As often is the case with shitlists, I find fault on both sides. Macdonjo3, you did specify in your thread that the domains were indexed - and the 2 provided were not. yes, I realize that once they are registered, they can be reindexed quickly once they are registered.
Hoodbot, you assumed alot when you ordered. You obviously didn't read the full BST before you ordered based on what I saw in the skype log. You didn't ask for any clarification of anything you weren't sure about and placed your order. Then for a reason I still can't figure you, you posted one of the 2 domains on here in public view. Why do you think that I sent you the log URL via PM so you could verify it? It wasn't so you could out one of the two domains by posting it here. In addition, you had a very rude and abrasive attitude, but lucky for you that I don't make judgments purely on that.
Overall, Macdonjo3 provided you what he advertised with the exception that the domains were not currently indexed (which you only realized was mentioned in the thread when someone else posted it).
The way I see it, this isn't even a 50/50 issue... especially after you outed the domain. So in my judgement, he should refund you $25 of the payment, and that's it.
Drop the dispute and he will have to refund you the $25.
OS
PS. You asked for the niche that you asked for and he provided the domains within that niche. You aren't going to get exact match to a very narrow niche so the domains you received were within the broad niche you provided. If you feel that there was an isssue with one or both of the domains, you work it out with the seller. You don't become rude and start cursing at him. At this point, if you still feel you have a good reason to change one or more of the domains, then work it out with macdonjo3 - and you can begin by being civil when you chat with him.