Scrapebox works fine but use it properly,are you filtering out low PR links,checking for AA only by running the lists on test sites then immediately using the high pr found links so they are fresh,doesn't sound like you are because your trust/citation would increase.You must pepper inner pages as well.Indeed create web 2 with only inner page links.
2 tools I need scrapebox and ultimate demon.
I could go on but you need get the basics first.
I am not new btw I lost my password and the email used got deleted.Anyway good luck with it.