Method: Utilizing New Youtube/Google + Comments

This is working amazing for me (Switching IP'S) OP i owe you a big slobbery kiss (I'm not gay)
 
It is easier since the spammer just has to reply to his own comment 100 times to make it to the top. Once that is fixed (I am sure it will be) it is going to be harder for those people to get top comments unless you have tons of clean IPs as you already mentioned.

It's already fixed.. I got my account disabled (50 of them) when you use your accounts on replying your own comment and you're right clean ip + fresh account will do this trick..

so here's the new formula now
Accounts for mass comment + fresh ip
Accounts for replier + fresh ip
Accounts for thumbing up + fresh ip.
 
Utilization complete. Thanks for this method that works with the new G+ comments.
 
Why are you guys so obsessed with clean ips and proxies and crap? I have been manually "marketing" (sounds better than spamming ^^) youtube for years, and i hardly lost any accounts at all. The only time i lose accounts is when i log in from a diffetent ip, then google thinks it is "unusual activity" and locks the account. So account wise proxies do two things for me; slow me down and ban my accounts.

As for the comments, both posting and thumbing up i havent noticed ANY difference what so ever between proxied and not proxied advertizing (except that it is slower with proxies)

And no, my comments do not get ghosted, i check them on my laptop with a differeny isp and they are there.. all the comments and all the thumbs.

So.. what am i missing here? Why is everyone so obsessed with proxies and ips? Am i missing something here?
 
Looks like there is about to be a major change coming. As or right now Top Comments and Newest Comments are giving the same results.
 
Looks like there is about to be a major change coming. As or right now Top Comments and Newest Comments are giving the same results.

Yap , I felt it, and i am can not reply twice in same comment
 
It really pisses me off how some guys were exploiting the new comment system. They're so dumb. Promoting all type of BS all over the place specially on most popular videos. Adults, casino, fake hacks... etc Really?? I was able to get top comments easily and I was doing it all manually, but now thanks to these people YouTube is about to change the game AGAIN... Some people just don't get it....
 
This is what this person had to say:
pewdiepie comment.png
.....
 
have anyone tried comment reply from same IP help to be on top comment?
 
I still can.

From what I see they are going back to the old most thumbs up gets top comment.

nopes, I am looking at a video right now, top comment has no thumbs, a few comments down is one with 1 thumb, further down, after a few no-thumbers is a +2 thumbs.

so there are top comments, but thumbs doesn't work to get your comment up... this needs more investigation :D
 
It really pisses me off how some guys were exploiting the new comment system. They're so dumb. Promoting all type of BS all over the place specially on most popular videos. Adults, casino, fake hacks... etc Really?? I was able to get top comments easily and I was doing it all manually, but now thanks to these people YouTube is about to change the game AGAIN... Some people just don't get it....

So how is what they were doing different than what you were doing? You can't get mad at people for automating the same process you used.
 
Is that 1000 comments for only one comment or After getting 1000 replies your every comment will be top?

See, i know this trick fails.. I have seen many videos where a troll message, who got only 2 reply(one from himself) is at top comments, while other 20 long discussions are down to page 2-3.
 
I have seen something strange too...I am sorry for posting it in two different threads but this is very akward
look at the pic...basically this guy was able to rank his comment in the top by replying to himself with the same account over and over on a video with like 17 mil views...
1.jpg
 
Newest Comments and Top Comments are the same. They are making changes. What a mess. Like they don't even test their shit.
 
I have seen something strange too...I am sorry for posting it in two different threads but this is very akward
look at the pic...basically this guy was able to rank his comment in the top by replying to himself with the same account over and over on a video with like 17 mil views...
View attachment 41564

Video link pls?
 
Newest Comments and Top Comments are the same. They are making changes. What a mess. Like they don't even test their shit.

Some New Comments don't make it as a Top Comment, there must be some kind of filter in place. Not sure what it is.
 
Back
Top