I’m about to start a new channel. Should I pay for a voice actor or just use ElevenLabs?

I’ve heard YT is demonetizing "robotic" content—anyone have a channel that’s still monetized with AI?
If it too obvious, it will drive less traffic.

As long as it sounds quite realistic, people don't mind.
 
i don't hate it, as long as they listenable i am okay with that
 
most viewers don’t hate ai voices - they hate bad AI voices

if it sounds robotic, flat, wrong pacing, weird emphasis, people click off fast
 
I have subbed to so many AI audios and if the content is great and has great audio I just go with it. I'm coming to like audio books and some philosophy videos.
 
That depends. If the AI voice over sounds too artificial or overly polished users can easily tell it’s not real. But if you can make it sound natural and believable then you’re good to go.
Natural delivery is definitely the goal. Has anyone here moved away from Text-to-Speech and started using Speech-to-Speech? I’ve been recording a rough 'junk' take on my phone and letting ElevenLabs skin it. It keeps my natural pacing/breathing but uses a pro-level voice.
 
if its a tutorial video, people usually just tolerate it if you are actually giving good info
 
Eleven Labs has voices that are indistinguishable from real ones. Most people dislike voices that are made on old neural networks.
 
Me personally not really, I hate it's so noisy but there is some good voices
 
I think AI voices can still work, especially for faceless channels, but engagement usually depends more on content quality and storytelling than the voice itself. Are you planning to add original commentary or just narration, and have you seen monetized channels in your niche using AI successfully?
 
AI voices are still not realistic, they always miss punctuation and pauses, it's still one of the AI weak spots that gives AI videos away
 
AI voices are still not realistic, they always miss punctuation and pauses, it's still one of the AI weak spots that gives AI videos away
 
Plenty of monetized channels use AI voices—what YouTube cares about is value, not whether you used YouTube automation. Low-effort, repetitive content gets flagged, not simply AI narration. ElevenLabs sounds natural if you tweak pacing and emotion. If budget’s tight, start with AI, focus on strong scripting and editing, then upgrade to a voice actor once revenue justifies it.
 
Back
Top