I already rank for a niche where lifetime value of customer is very high and its targeting a wealthy location. Lets say for the sake of an example I am ranking for beverly hills plastic surgeon. One customer equals thousands of dollars in revenue over time. $500/lead for plastic surgeon is a reasonable price, same goes for a roofing company. You sending 1 client a month could mean $10-20k in business for some types of business. Now ask yourself - as a business owner how much would you pay in referral fees to acquire $10-20k of new business? With 10% being lowest you are looking $1-2k. If you are generous at 20% you are looking $2-4k.
As stated before I would use a detailed lead form. For plastic surgeon you can ask what type of surgery lead would be interested in, are they paying in full (plastic surgery is not covered by insurance) or payment plan, do they want to schedule an appointment, the list goes and on. The more information you can get from a lead the higher you can charge for it. Location, location, location. Leads for Beverly Hills, California are worth more than leads for Compton, California.
Please lets stay on the subject of renting the site and not twisting it into ranking a website or local listings.
Very good information!
But I do have one, albeit minor, disagreement. With the rent-a-site, I think it is a very good idea to have a Google Places set up to - no doubt you're missing out on traffic and potential leads?
Otherwise, top info. there, really puts it into perspective.
I assume that you charge PER lead not per CONVERTED lead, is that correct? Would be hard to have to believe them whether a lead converted or not.