well I think its a lie or at least half lie, cause well long story short I just did a search @ google for this http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/25/us/politics/25obama.html?_r=1&hp, it new stuff and then did a search for part of the title "Obama Assures Nation: " if you see, the first ones are the ones from nytimes, but all of the other ones are from blogs and pages using rss feeds or stuff to gather the stuff..
so for the thing about not getting your pages indexed I guess its pretty self explanatory.
thinking outside the box for a sec. I can dare to say and being optimistic, that about 30% or less that is actually 'in' the net is original content and all of the other stuff is either an exact copy of the original material or an 'optimized' version, so if google decided to take all that sh*t out of their results or penalize them, they would not be the monster they are right now.
I could be wrong though, I am not a guru nor I dont work @ google, just my thoughts.