-
Please take a moment to look over the Suggestions & Feedback rules before making a post: READ RULES HERE
No more Jr Execs??
- Thread starter KraftyKyle
- Start date
- Status
- Nov 2, 2008
- 59,090
- 26,636
just an observation - Kyles / Batts post of no notice / reason reminds me of recent mods who where let go
and some also commented they were not even told they where being let go or why or no thanks
for there time served, i guess bhw is having communication issues in some areas .
but its odd they let 2 execs go who are around often - but keep some execs who are hardly here
but dropped by to vote 2 active members out. clicks will be clicks.
Last edited:
- Jan 16, 2017
- 5,074
- 10,327
How many non-Jr. Execs have been promoted to this status in, let’s say, the past twelve months?
Indeed, no added benefits, other than a shiny username and more appealing forum presence, is to be bestowed upon those most fortunate to attain the status through a vote made by those already holding the title.
I believe the number of promotions have been very little, and hopefully, such votes can take place on a community-wide basis instead of such fate being dictated by the hands of a select few that can only initiate votes at their time of choosing, which does not seem to be much (perhaps wrongfully assumably, to keep the number of such title holders to a minimum, effectively making their status a more coveted one and as such, boosting their forum rep even more).
All that said, a new status system is needed, and the current, revamped, so that such titles of recognition are not only easier to attain but so members are more compelled to make contributions to the community, which I must admit, would be refreshing to see around here.
Thank you to the MODs and team leading the changes that are taking place, I speak for a good majority of us when I say your efforts do not go unnoticed.
Indeed, no added benefits, other than a shiny username and more appealing forum presence, is to be bestowed upon those most fortunate to attain the status through a vote made by those already holding the title.
I believe the number of promotions have been very little, and hopefully, such votes can take place on a community-wide basis instead of such fate being dictated by the hands of a select few that can only initiate votes at their time of choosing, which does not seem to be much (perhaps wrongfully assumably, to keep the number of such title holders to a minimum, effectively making their status a more coveted one and as such, boosting their forum rep even more).
All that said, a new status system is needed, and the current, revamped, so that such titles of recognition are not only easier to attain but so members are more compelled to make contributions to the community, which I must admit, would be refreshing to see around here.
Thank you to the MODs and team leading the changes that are taking place, I speak for a good majority of us when I say your efforts do not go unnoticed.
Zwielicht
Elite Member
- Aug 31, 2013
- 21,128
- 40,602
I like the idea of the community voting members into Jr. Exec. Maybe make it a monthly event.
The new formula has already been created, it just needs to go through approval, but it would be interesting to see who would get suggested by the community to become a Jr. Exec. Maybe the ability to vote on Jr. Execs can be a Jr. VIP benefit as well. There's a lot to consider there.
Nice suggestion, @ContentExpert!
- Oct 6, 2020
- 2,626
- 9,932
bhw is like crypto, you invest only what you are ready to lose
- Nov 2, 2008
- 59,090
- 26,636
Code:
All that said, a new status system is neededtheres a simple system - you contribute within a certain group then you
retain the rank upgrade, if you post twice a year, the free upgrade gets removed.
its pretty simple, if you dumping members from a group who are active while
retaining people posting 3 times a year, then that rank in itself becomes a joke
where they stick together to vote out hard workers while they retain there group
position and contribute little
Castamir
BANNED
- Sep 4, 2019
- 1,200
- 1,058
At this point, BHW needs an algorithm that ranks members and not based on human inputs which can be biased.
For example, it can be a simple rule that if you get featured in newsletters 50 times or an 5 execs like your post or you get pinned 50 times, you become a junior exec.
For example, it can be a simple rule that if you get featured in newsletters 50 times or an 5 execs like your post or you get pinned 50 times, you become a junior exec.
Zwielicht
Elite Member
- Aug 31, 2013
- 21,128
- 40,602
That is exactly what the formula I was working on is for!
Society Girl
Elite Member
- Feb 20, 2014
- 3,164
- 2,627
Will be abused as mentioned previously (if it was made public). We know you guys are
Moving this thread to Suggestions and Feedback.
- Dec 3, 2015
- 5,318
- 6,022
I feel xoxo offended. (jkin)
There are quite a few moderators that got demoted months ago with no much drama, It's just business no much hard feelings. Since not bonded by law. Moreover, businesses change hands and new owners could come with best practices that deem fit.
Castamir
BANNED
- Sep 4, 2019
- 1,200
- 1,058
That's great to know. I know @bartosimpsonio will easily be above the threshold of the values of BHW algo.That is exactly what the formula I was working on is for!
soa0611
Elite Member
- Apr 20, 2015
- 2,790
- 2,542
in my humble opinion , some other members more deserve to be even Exec VIP but they don't cry
for example, @Rachmaninoff
for example, @Rachmaninoff
- Dec 3, 2015
- 5,318
- 6,022
But then he's not been active, That's one big factor the mods are considering.
KlaudiaK
Banned - selling outside of the marketplace.
- Jul 26, 2019
- 421
- 320
I think it was his ego that took a hit hahaha. I laughed at I have nearly 7000 likes.... So insecure.
- Mar 30, 2018
- 12,091
- 14,356
@Zwielicht if you ask the community to vote then besides these two, I would nominate @proxygo while he doesnt wish to be a mod he at least deserves this, second person @bartosimpsonio for his witty threads,
and if it’s only seo based then these 2 @tiiberius @splishsplash or better loved by newbies and pros Mr Positive
moral of the story we will create posts for favourites users which will again be disagreed and so on.I like the idea of community voting but honestly I feel it’ll gamed unless only Jr Vips with over 1000 posts and 200 likes can vote this will be harsh on other members but only way to prevent it from gaming
but as usual I’ll leave this headache to you and other mods unless you intent to give all review copies you get for a year I’m going to stop more suggestions lol.
Sardi
Power Member
- Oct 25, 2019
- 692
- 2,416
I like this, Jr.Vips are more seasoned members and can better judge who earned that title.
There are some legends here that are not Jr.Vip currently but maybe have been in the past... I am just saying that leaving this to the jr.vips is a better option because it narrows the pool down a bit or you can let all the forum vote but this needs some kind of limitation, like a post limitation or how old your account similar to jr VIP ...
KlaudiaK
Banned - selling outside of the marketplace.
- Jul 26, 2019
- 421
- 320
It's quite simple, if they have lost there jr exec titles then the team have spoken. What I don't like is that if you are jr exec and lost status why create a thread ? That too me is just to loud and demotion should be taken on the chin like a man not cteati a thread telling everyone you had 7000 likes.
I'm not been funny but jr exec is privilege. Just because we create witty threads, has no way or impact on who should get promoted IMO tbh.@Zwielicht if you ask the community to vote then besides these two, I would nominate @proxygo while he doesnt wish to be a mod he at least deserves this, second person @bartosimpsonio for his witty threads,
and if it’s only seo based then these 2 @tiiberius @splishsplash or better loved by newbies and pros Mr Positive
I like the idea of community voting but honestly I feel it’ll gamed unless only Jr Vips with over 1000 posts and 200 likes can vote this will be harsh on other members but only way to prevent it from gaming
but as usual I’ll leave this headache to you and other mods unless you intent to give all review copies you get for a year I’m going to stop more suggestions lol.
A dude who signed up yesterday could be the funniest guy you ever met, does not mean they should get promo ?
I think promo should be based on activity, quality of content and shares, etc. Not just because some guy is "witty"
Bhw does not need an "algo" it just need people to behave like adults and accept change. Some people don't like change. Simple as that. Algos can be manipulated and last thing we want is more games been played.
D
Deleted member 1333509
Guest
Solid suggestion and articulately put, would make the process a community-wide thing which could only be beneficial for all involved.
- Status