theconscience
Regular Member
- May 16, 2014
- 311
- 30
Comic is like Beano Or Dundee?
During a review of your KDP submission, we found content in your book that is freely available on the web. Before we can publish your book, you need to take one of the following actions within five days:
1. If you hold the publishing rights for all of the content in this book, resubmit your book for publishing following the instructions provided below.
2. If the book is in the public domain, please confirm the initial publication date of the work and the author?s date of death. We will contact you if we need additional information.
3. If you do not hold rights for all of the content in this book, please remove the book following the instructions provided below.
If you publish books for which you do not hold the electronic publishing rights, we may terminate your account or you may lose access to optional KDP services.
I received an email from Amazon stating the following:
I decided to be on the safe side and unpublish the book for now.
Has anyone experienced this?
Since we are talking about recipes does anyone actually own the rights to them?
You cannot copyright a recipe, but if you have simply gone around the web and collected them Amazon probably is not that interested in publishing the collection as it is freely available in the public domain.
I understand that and I'm not trying to trick Amazon. I did find the recipes online, but I improved them.
I added nutritional information at the ingredient level and included UK and US names for the ingredients. So, it wasn't an easy copy/paste job.
To my understanding after doing all that, if I go ahead and completely rewrite the directions, it is my practically my version of the recipes. Am I missing something?
I just wonder, did anyone else publish recipe books? What was the procedure you followed to avoid this issue?
You misunderstand something about Kindle they don't have to publish your books if they don't want to. It doesn't matter legally how you created it.
If you have created a book that is in a category that is saturated and they don't feel it adds value they will just not publish it, this is particularly the case with public domain works. Recipes frequently fall into this category.
However you changed it they have clearly found that the core content is "freely available on the web", as that is what they are telling you. And you are stating that is actually correct.
So you will have to remove it option 3.
If you got the recipes from 1 or 2 public domain books, you will have to tell them which it is and pick option 2 or you can lie and pick option 1!
But if you pick options 1 or 2, chances are you will get a follow up email where they say after reviewing your book they have decided not to publish it.
If you lie and then they find out they will give you a warning. You get 1 warning, do it again and they close your account.
Personally I would learn a lesson and create a better quality book, as chances are this one is not going to sell that well anyway. I doubt you have made the recipes and taken nice pictures of them all, else you would not be getting that message.
Thanks for the insight.
You are right. I didn't really take into account that Amazon might not want to publish a book for their own reasons. If I knew that, I probably wouldn't have gone with a recipe book at this point.
I may properly edit and reupload the book in the future, but I don't think it's worth it right now. And I definitely don't want a banned account, so I'll just stick with the 3rd option.