will see it/crawl it), then it is a very white hat linking strategy (manual linking does not necessarily mean white hat and vice versa).

It is this statement that really bothers me though:

"It's pretty much impossible to get a link from an authority site(for one because they don't really exist in this field) and I'm left with web 2.0 blog style links, profile links, social bookmarks and forum posts... but ALL of that stuff is blackhat or at the very best case scenario grey hat".

If your Web 2.0, profile links, social bookmarks, forum posts, etc. look completely natural (whether it is created artificially AND comes from various IP's), then this is not black hat at all (in Big G's eye) cause nobody (your traffic or the search engine) won't know the difference (when disguised well).

Black hat methods are purely timesavers so you can focus on multiple campaigns. When used effectively, the best black hat methods 'mimic' those of white hatters. You already know this (just offering some advice...see below) as you have ranked many "sites" in the past.

Let me just clarify something from all of those fellow members following this thread:

Sites DO NOT RANK!! If you are trying to rank a "site", then you are wasting your time...instead,you should focus on how to best RANK EACH INDIVIDUAL PAGE of a site. This may come as to a surprise to some of you in IM, but it is true (If anyone would like to dispute this, I would be glad to point them to my sources). Each page ranks for several reasons and there are many formulas plus much speculation as to how this actually works.

When you are trying to target traffic in a particular niche (or in your case field) in attempts to get them to visit your PAGES, you simply are trying to outrank your competition for the specific keywords that are typed into a search box. Since you mentioned that you are involved in a highly competitive e-commerce niche, then this would be a prime opportunity for you to alter your linking strategy and marketing approach overall.

What I would suggest here (as I am successful in marketing for high-competition e-commerce niche markets myself) is to focus on making each particular page become as high ranking as possible. This may require (as it has in the past for me and let's just say Amazon Affiliate marketing) re-optimizing your individual pages, tags, and inbound linking anchor text (a huge boost for me since the last Panda update!).

I repeatedly compete in high competition niche markets for e-commerce where my 'review' pages outrank the companies I sell for. I also gather inbound links from the manufacturers in most cases. They are often quite receptive to my efforts as it aids them by strengthening their online presence. This is done as a reciprocal linking strategy that I arrange through e-mail correspondence with webmasters from that particular manufacturer.

I use similar strategy (very white hat btw) with many of my niche sites and not just my e-commerce ones.

You posted this thread to get answers to the questions that you asked and I am trying to do my best to provide you with the kind of information that you need to get yourself ranking well in the SERP's. I have presented a couple linking strategies that I use successfully and apologize that they are not in a list form like you asked.

I am a bit curious, as are several other readers of this thread I can see, what kinds of SEO services are you looking to offer? It looks as if you are referring to off-page SEO in particular.

You had also mentioned: "I have ranked every site i have worked on to page 1 and multiple #1 rankings. This is simply a post to get some ideas on making the process as clean and googleproof as possible". Were these ranking methods that you used to achieve these results 'dirty' to you?

I am just trying to offer my take on this matter as it is becoming more a an issue with marketers recently. Not too sure if it is guilt or ethics for some of us folks. Just remember....no matter how dirty it is, money is always green!

Good luck in your SEO venture and hope that this e-commerce site works out well for you!
 
Last edited:
My understanding is there are no formal definitions for "Black hat SEO" or "White hat SEO", but "White Hat" is defined as one who is admirable and honorable or for computer science purposes an ethical hacker.

Since the terms are open to interpretation, I would suggest that the following meanings from Webopedia represent the majority view:

What is White Hat SEO?

In search engine optimization (SEO) terminology, White Hat SEO refers to the usage of SEO strategies, techniques and tactics that focus on a human audience opposed to search engines and completely follows search engine rules and policies. For example, a Web site that is SEO optimized, yet focuses on relevancy and organic ranking is considered to be optimized using White Hat SEO practices. Some examples of White Hat SEO techniques include using keywords and keyword analysis, backlinking, link building to improve link popularity, and writing content for human readers White Hat SEO is more frequently used by those who intend to make a long-term investment on their Web site. Also called Ethical SEO.

What is Black Hat SEO?

In search engine optimization (SEO) terminology, Black Hat SEO refers to the use of aggressive SEO strategies, techniques and tactics that focus only on search engines and not a human audience, and usually does not obey search engines rules. Some examples of Black Hat SEO techniques include keyword stuffing, invisible text and doorway pages. Black Hat SEO is more frequently used by those who are looking for a quick financial return on their Web site, rather than a long-term investment on their Web site. Black Hat SEO can possibly result in your Web site being banned from a search engine, however since the focus is usually on quick high return business models, most experts who use Black Hat SEO tactics consider being banned from search engines a somewhat irrelevant risk. Black Hat SEO may also be referred to as Unethical SEO or just spamdexing, as spamdexing is a typical frequently used Black Hat SEO practice.
 
Wall of helpful text I'm quoting to show I'm replying to this post in particular

Thank you that must have taken a while to write :)

I understand the idea behind ranking pages and not sites. I just didn't use the correct terminology in this case it seems.

I have successfully ranked pages(including the homepage) on various domains for multiple keywords. To date i have approx 50 #1 rankings across varying low to high competition terms to my name across those pages.

I have mainly used senuke and on page as well as some blog commenting and some limited xrumer stuff.

I think you have reinforced my general opinion. White hat = looks natural but in reality it's all just an illusion.

I am a bit curious, as are several other readers of this thread I can see, what kinds of SEO services are you looking to offer? It looks as if you are referring to off-page SEO in particular.

I was refering to off-page as I already know my answer in regards to on-page and to be honest off page gets far better ROI once you move past the basics like making sure the page you're trying to rank isn't retarded.

The service I was going to offer was a simple $500/month for getting 10 keywords to page 1 within say 6-12 months kind of gig. Price dependant on keyword difficulty.

I was also going to look at offering google maps optimisation and reputation/ratings management.

During a client pitch the question will come up as to whether I'm white hat or black hat. I need to know how best to answer that question. I know I can get results. The question is how do I sell myself without sounding like the super squeeky clean whitehat douchebag and being a hypocrite at the same time whilst flat out lying to my clients. As most of them do.

I think a lot of whitehats think that manual = white hat, automated = black hat.
 
Back
Top