Dawid_777_7
Registered Member
- Sep 28, 2020
- 59
- 27
it's not possible. AI content is moving towards perfection and it's matter of time when it will be better than any copywriter.
Do you think Google will punish Ai content?
- Thread starter sscaz
- Start date
- Mar 22, 2020
- 204
- 43
at the end it all depends on the quality content
- Mar 2, 2012
- 3,503
- 1,652
im sure google has their own ai for detecting ai stuff
BlackHatSoda
Regular Member
- Oct 6, 2009
- 393
- 329
I think the people posting about how it doesn't matter if the content comes from an ML model or not as long as it's quality, are missing the point. These chatbots don't generate good quality content. They generate passable content if it's short form and that's about it.
Try making ChatGPT, 3.5-turbo or 4, produce quality content, even via the API with the penalties for repeating terms set to max, and it'll still reiterate content (unless you tell it to produce short form), the text will be stilted and dry (tell it to add more emotion and it starts to generate content that is unnaturally overly emotional). In general it mostly cobbles together a bunch of of high level points about the topic and doesn't generally go into real detail unless you prompt it for specifics on those details, which means you have to know something about the subject matter to make the prompts, then edit the output, then piece the different outputs together so they flow.
At this point you might as well just write most of the content yourself and only use ChatGPT as tool to answer questions which you then rephrase and work into a coherent article.
Again, this is if you want quality content, which is what Google says they want. Otherwise, what you're getting is basically the kind of seo spam content you get from cheap non-native english speakers just with better spelling and grammar. And I wouldn't think that qualifies as quality content in the eyes of search engines.
Stack Overflow banned posting code generated by ChatGPT because of how bad it usually was. So I can imagine even if Google doesn't specifically try and detect ML generated content, it'll still get filtered out due to the quality.
At least until a much better generative text model is produced.
Try making ChatGPT, 3.5-turbo or 4, produce quality content, even via the API with the penalties for repeating terms set to max, and it'll still reiterate content (unless you tell it to produce short form), the text will be stilted and dry (tell it to add more emotion and it starts to generate content that is unnaturally overly emotional). In general it mostly cobbles together a bunch of of high level points about the topic and doesn't generally go into real detail unless you prompt it for specifics on those details, which means you have to know something about the subject matter to make the prompts, then edit the output, then piece the different outputs together so they flow.
At this point you might as well just write most of the content yourself and only use ChatGPT as tool to answer questions which you then rephrase and work into a coherent article.
Again, this is if you want quality content, which is what Google says they want. Otherwise, what you're getting is basically the kind of seo spam content you get from cheap non-native english speakers just with better spelling and grammar. And I wouldn't think that qualifies as quality content in the eyes of search engines.
Stack Overflow banned posting code generated by ChatGPT because of how bad it usually was. So I can imagine even if Google doesn't specifically try and detect ML generated content, it'll still get filtered out due to the quality.
At least until a much better generative text model is produced.
- Nov 11, 2018
- 12,098
- 10,852
No matter what they tell ya they will eventually.
Here is the scenario:
Google gets a really good ai eventually much better then chatgpt.
It makes no sense to me to show you lame static ai content when googles ai can interactively / dynamically fulfill the search intent.
So your ai content gets thrown out.
Here is the scenario:
Google gets a really good ai eventually much better then chatgpt.
It makes no sense to me to show you lame static ai content when googles ai can interactively / dynamically fulfill the search intent.
So your ai content gets thrown out.
Illumi_96x
Junior Member
- Feb 4, 2022
- 193
- 197
One ought to be quite naive to think that Google hasn't figured out a way to detect AI content at this point, they're the largest and most powerful internet corp for God's sake 
Also, Google claimed they won't penalize AI content as long as it is high-quality and relevant, in other words, they don't care.
Also, Google claimed they won't penalize AI content as long as it is high-quality and relevant, in other words, they don't care.
bojanpeic
Power Member
- Jan 23, 2018
- 685
- 363
I highly doubt that.
1: I've ran some old content I wrote like 3-4 years ago through AI detectors and got like 30-40% of content marked as AI written. That's just not possible as I've been writing that content years ago high like a kite.
2: Murphy's Law - Anything that can happen will happen. With endless possibilities what stops a human from writing a piece of content that's 100% AI like? I'd be stupid of Google to punish content just because a machine said that machine wrote it, while that might not be true.
If the content is good it will rank, if it's crap it wont. In my opinion.
1: I've ran some old content I wrote like 3-4 years ago through AI detectors and got like 30-40% of content marked as AI written. That's just not possible as I've been writing that content years ago high like a kite.
2: Murphy's Law - Anything that can happen will happen. With endless possibilities what stops a human from writing a piece of content that's 100% AI like? I'd be stupid of Google to punish content just because a machine said that machine wrote it, while that might not be true.
If the content is good it will rank, if it's crap it wont. In my opinion.
Yes
jootess
Regular Member
- Feb 17, 2022
- 240
- 27
Many free tools smaller than Google can now recognize AI content, just search "AI content detector tools online" on Google. How do you think Google can't? It definitely can