Which is the best SeoWriting.ai or Allinwriter.com? Or none of them?

Hi

What is your experience with these Seowriting tools, have you seen success, if yes with which one?
And what about the latest model selection for Seowriting, is Gemini, Chatgpt or Claude? Which is the best if it works?

This is not a sposnored thread, i had to mention both to know for which tools i am asking for.

Regards

mangoone1 said:

Hi

What is your experience with these Seowriting tools, have you seen success, if yes with which one?
And what about the latest model selection for Seowriting, is Gemini, Chatgpt or Claude? Which is the best if it works?

This is not a sposnored thread, i had to mention both to know for which tools i am asking for.

Regards

Click to expand...

I've been experimenting with AI content workflows, and honestly, I think the model matters less than how you use it. Gemini, ChatGPT, and Claude can all produce good content, but getting consistent results for SEO still takes the right prompts and workflow. Thats it.

I'd test both with the same topic and compare factual accuracy, readability, editing time, and content quality. The underlying model matters, but so does your workflow. No tool guarantees rankings, so I'd judge by how much useful, original content you can produce rather than output volume alone.

I wouldn’t choose based on the model name alone. Run a few real articles through both tools and compare the output, editing time, and cost. The best one is the tool that fits your workflow and consistently produces useful content.

I'd put the model choice pretty far down the list. For me, what matters more is everything around it: researching the right keywords, matching search intent, planning a useful content calendar, adding relevant internal links, and getting the articles published.

I'd judge these tools on how well they handle that whole process. Can the research actually guide the article? Does the calendar make sense for your site? Do the internal links help the reader, or are they just dropped in wherever a keyword matches?

The LLM still needs to write a decent draft, but thats only one part of the job. I'd rather have a solid draft backed by useful research and a sensible publishing plan than nicer wording with all the SEO work left to do.