Milk Suspended Etsy Shop

hiatus · Sep 16, 2025

Hello!

Etsy suspended my shop, which was fairly big (over 20k sales). I applied for reinstatement, but they declined because I was selling items that violated their policy. I still have access to the shop and all the messages. What if I create my own website on shopify and start messaging my etsy buyers to let them know I’ve moved my business there?

BornAHustler · Sep 16, 2025

What were you selling? And you could definitely host your page somewhere else as long as the items aren't prohibited there. Ebay, facebook, any third party platform. Maybe even shopify like you said. See what is prohibited on the platforms so you know what the level of risk is. Good luck

Venusaur · Sep 16, 2025

I don't think they are so stupid to allow a banned seller to mass dm buyers with a link
Your messages would probably be shadowbanned
But you don't have anything to lose (except for time), try to do that, let's see if their system works

cartiology · Nov 6, 2025

Venusaur said:
I don't think they are so stupid to allow a banned seller to mass dm buyers with a link
Your messages would probably be shadowbanned
But you don't have anything to lose (except for time), try to do that, let's see if their system works

I agree, you most probably will not be allowed to do it. anyways, what was the product you were selling?

NotableMoney · Nov 6, 2025

I do not recommend using Etsy to communicate with your customers. This will lead to a permanent ban of your Etsy account. However, if there are no other ways, then you can use this as a very last option.

geekproxy · Nov 6, 2025

hiatus said:
access to the shop and all the messages

Considering that you have nothing to lose, identify your most loyal/major clients and start with them. Do not send messages too often, and do not insert any copypasted text with links or make them look like simple text.

Amaney · Dec 22, 2025

Same thing, its about 4 policies violations and immediatly suspended unfortunately. However I opened new shop

mem999 · Feb 22, 2026

I was trying to start an Etsy business with digital products, but my account got locked, which is frustrating.

Milk Suspended Etsy Shop

hiatus

Power Member

BornAHustler

Junior Member

Venusaur

Elite Member

cartiology

BANNED

NotableMoney

Junior Member

geekproxy

Junior Member

Amaney

Registered Member

mem999

Junior Member

Main Menu

Marketplace

Making Money

BlackHat World