The End of PAA (people also ask) automated sites is here, seems like google manually push them down

Mr. Grinder

Mr. Grinder

Failed to resolve a dispute resolution thread.
Joined
Jul 29, 2017
Messages
1,058
Reaction score
688
I started a PAA site in January in this year, thats not doing good anymore, indexed almost 200k links, getting like 1k, 2k click but suddenly it dropped to 20 click,

and like me, those big boys also dropped :D. but literally to say, the amount of money they made, they can live their whole entire life.

this is why i advise everyone is that just walk under the radar. they are gaining almost million of traffic, but what? if they locked their site like 200k traffic per month and create 10x more site. idk thats the other things. but they already banked hard :suspicious:

Screenshot_2.png

Screenshot_3.png

Screenshot_4.png

Screenshot_6.png

Screenshot_7.png

Screenshot_8.png
 
Advertise on BHW
If you got all questions in your subheadings it's a big big red flag.
Convert questions to simple headings.
What is x
To
x
And
Do not scrap content thats duplicate content. No matter how good you spin it.
Use an ai writer instead.
 
Yup alot of such sites went down.but I have list of other 50 or so site that are still doing good. Let's see what's their status be after couple of months
 
IM Rider said:
If you got all questions in your subheadings it's a big big red flag.
Convert questions to simple headings.
What is x
To
x
And
Do not scrap content thats duplicate content. No matter how good you spin it.
Use an ai writer instead.
Click to expand...

But how is that good?
Isn't it just logical to use questions in the H2/H3? Because any question is also a keyword.
 
RealDaddy said:
But how is that good?
Isn't it just logical to use questions in the H2/H3? Because any question is also a keyword.
Click to expand...
No it's not a blog is not a series of questions. It just not.
 
IM Rider said:
If you got all questions in your subheadings it's a big big red flag.
Convert questions to simple headings.
What is x
To
x
And
Do not scrap content thats duplicate content. No matter how good you spin it.
Use an ai writer instead.
Click to expand...
you can not spun it, rewrite or those heading, because if you want to? you need to pay at least $30k to GPT3 or ai based re writer.

i scrapped findwanyanswer in january that has almost 20 million of article in their site, lets say each article has 20 to 30 questions, those huge number, you have no chance for re write. all you can do is scrape and post
neOtron said:
Yup alot of such sites went down.but I have list of other 50 or so site that are still doing good. Let's see what's their status be after couple of months
Click to expand...
yes you are right, if they can survive at least 3, or 4 month, they easily have $100k or $200k in their bank :D
 
IM Rider said:
No it's not a blog is not a series of questions. It just not.
Click to expand...
Why not? Let's say I am writing on this topic: "Why my bike is not starting?"

Can't I use these H2/H3:

How to check your bike ignition?
How to check the fuel level in a bike?
Why my bike is not starting after fueling up?
Etc.
 
RealDaddy said:
Why not? Let's say I am writing on this topic: "Why my bike is not starting?"

Can't I use these H2/H3:

How to check your bike ignition?
How to check the fuel level in a bike?
Why my bike is not starting after fueling up?
Etc.
Click to expand...
No you can't, like i said, blog is not a series of questions. Got it!!
 
RealDaddy said:
Why not? Let's say I am writing on this topic: "Why my bike is not starting?"

Can't I use these H2/H3:

How to check your bike ignition?
How to check the fuel level in a bike?
Why my bike is not starting after fueling up?
Etc.
Click to expand...
yes you can use but you have write lot more to make white hat of google eyes like its really human customizable content, something like you need to write bullet point, key point of topics and different kind of paragraph.

because lot of PAA sites has same patterns, question is in h2 then paragraph
IM Rider said:
No you can't, like i said, blog is not a series of questions. Got it!!
Click to expand...
yes as i said before you have write lot more to make your content white hat to google eyes like its really human customizable content, something like you need to write bullet point, key point of topics and different kind of paragraph.
 
Does anyone have a guide or is there a post on how to make these type of sites would like to try this type of site
 
deepdigger said:
yes you can use but you have write lot more to make white hat of google eyes like its really human customizable content, something like you need to write bullet point, key point of topics and different kind of paragraph.

because lot of PAA sites has same patterns, question is in h2 then paragraph

yes as i said before you have write lot more to make your content white hat to google eyes like its really human customizable content, something like you need to write bullet point, key point of topics and different kind of paragraph.
Click to expand...
You got duplicate content site. No need to a take second a guess. You got hit due to duplicate content. Plane and simple.
 
Last edited:
deepdigger said:
yes you are right, if they can survive at least 3, or 4 month, they easily have $100k or $200k in their bank :D
Click to expand...
That's enough to start a real business.
 
I've never understood why people are trying to post 10k-50k+ posts per day to a site - it's a glaring red flag... Google is dumb, but not that dumb. If you get lucky and manage to rank for a few months, it's worth it though.

Better to divide the content across multiple domains - slow and steady. Add unique (Ai or otherwise) content before, after, or in between, sprinkle in images & videos, and consider avoiding adsense in favor of other monetization options.

Also, the door seems much wider open for non-english markets - Google tends to be pretty slow rolling out anti-spam updates to quite a few countries.

Still plenty of ways to make $ with PAA, but the mass-blasting was never meant to be sustainable - still feasible for churn and burn though.
 
X said:
I've never understood why people are trying to post 10k-50k+ posts per day to a site - it's a glaring red flag... Google is dumb, but not that dumb. If you get lucky and manage to rank for a few months, it's worth it though.

Better to divide the content across multiple domains - slow and steady. Add unique (Ai or otherwise) content before, after, or in between, sprinkle in images, and consider avoiding adsense in favor of other monetization options.

Also, the door seems much wider open for non-english markets - Google tends to be pretty slow rolling out anti-spam updates to quite a few countries.

Still plenty of ways to make $ with PAA, but the mass-blasting was never meant to be sustainable - still feasible for churn and burn though.
Click to expand...
ohh boy , you are in this from 2019!!!!!! but its worth to try, they does not feel sad when they got $200k or $300k to their bank already :D
 
  • Like
Reactions: X
deepdigger said:
ohh boy , you are in this from 2019!!!!!! but its worth to try, they does not feel sad when they got $200k or $300k to their bank already :D
Click to expand...
How about a million, a billion or a trilion? Your projections are getting wilder and wilder. I saw I guy making these wild claims is trying to sell paa "done for you" site.
A guy making wild upwork claims is trying to sell upwork ebook.
A guy making wild dropshipping claim was trying to sell some crap I don't even remember. What I remember he got banned.
 
RealDaddy said:
Why not? Let's say I am writing on this topic: "Why my bike is not starting?"

Can't I use these H2/H3:

How to check your bike ignition?
How to check the fuel level in a bike?
Why my bike is not starting after fueling up?
Etc.
Click to expand...
If you build a website blog with the same structure now in the AI era don't forget google can detect a lot of things.
Hundreds of thousands of posts with same structure questions and only questions is a big red flag.

I have been running autoblogs for years now and I have had no serious issues with any of the updates.
Thing is people create blogposts with PAA instead they should just use them wisely in blogposts.
X said:
I've never understood why people are trying to post 10k-50k+ posts per day to a site - it's a glaring red flag... Google is dumb, but not that dumb. If you get lucky and manage to rank for a few months, it's worth it though.

Better to divide the content across multiple domains - slow and steady. Add unique (Ai or otherwise) content before, after, or in between, sprinkle in images & videos, and consider avoiding adsense in favor of other monetization options.

Also, the door seems much wider open for non-english markets - Google tends to be pretty slow rolling out anti-spam updates to quite a few countries.

Still plenty of ways to make $ with PAA, but the mass-blasting was never meant to be sustainable - still feasible for churn and burn though.
Click to expand...
And your questionforge has been of massive help.
Day before yesterday around 45 minutes & over 5K Question keywords.

Leave PAA's aside I don't leave any questions I find not even the ones with zero search volume.
Questions are an integral part of search and if done properly the Era End this is pretty much avoidable.

It all depends what are your goals & do you actually want to keep this running or it's just churn and burn kind.
deepdigger said:
they got $200k or $300k to their bank already
Click to expand...
:suspicious: Wondering why am I not there with my autoblogs that have been running for years.
 
RealDaddy said:
Do autoblogs still make money?
Click to expand...
Yes they do but not like it used to be earlier just spamming spun content.
Earlier it used to work without keyword research now that's important.
And with AI content you now have access to better researched & readable content.
Also monetization is important only using ads is not always working.
Build lists like I started a job website and lots of jobseekers register everyday.
There are few other blogs that share money making tips and tricks monetized with paid surveys and GPT offers.
And unconventional niches are working great as most people don't use them.
I have a business directory + blog with data scraped from internet earning good from sponsored ads banner.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top