outreach - personalization or ai slop?

Joined
Nov 12, 2026
Messages
17
Reaction score
3
hey guys,

all the time I do outreach, highly personalized messages (manual -
that give me less struggle on each stage, more response rate, better call close rate and etc - but a lot of time...


anytime I do ai slop outreach with ai personalization, struggle everything and
to get to a call or needed action I need to make 7-8 follow ups.

is that my prompt sucks or ppl really response only on personalization.

have u ever set up campaign with really good ai personalization, if yes , how the prompt looked like, what data source used and etc? maybe some examples. thx
 
bro i think the problem is not just the prompt.

ai personalization can still feel fake if there is no real value behind it. i'd focus on finding a genuine pain point and keeping the message short and natural.
sometimes a simple message with a relevant offer gets better replies than a heavily personalized ai email.
 
bro i think the problem is not just the prompt.

ai personalization can still feel fake if there is no real value behind it. i'd focus on finding a genuine pain point and keeping the message short and natural.
sometimes a simple message with a relevant offer gets better replies than a heavily personalized ai email.
sometimes offer could be pretty shitty, also I use it for other purposes. personalization is always win. I mean ALWAYS , even if your offer is absolutely insane shit like web design or whatever.
 
The 7-8 follow ups thing sounds like the AI is personalizing the wrong stuff. Most prompts just grab a company name and a line from their About page, and people can smell that in about two seconds, so it lands as slop with extra steps. What worked better for me when I tested it was feeding the model one real, recent signal per lead, like a post they made, a job ad they put up or something that changed on their site, and telling it to write only one short line about that and nothing else. Honestly the manual stuff wins because you notice what actually matters, and the model just notices what is easy to scrape, shocking I know. Are you pulling the data from LinkedIn or somewhere else, and do you check each AI opener by hand before it goes out?
 
The 7-8 follow ups thing sounds like the AI is personalizing the wrong stuff. Most prompts just grab a company name and a line from their About page, and people can smell that in about two seconds, so it lands as slop with extra steps. What worked better for me when I tested it was feeding the model one real, recent signal per lead, like a post they made, a job ad they put up or something that changed on their site, and telling it to write only one short line about that and nothing else. Honestly the manual stuff wins because you notice what actually matters, and the model just notices what is easy to scrape, shocking I know. Are you pulling the data from LinkedIn or somewhere else, and do you check each AI opener by hand before it goes out?
depending from audience, could be Linkedin, could be smth else.
yeah, I'm checking and 50% of all opening are just absolute slop. even when there's interesting data that I scrape that can't be really used for interesting personalization.

I'd like to not check , and maybe automate the messaging on volume as I see other ppl in the industry doing
 
I think the problem isn't necessarily the AI itself, but how much of the personalization is actually relevant to the person receiving it. Mentioning someone's company name or recent activity doesn't automatically make a message personal. People can usually tell when a message is generated just to look customized.

I'd use AI for research and gathering information, but keep the actual message focused on a specific problem or opportunity you've identified. That way, you save time without losing the human touch. Personalization works best when the recipient can see why you're reaching out to them in particular.
Make my advice sound more conversational
 
Back
Top