Reddit mass removing comment links today?

yowahoshi23 said:
What about the google redirect method, has anyone tried it yet? I am gonna have to wait until tomorrow so I can start spamming got a lot of my accounts banned today.
Click to expand...
how much do you pay for working accounts? buying accounts stopped working for me many months ago
 
Advertise on BHW
so far a few hours later my comments i upvoted + Link are still up. normally these would be down after 3 or so hours if it would be automatially removed. but i suspect the upvoting thing detection cuold take time or maybe its cause i didnt upvote these ones as aggressively
 
blackhatters1234 said:
no one has answered if all these commets that were removed over a 4 day span old comments were showing up in the spam queue on moderatuer queues? or were they totally absent and it was quietly removed without no one not even the mods of the subreddits knowing?
Click to expand...
They were 100% removed automatically. I had comments in unmoderated subreddits taken down. And most of the subreddits I targeted had very inactive moderators, no way they all started becoming useful moderators at once.

Going forward, I'm guessing we may end up in their mod queue.
 
starched said:
They were 100% removed automatically. I had comments in unmoderated subreddits taken down. And most of the subreddits I targeted had very inactive moderators, no way they all started becoming useful moderators at once.

Going forward, I'm guessing we may end up in their mod queue.
Click to expand...
doesnt have anything to do with active mods or not cause generally commetns viewed as spammy are removed by reddit FIRST AND then show up inthe spam modque(so if the mod never looks it STAYS REMOVED). so the question is were those mass comments old ones removed showing up in anyons mod queues with a 10 year backlog lol or are the mods totally in the dark on what happened behind the scenes?
 
guys reddit is probably watching this thread so be careful of telling too much (im already guilty) but if we find a solution lets not say more.
i doubt they will ban google so i dont care about that one
 
people here are doing twitter. anyones twitter comments get removed in teh 4 day removathon? That would be telling it would mean upvoting algorthsm was enough to override even if you used twitter links
 
blackhatters1234 said:
doesnt have anything to do with active mods or not cause generally commetns viewed as spammy are removed by reddit FIRST AND then show up inthe spam modque(so if the mod never looks it STAYS REMOVED). so the question is were those mass comments old ones removed showing up in anyons mod queues with a 10 year backlog lol or are the mods totally in the dark on what happened behind the scenes?
Click to expand...
@KamBhai any insight on this with all your subreddits? I think the mods are completely in the dark on what just happened. I saw an Admin say there would be a spam update ~1 mo ago in one of my mod mail things. But I thought it was about the automod, no mention of retroactive or anything like that.

blackhatters1234 said:
guys reddit is probably watching this thread so be careful of telling too much (im already guilty) but if we find a solution lets not say more.
i doubt they will ban google so i dont care about that one
Click to expand...
Agreed, DMs are open for sharing as well :)

edit:
blackhatters1234, you should consolidate your messages into 1 instead of a bunch back to back. Copy text, quote, insert quote. Your one liners blowing up my shit lol
 
starched said:
@KamBhai any insight on this with all your subreddits? I think the mods are completely in the dark on what just happened. I saw an Admin say there would be a spam update ~1 mo ago in one of my mod mail things. But I thought it was about the automod, no mention of retroactive or anything like that.


Agreed, DMs are open for sharing as well :)

edit:
blackhatters1234, you should consolidate your messages into 1 instead of a bunch back to back. Copy text, quote, insert quote. Your one liners blowing up my shit lol
Click to expand...
i have subreddits but how do you get a mod mail (im not into the subreddit thing as much as some of you guys)? can you copy hte message? have you see a mention like this before in the mod mail or was it unusual for them ot mention a spam update coming?
 
blackhatters1234 said:
i have subreddits but how do you get a mod mail (im not into the subreddit thing as much as some of you guys)? can you copy hte message? have you see a mention like this before in the mod mail or was it unusual for them ot mention a spam update coming?
Click to expand...
I will look for it. It might have been an Admin's account answering questions, not necessarily inside modmail. I'll get back to you
 
Some of my old comments with links still stay, so I tested sending some small upvotes (8-10) to these comments and after 2 days they are still there.

I also bought small upvotes to new comments without link, they’re still there after 24 hours.

Only got one subreddit probably autobanned me, I posted 2 comments without links to this subreddit using 2 different aged accounts, high karma, different proxies, but both comments removed immediately after posting. 1 account even get permanent banned from this subreddit even though I didn’t do any shady things in this sub yet.

I have yet to try the google redirect idea. Will try and report back
 
jenny255 said:
Some of my old comments with links still stay, so I tested sending some small upvotes (8-10) to these comments and after 2 days they are still there.

I also bought small upvotes to new comments without link, they’re still there after 24 hours.

Only got one subreddit probably autobanned me, I posted 2 comments without links to this subreddit using 2 different aged accounts, high karma, different proxies, but both comments removed immediately after posting. 1 account even get permanent banned from this subreddit even though I didn’t do any shady things in this sub yet.

I have yet to try the google redirect idea. Will try and report back
Click to expand...
yeah ive sent some upvotes to some comments with links and without and so far no removals whether small or big amounts of upvotes

my worry though is the voting thing takes time to show up cause its observing you or more complex calculations

so for now im gonna assume upvoting is mostly taboo
 
if links get hard to do completely (Like any link) then i guess hte last resort would be to do subreddit links or text urls (domain) without clickable

pointing to subreddits though can often get your atual subreddit banned

i wonder what percentage would ultimately opoen your link though in those 2 forms

id imagine n moible they are less likely to open a text url
 
blackhatters1234 said:
if links get hard to do completely (Like any link) then i guess hte last resort would be to do subreddit links or text urls (domain) without clickable

pointing to subreddits though can often get your atual subreddit banned

i wonder what percentage would ultimately opoen your link though in those 2 forms

id imagine n moible they are less likely to open a text url
Click to expand...
Another form is to put the link in your profile description. I will comment without link, and then ask people to check out my profile for more resources on the subject. I use something like link in bio and add few links inside there. The downside is you can only promote very limited links. If you want to promote more links, then use different account.

So far I have about 3 comments to directly ask people check out my profile, and have total 120 clicks last 3 days according to the link tracker. However, when I check GA4, the visit from Reddit is less than what link tracker show. In GA4 only show 70 sessions from Reddit last 3 days.

I also try to write helpful comments without asking people checking my profile, in the hope that they will find it helpful and check my profile out. This also help to make the account looks less spammy by actually providing value.
 
jenny255 said:
Another form is to put the link in your profile description. I will comment without link, and then ask people to check out my profile for more resources on the subject. I use something like link in bio and add few links inside there. The downside is you can only promote very limited links. If you want to promote more links, then use different account.

So far I have about 3 comments to directly ask people check out my profile, and have total 120 clicks last 3 days according to the link tracker. However, when I check GA4, the visit from Reddit is less than what link tracker show. In GA4 only show 70 sessions from Reddit last 3 days.

I also try to write helpful comments without asking people checking my profile, in the hope that they will find it helpful and check my profile out. This also help to make the account looks less spammy by actually providing value.
Click to expand...
ive seen other people do similiar method but they dont do the profile angle they just link to youtube, blogs, subreddits, direct domain, etc but they mix it all up so not one specific type of way all in one account so it doesnt look as spammy

120 clicks is alot for such few comments but i dont know what you wuold normally get in a direct aproach.

that would get around the subreddit ban issue but i wonder if the click rate to the actual site would be higher then a non clickable domain mention? if i had ot guess the profile idea might be the worst converting of all the few ideas i gave as alternates. maybe only the youtube idea would be worse cause i suspect most are not gonna look at a youtube video and if they did wont bother to look and actually click at the video description where you can drop a url i think mostwould just exit once they see the youtube video is pointless lol

direct to a subreddt post could onvert cause it tricks peopel into clicking and then they may just wind up clicking on whathever shows in the instead of closing the window
 
moonshine7000 said:
Youtube tutorials on Reddit on how to spam Reddit is what compounded the problem for people to notice.The Youtube channel owner is making most of the money selling the shovels like Reddit accounts,upvotes and proxies
Click to expand...

Now this is something!
 
The only thing I didn’t try today was making likes on aged, maybe I’ll wait a week or something like that, I waited a day for some accounts, but it didn’t help, they are still deleted after upvote, regardless of the speed of the service, maybe it’s worth waiting a week if someone will find a loophole and maybe share the information, but I don’t think so)
 
Jumandji said:
The only thing I didn’t try today was making likes on aged, maybe I’ll wait a week or something like that, I waited a day for some accounts, but it didn’t help, they are still deleted after upvote, regardless of the speed of the service, maybe it’s worth waiting a week if someone will find a loophole and maybe share the information, but I don’t think so)
Click to expand...
Im not gonna be sharing any more secrets (if i even have any plausible deniability) publicly every man for himself cause i think at this point maybe we should not share anymore cause reddit and google guaranteed are watching and the minute someone drops a tip here they will inrease the intensity of the filters and any hope we had will be over so every man for himself at this point. I almost regret making this thread now cause i know reddit is reading this lol. better to figure out the nitty gritty details on your own in secret or else your just gonna screw yourself over the minute you share. we got the jist of whats going on no need for reddit to make it harder by finding out we know or getting close to knowing all the loopholes
 
Last edited:
blackhatters1234 said:
Im not gonna be sharing any more secrets (if i even have any plausible deniability) publicly every man for himself cause i think at this point maybe we should not share anymore cause reddit and google guaranteed are watching and the minute someone drops a tip here they will inrease the intensity of the filters and any hope we had will be over so every man for himself at this point. I almost regret making this thread now cause i know reddit is reading this lol. better to figure out the nitty gritty details on your own in secret or else your just gonna screw yourself over the minute you share. we got the jist of whats going on no need for reddit to make it harder by finding out we know or getting close to knowing all the loopholes
Click to expand...

You are absolutely right, people revealing secrets got so many new guys spamming thus making Reddit increase the spam detection. This thread should be locked.
 
blackhatters1234 said:
people here are doing Twitter. anyones Twitter comments get removed in the 4-day renovation? That would be saying it would mean the upvoting algorithm was enough to override even if you used Twitter links
Click to expand...
I am using Twitter. So just did research, some of the comments are still there, and some have been removed( all of my comments with upvotes) Made some new comments with Twitter links, and all comments with upvotes got removed, but those which was not upvoted are still there. Very interesting, so far hard to understand whats excatly works and what not
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top