I'm new on this forum and this is my first post (after introduction) and I would like to share my experience about Freelancer.
My name is Mladen Djukic (same username on Freelancer too, also my real name), I'm from Belgrade, Serbia and I'm a graphic designer for last two and a half years. Since December 2010 I am registered on Freelancer. For almost two years everything was ok, 15 jobs completed, stayed in touch with few employers that I still work with today (out of Freelancer), payments on Freelancer were regular and on time...like i said everything seems to be fine...since two months ago.
At Saturday, November 17th 2012, I've won the contest on Freelancer (Logo design for iisoft, ID: 11325). Contest was guaranteed, prize was 490$. Same day when contest holder chosen me as a winner I have sent files to him, same day contest holder transferred money to my Freelancer account. Same day I've even withdrawn money to my debit card (status pending, for almost 24 hours)...suddenly tomorrow there was no any money on my account, my balance even was -40/50$, because of Freelancer's fee of 10%...after few emails they refunded 10%, but the rest of the prize, of course no.
So, what's happening?
Contest was deleted, as well as employer's profile. First step, contacting Freelancer support... Support suggested me that I should contact employer directly, which I did. He was suspicious (?) and they said that money is reversed to him. I've contacted him, he replied me back (which I didn't expect cause they told me that he is a fraud) surprised by Freelancer action and deleted account. Obviously, he's not a fraud...if it is, he wouldn't reply to my email...pretty simple and obvious. Is he or not, that I'll never know and that shouldn't be my concern...I don't know that person and I don't have anything with him, he didn't take money from my account, Freelancer is. So, Freelancer don't want to refund me, nor the employer (probably)...and I'll repeat, contest was GUARANTEED.
After tons of emails, tickets and complains I didn't get right answer nor my prize back. Freelancer's Support is a pure rubbish, they send copied texts from Terms & Conditions or something like that. Of course, no one from Freelancer will ever admit system failure (if it is failure, if not pure stealing).
Who knows, maybe that's the best thing that happened to me...after that I've started on other website and won 3 contest in 1 month, and earned almost 1000$.
Yes, Freelancer is a big scam, avoid them!