well, that´s expected. The gaming niche it´s a very competitive one, specially during COVID19 times.
Let´s see...
These are your top competitors (according to you)...
And this is your site....
Right off the bat...
- They have 4x to 5x more links than you
- From more referring domains than you
- Have 2x-4x more tanking keywords than you
Still, I think there isn´t THAT big of a difference, to be honest.
Let´s quickly browse myownrank.com backlink profile since it´s the biggest authority domain on your niche from those you mention.
Look to the referring Domain tabs filter by the ones with the most do follow backlinks...
As you can see from the screenshot above, myownrank.com is getting a significant amount of "link juice" from sites like Wikidot and steinberg.
I never heard of steinberg.net before but take a look at what they do...
Do you think that´s a relevant site? I think not so, let´s not worry about it and go back to wikidot for a moment. Take a look what we get when I run a search for "site:wikidot.com CS:GO...
There are over 3,000 subdomains that are build around that keyword. My guesses are, those guys own a lot of those pages and linking back to their main site.
Now, let´s take a look at yours...
Are you seeing what I see? Your top 3 referring domains with the most do-follow backlinks to your sites are .edu domains and, I don´t think I need to tell you those are NOT relevant to your niche.
In fact, I don´t think there´s a single domain there that is relevant to your niche.
You need to refocus your linkbuilding efforts and give relevance a lot more weight. It´s not just about the number of authoritative domains linking back to your site but also how relevant are these domains to your niche.
And, I am not even diving into other crucial and critical areas of SEO many BHWers already mention like technical and on-page SEO, keyword research, and high-quality and relevant content.
I hope this helps,
Cheers!!