SeoJuice Case Study on Two MNS

UPDATE

Site #2's Plural broad keyword is back to the positive trend after falling by 30 places, though i kind of expected a bigger jump. Not much to say about the other keywords at the moment as they're all jumping around roughly the same rank. Hoping to see some more movement soon.

Site 1:

Exact match keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 24 +1
2nd jan: 24
4th jan: 28 +4
6th jan: 26 -2
8th jan: 28 +2

Broad keyword:
30th dec: Not in top 1000
1st jan: Not in top 1000
2nd jan: Not in top 1000
4th jan: Not in top 1000
6th jan: Not in top 1000
8th jan: Not in top 1000

Site 2:

Broad keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 23
2nd jan: 24 +1
4th jan: 24
6th jan: 23 -1
8th jan: 24 +1

Broad keyword plural:
30th dec: 149
1st jan: 119 -30
2nd jan: 79 -40
4th jan: 55 -24
6th jan: 85 +30
8th jan: 68 -17

Longtail:
30th dec: 7
1st jan: 5 -2
2nd jan: 5
4th jan: 7 +2
6th jan: 5 -2
8th jan: 5

Longtail plural:
30th dec: 10
1st jan: 11 +1
2nd jan: 11
4th jan: 10 -1
6th jan: 10
8th jan: 12 +2

Subscribed. Thanks for the infos and keep up the updates.

UPDATE

Site #2 is doing pretty well, but STILL no sign of Site #1 anywhere near the first page.

Site 1:

Exact match keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 24 +1
2nd jan: 24
4th jan: 28 +4
6th jan: 26 -2
8th jan: 28 +2
11th jan: 28

Broad keyword:
30th dec: Not in top 1000
1st jan: Not in top 1000
2nd jan: Not in top 1000
4th jan: Not in top 1000
6th jan: Not in top 1000
8th jan: Not in top 1000
11th jan: Not in top 1000

Site 2:

Broad keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 23
2nd jan: 24 +1
4th jan: 24
6th jan: 23 -1
8th jan: 24 +1
11th jan: 21 -3

Broad keyword plural:
30th dec: 149
1st jan: 119 -30
2nd jan: 79 -40
4th jan: 55 -24
6th jan: 85 +30
8th jan: 68 -17
11th jan: 25 -43

Longtail:
30th dec: 7
1st jan: 5 -2
2nd jan: 5
4th jan: 7 +2
6th jan: 5 -2
8th jan: 5
11th jan: 3 -2

Longtail plural:
30th dec: 10
1st jan: 11 +1
2nd jan: 11
4th jan: 10 -1
6th jan: 10
8th jan: 12 +2
11th jan: 10 -2

UPDATE

Things are slowing down now, which is why i'm not posting updates so often.
Since the last update, everything has gone down, so half way through the month and all keywords seem to be taking a negative turn - Hoping for some improvement in the next couple of weeks, or else i shall start some SeNuke Campaigns on these two sites.

Site 1:

Exact match keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 24 +1
2nd jan: 24
4th jan: 28 +4
6th jan: 26 -2
8th jan: 28 +2
11th jan: 28
15th jan: 33 +5

Broad keyword:
30th dec: Not in top 1000
1st jan: Not in top 1000
2nd jan: Not in top 1000
4th jan: Not in top 1000
6th jan: Not in top 1000
8th jan: Not in top 1000
11th jan: Not in top 1000
15th jan: Not in top 1000

Site 2:

Broad keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 23
2nd jan: 24 +1
4th jan: 24
6th jan: 23 -1
8th jan: 24 +1
11th jan: 21 -3
15th jan: 24 +3

Broad keyword plural:
30th dec: 149
1st jan: 119 -30
2nd jan: 79 -40
4th jan: 55 -24
6th jan: 85 +30
8th jan: 68 -17
11th jan: 25 -43
15th jan: 80 +55

Longtail:
30th dec: 7
1st jan: 5 -2
2nd jan: 5
4th jan: 7 +2
6th jan: 5 -2
8th jan: 5
11th jan: 3 -2
15th jan: 4 +1

Longtail plural:
30th dec: 10
1st jan: 11 +1
2nd jan: 11
4th jan: 10 -1
6th jan: 10
8th jan: 12 +2
11th jan: 10 -2
15th jan: 12 +2

it looks like you didn't really get much in terms of links that matter... broad improvements, but still far from the first page (not high converting anyway)... exact got worse

so i take it you wouldn't recommend?

UPDATE

This is the last update on this case study.
I have not seen significant enough positive results to justify a $250/month service and have thus cancelled my subscription to Seo Juice. Others may have a different experience with the company, but i have come to a conclusion that it will not work for me.
I am now testing out High Page Rank Society on Site #2, would anyone be interested in me doing a case study for this?


Site 1:

Exact match keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 24 +1
2nd jan: 24
4th jan: 28 +4
6th jan: 26 -2
8th jan: 28 +2
11th jan: 28
15th jan: 33 +5
25th jan : 71 +38

Broad keyword:
30th dec: Not in top 1000
1st jan: Not in top 1000
2nd jan: Not in top 1000
4th jan: Not in top 1000
6th jan: Not in top 1000
8th jan: Not in top 1000
11th jan: Not in top 1000
15th jan: Not in top 1000
25th jan : Not in top 1000

Site 2:

Broad keyword:
30th dec: 23
1st jan: 23
2nd jan: 24 +1
4th jan: 24
6th jan: 23 -1
8th jan: 24 +1
11th jan: 21 -3
15th jan: 24 +3
25th jan : 21 +3

Broad keyword plural:
30th dec: 149
1st jan: 119 -30
2nd jan: 79 -40
4th jan: 55 -24
6th jan: 85 +30
8th jan: 68 -17
11th jan: 25 -43
15th jan: 80 +55
25th jan : 62 -18

Longtail:
30th dec: 7
1st jan: 5 -2
2nd jan: 5
4th jan: 7 +2
6th jan: 5 -2
8th jan: 5
11th jan: 3 -2
15th jan: 4 +1

25th jan : 5 +1


Longtail plural:
30th dec: 10
1st jan: 11 +1
2nd jan: 11
4th jan: 10 -1
6th jan: 10
8th jan: 12 +2
11th jan: 10 -2
15th jan: 12 +2
25th jan : 12

Yes, i am

any case study is welcomed