Invest in SEO expert or invest in tools?

S

serenareid

Newbie
Joined
Jul 23, 2026
Messages
11
Reaction score
11
As a content website owner doing SEO on my own for last 7 years, I feel lost with the current multiple changes in google SERPS because of Ai. The website has also lost about 50% of organic traffic in last 1-1.5 years.

I feel now I need someone to guide me in this highly volatile SE0 landscape. All the gurus I used to follow are all saying different things making it highly confusing.

Should I hire a new SEO person in the team or invest the same money in tools and supporting resources?
 
Advertise on BHW
I would probably invest in the person before the tools. tools can give you data, but they won’t necessarily tell you which problems actually matter or what to prioritize after a major traffic drop.

If you have already been doing SEO for 7 years, I wouldn’t blindly buy another stack of tools. I would first get someone experienced to audit the site, traffic decline, content, technical setup, and what has changed in your SERPs. once you know where the problem is, then use tools to execute and monitor it.

the biggest mistake would be paying for an “SEO expert” who just logs into Ahrefs / Semrush and gives you the same reports you could generate yourself. Id look for someone who can explain what they would change, why they would change it, and how they will measure whether it worked.
 
MajestySEO said:
I would probably invest in the person before the tools. tools can give you data, but they won’t necessarily tell you which problems actually matter or what to prioritize after a major traffic drop.

If you have already been doing SEO for 7 years, I wouldn’t blindly buy another stack of tools. I would first get someone experienced to audit the site, traffic decline, content, technical setup, and what has changed in your SERPs. once you know where the problem is, then use tools to execute and monitor it.

the biggest mistake would be paying for an “SEO expert” who just logs into Ahrefs / Semrush and gives you the same reports you could generate yourself. Id look for someone who can explain what they would change, why they would change it, and how they will measure whether it worked.
Click to expand...
Thank you, I will consider finding someone who is truly good at SEO and can help me during this stage.
 
I’d spend the money on a good SEO person before stacking more tools. Tools can show you what changed, but they won’t necessarily tell you why traffic dropped or what to prioritize.
I’ve seen site owners subscribe to 5 - 6 platforms and still struggle with the same issue. A capable SEO can audit the losses, compare competitors, review SERP changes, then use a few tools to validate the findings instead of collecting data without a clear direction.
 
Not just you, many people lost traffic after AI tools became popular. As you have experience in SEO, you should do an audit to figure out the industry-wide changes and find out where the missing traffic is going. If the traffic is going to a competitor site, then you can either hire an SEO expert or build backlinks to improve site authority. If the traffic is going to AI tools, then you should focus on brand mentions & citations. If the overall traffic has declined over the years, then there is not much you can do. Google has also made many changes to its algorithm recently that destroyed many whitehat sites. So, there could be multiple reasons for losing traffic and you can only identify the reasons after an audit.
 
Tools

AI is the new SEO expert, just ask it
 
serenareid said:
As a content website owner doing SEO on my own for last 7 years, I feel lost with the current multiple changes in google SERPS because of Ai. The website has also lost about 50% of organic traffic in last 1-1.5 years.

I feel now I need someone to guide me in this highly volatile SE0 landscape. All the gurus I used to follow are all saying different things making it highly confusing.

Should I hire a new SEO person in the team or invest the same money in tools and supporting resources?
Click to expand...
In my opinion, I would surely hire an experienced SEO specialist from the vry start. tools will provide you with the data, but experience will show you how to utilise it.
 
Tools give data, but an expert knows what to do with it. Invest in the expert first.
 
That’s because I would invest in a good SEO professional right away if you know the tools even just part time. That way, an audit and strategy will prevent months of fruitless chase for Google updates.
 
Before hiring someone, get a proper audit done first. You need to know where the traffic was lost before spending more money.
 
serenareid said:
As a content website owner doing SEO on my own for last 7 years, I feel lost with the current multiple changes in google SERPS because of Ai. The website has also lost about 50% of organic traffic in last 1-1.5 years.

I feel now I need someone to guide me in this highly volatile SE0 landscape. All the gurus I used to follow are all saying different things making it highly confusing.

Should I hire a new SEO person in the team or invest the same money in tools and supporting resources?
Click to expand...
I'd invest in an experienced SEO consultant first, not more tools. With a 50% traffic drop, you need to understand why rankings and traffic declined before spending more on software.

Get a proper audit identify the pages issue that lost traffic, then use tools to support the recovery strategy
 
I feel at the stage you are right now, getting help from someone who can guide you would be best.

You are currently overwhelmed with so much and don't know the best direction to follow for your website.

It might not even be about hiring someone to fix everything for you but rather getting someone who can give you a clear direction on what you should focus on and do next after they analyze and audit your website to understand the issues you're facing

Then, you can invest in tools if they are actually needed and you can probably solve some of the issues yourself cheaper that way.
 
serenareid said:
As a content website owner doing SEO on my own for last 7 years, I feel lost with the current multiple changes in google SERPS because of Ai. The website has also lost about 50% of organic traffic in last 1-1.5 years.

I feel now I need someone to guide me in this highly volatile SE0 landscape. All the gurus I used to follow are all saying different things making it highly confusing.

Should I hire a new SEO person in the team or invest the same money in tools and supporting resources?
Click to expand...
I think I would try to get some experience. It would not be helpful before you learn to decode the signal which is not an easy task becuz of the sudden reduction in traffic.
 
If you want to build business to next level you should build a good team and make them to do the work even you are not there your business should run without you for weeks, even months. Instead of invest in tools and do it by yourself you can consider adding experienced SEO person and get an idea from them. Since you have an experience adding a new member will give you more energy and new ideas too!
 
I’d begin by talking with an SEO expert or consultant for guidance first, not rushing into a full time hire. Before anything else, figure out why your traffic slipped, then pick the right tools and sharpen your current content. If the work burden turns out to be too heavy, bring in an SEO person later on.
 
I would go with the expert first. You already have the tools, but a fresh perspective may help find what you are missing.
 
If you already know SEO well after 7 years, another tool may not help much. A fresh opinion from an experienced SEO person can help you find things you may have missed.
 
Having 7 years of SEO experience means you already understand the fundamentals, so simply subscribing to more SaaS platforms or hiring a generic "expert" who just sends you an automated Semrush/Ahrefs export won't solve the problem.

Before committing budget to either a full-time hire or new tooling, do a granular segment analysis of how that 50% drop happened:

  1. Zero-Click / AI Overview Cannibalization: Check whether your actual rank positions remained steady (top 1–3) while impressions/clicks tanked. If Google’s AI Overviews are directly answering the user queries on the SERP, no amount of traditional SEO or new tools will bring that specific traffic back. You would need to pivot toward bottom-of-funnel, opinion-based, or non-summarizable content.
  2. Algorithmic Devaluation / Helpful Content Impact: If your actual keyword positions dropped across entire categories, your domain likely took a hit on overall trust or content quality signals.
Instead of a permanent hire or recurring software subscriptions right away, consider booking a one-time deep-dive audit with an established consultant who specifically understands post-AI SERP volatility. Let them diagnose the exact root cause first, and then decide whether you need specific tools or extra hands to execute the recovery.
 
Neither yet. Tools show you numbers you already half know. And an expert without your data is guessing. Search Console is free. It covers most of it. If I was you I'd spend 3 months in there first, then you'll know what you're actually buying.
 
Invest in person who can handle tools and your site.
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top