Since a few people mentioned
SpeedyIndex is down (and Indexing Expert is hit or miss lately), here is what’s actually moving the needle for me right now:
- For Speed: GIGA Indexer has been solid. About 80% success rate and cheap to test (~$15).
- For Volume: Indexceptional if you're running heavy campaigns and need a reliable API.
- For Retention: UltimateIndexing. It’s not instant (takes ~6 hours), but the 90-day "stickiness" is the best I've seen.
The "Real Talk" takeaway: Don't put all your eggs in one basket. I’ve switched to a
50/50 hybrid approach: 50% low-OBL blog comments (as the study suggests) and 50% paid indexers.
Also, if you have a bit of technical skill, the
GSC API is a life-saver for money pages. It’s free, takes 2 hours to script in Python, and gets you 200 URLs a day with zero risk.
I’ve managed to cut my indexing budget from $500 to under $200 just by using this mix. Stop waiting for SpeedyIndex to fix their servers and just pivot.