Most are just fairly boring to read and wouldn't capture this particular audience whatsoever. A gaming PC is a PC built for gaming. It has higher end cooling capabilities... Yawn..
Yeah, that's so true. As a gaming fan myself, it was painful to read some of the best articles.
As one of those who wrote for this project, I have to disagree strongly.
The supplied topic was the most generic subject possible - and in my experience, "What is a ---" is
not aimed at knowledgeable "fans" of a subject.
"What is a ---" is a basic informational topic aimed at newbies.
Additionally, the order did not specify a "particular audience," nor did it say "please go wild" or "please use your creativity." The audience and approach, though, could be pretty clearly assumed from the order.
Yes, anyone who is a gaming fan
knows that a gaming machine has a higher-end GPU and higher-end cooling capabilities.
But someone asking "What is a gaming computer" does
not - so that is essential information which would form the basis of an article with this subject.
I've written numerous review articles on gaming machines, both for different price levels and for specific different types of gamers.
That's not what this assignment was. Discussing (for instance) the specific overclocking capabilities of various GPUs in a 500 word article for newbies would be quickly jumping into information that was way over a newbie's head.
For anyone who's considering ordering content from any provider, I believe there are some lessons here.
1. If there's a specific audience the piece is aimed at, or knowledge base a reader is expected to have - let the writer know.
Otherwise, the writer will gauge the audience and knowledge base from the subject/title.
2. If you want clever, edgy or any other writing style - JUST ASK. It's much more likely that a smart-ass or click-bait style will offend more clients than it delights. "What is a ---" is a subject that would generally call for a matter-of-fact article, not something that would be written for Saturday Night Live or a smarmy blog. The latter are valid approaches to this or any other subject; just don't assume you're going to get them and don't be disappointed if you don't.
I haven't read the other articles (I'm the writer who had surgery today and shouldn't even be at the computer right now), but if the high-priced articles all seemed basic and "boring," there is a good reason for that. Good writers judge the target audience and desired style from the information they're provided. They're not mind readers; they're professionals. They're going to properly explain a topic, perhaps with a little personality included, and cover the important facts - unless something different is requested.
This was a great idea for a project and a lot of work was put into it. I'm pleased to have been included.
And I'm grateful that OP put in all of this effort. It was a valuable service.
I just felt it was necessary to mention a few things people should consider, for the sake of completeness.