I actually haven't read all of the thread, just the main bits which had a lot of thanks! But here are my points, not that they would be of importance but just my opinions..
1) OP was offering a SEO service, and regardless of the fact of whether it worked or not - he got the BST approved in a so what unethical way. Making multiple accounts and faking reviews alone should count as a perma-bannable offence. You are really lucky you are still here!
2) BassTrackerBoats - you are a gentlemen. Always have respected you, and always will!
3) BK071 - Nice screenshots of your point. Nice!
4) BB - Great way to handle this. If I was a Mod, I would have banned this guy ages ago, simply for the multiple accounts. There are people who have been rejected from BST's before (including me) and its just annoying to see someone fake their way through.
5) Portugal, no matter how effective your service is - you deserve to be banned IMHO. You have fake reviews and ultimately multiple accounts.
6) Lastly, when your service was up, I actually honestly thought it was too over rated and priced. No offence and this is just my opinion. I then PM'ed you I think asking regarding articles and keywords and you said that your service works well that way. With 2 keywords as max, I don't see that as being good. Hell yeah, it might work for the short term but when the next major update rolls out, you're fucked.
Lastly, you don't learn SEO in a few weeks, or months. It's something which requires consistent knowledge, patience and tons of testing. Just my few cents. It took me years of work, testing, mistakes, $$$$ loss before I got to where I am now!
EDIT - Just removed my sig.
EDIT 2 - PORTUGAL, IT'S NOT ABOUT THE SERVICE. IT DOESN'T MATTER IF YOUR SERVICE IS THE BEST SEO SERVICE ON THIS FORUM. THE FACT THAT YOU MADE MULTIPLE ACCOUNTS AND HAD FAKE REVIEWS IS A VERY EASILY PERMA-BANNABLE OFFENCE.