2 Indexing Services - Case Study

[innosoft]

Is there a better link indexer than fake Google+ accounts?

Follow the thread.. Ull find it eventually..

 

[diesel1]

.

How many links are you going to add to each indexing service?

 

[mindmaster]

.

How many links are you going to add to each indexing service?

At least a few hundreds. Will depend on link type.
Will have to settle on type of links (probably same platform or same website).

Do you have suggestions?

 

[The SEO]

I've paid accounts with lindexed, onehourindexing and link huggers, let me know if you wanna use any of them as in your case study.

 

[zoewarrior]

P.S. I used to create about 200 backlinks a week per keyword, that would get me to 3rd or 4th serp page. Now I create 5-10 quality links which get me to 2nd page within a week ( plus some social 'sharing' too) with another 10, 15 or even 20 I'll get to 1st page of serp. The only problem that I need to solve now is to find some else for quality backlinks as I don't want to have all of them pointing into one direction. Although they are well diversified, worked well in the past and survived the 2014 penguin update I still think that having more diversity is better than less.

Can you define or elaborate your "quality links"?

 

[mindmaster]

Quick update after 72 hours after submission.

Speed-links - 42 indexed out of 58 submitted
InstantLinkIndexer - 17 indexed out of 58 submitted

 

[deedee1whoa]

It's awesome how BHW members are joining into this case study & want to help make it even more useful! Really wonderful.

 

[alextexan]

hi, i have subscription for Express Indexer , Backlinksindexer and lindexed . Let me know how can i help you with your case study . Btw , what kind of backlinks have you used for this test ? web 2.0 ? blog comments, profiles ?

regards

 

[mindmaster]

hi, i have subscription for Express Indexer , Backlinksindexer and lindexed . Let me know how can i help you with your case study . Btw , what kind of backlinks have you used for this test ? web 2.0 ? blog comments, profiles ?

regards

Great. Noted. Sent you PM.
I used web2.0's on same platform with same content (mostly pictures) for this first test.


Will wait a couple more days in case others want to join in.

Until them let me know if you have suggestions for the future case study (link types, platforms, etc).

 

[thejesus]

I have a subscription to Incredible Indexer and Instant Link Indexer and I would be willing to submit links to help this case study.

 

[thanhclix]

Is Speed-links URL Speed-links.net?

 

[mindmaster]

Is Speed-links URL Speed-links.net?

yes it is thanhclix.

 

[sharleneHJ]

Good case study. I would like more indexers tested too. Instant indexers seem to have a time limit beyond which no chance whereas others seem to work better given time.

 

[bahus]

Can you define or elaborate your "quality links"?

Basically they are home page blog posts on self hosted websites with good metrics. I used to do inner paged posts but they weren't as powerful as home page. It cost me a bit more, but well worth the price. Occasionally I do posts on free websites like wordpress to diversify my anchor text, but they must be at least 1 year old with quality articles/posts. That's it. I don't do wiki's, article directories, profiles links and what not.

 

[alextexan]

I submitted different kind of backlinks in Google Fetch and Google URL Submit ,they were succesfully indexed but without any SERP improvement. So indexing the backlinks with google tools seems to be useless for rankings (at leat in my case). When i used a paid indexing service i had good results in SERP as well. From what i know, google use different crawling bots when indexing pages.

mindmaster, would be great if you can track the SERP as well so we can make a detailed comparison between those indexing services

 

[mindmaster]

I submitted different kind of backlinks in Google Fetch and Google URL Submit ,they were succesfully indexed but without any SERP improvement. So indexing the backlinks with google tools seems to be useless for rankings (at leat in my case). When i used a paid indexing service i had good results in SERP as well. From what i know, google use different crawling bots when indexing pages.

mindmaster, would be great if you can track the SERP as well so we can make a detailed comparison between those indexing services

Good idea, but that would transform the case study into a complex one.
You would need not only same/similar links, but same/similar websites (targets) and keywords.
For now we will stick to measure indexing rate of different services.

 

[mindmaster]

Here is an update after 106 hours after submission:
speed-link - 52 indexed out of 58
instantlinkindexer - 20 indexed out of 58

Here is the second test between this 2 services. This time I submitted 100 links on each service.
Results after 4 days:
speed-links - 90 indexed out of 100
instantlinkindexer - 17 indexed out of 100

I think I can call it a day when it comes comparing this 2 services.

Stay tuned for the next case study.

Thanks to several members we will test 9 indexing services and publish the results on bhw.

 

[ultimateranker]

i think results will remain inconsistent will different indexers

 

[American Trends]

Really, great work buddy. I am curious to see the results before buying any new service.

 

[onlineonly]

Interesting. And thanks for sharing...