• Please take a moment to look over the Suggestions & Feedback rules before making a post: READ RULES HERE

What I would like to see from BHW in 2017

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 969102
  • Start date Start date
BSTs closed upon SL:

If a member has an open and active Shitlist thread against them, I think that automatically closing their BST (And possibly restricting posts in the Hire a freelancer section) would a) encourage them to resolve the situation a lot, lot faster and b) help other users stay safe.

I'll give you my thoughts on this as I hang around that section a little bit.

The restriction of posts in the HAF section I have imposed more than once when working on a SL thread and will do that again in the future... not all the time but when it seems to make sense to me.

Closing a BST is not a good idea in my opinion unless there are copious people popping in the SL thread saying they had similar negative experiences. I think there is merit in that thought if you have a handful of people complaining though but I would defer to the Marketplace Mods on any action there should that be instituted.

Often times it takes some time to get to the bottom of things as the Mod has other things on his plate, the seller or buyer is not online all the time, reading the reports provided can take some time (I had one SL thread where I had to go through 37 excel files) and to penalize the seller right off is not far from saying he is guilty without going through the process of proof.
 
I'll give you my thoughts on this as I hang around that section a little bit.

The restriction of posts in the HAF section I have imposed more than once when working on a SL thread and will do that again in the future... not all the time but when it seems to make sense to me.

Closing a BST is not a good idea in my opinion unless there are copious people popping in the SL thread saying they had similar negative experiences. I think there is merit in that thought if you have a handful of people complaining though but I would defer to the Marketplace Mods on any action there should that be instituted.

Often times it takes some time to get to the bottom of things as the Mod has other things on his plate, the seller or buyer is not online all the time, reading the reports provided can take some time (I had one SL thread where I had to go through 37 excel files) and to penalize the seller right off is not far from saying he is guilty without going through the process of proof.

That makes sense. Maybe I was a little hasty to say that they should automatically be locked, but maybe something could be posted at the top of the thread (like when people stop their Jr.Vip or do not renew their BST) just to make people aware. This could also be done after you aprove the SL to make sure that the person has a valid point.

Just a suggestion. Keep doing what you're doing -It's great!
 
I think they should ban freebies and asking for samples/reports. You could cut at least 50% of all the marketplace threads if you banned asking/offering freebies - if the moderator tested it and it's kosher that should be good enough.

And have all the marketplace thread owners have samples and reports in their threads when they open them up.

That way a person can see two things Reviews and Questions/Answers.
 
I think they should ban freebies and asking for samples/reports. You could cut at least 50% of all the marketplace threads if you banned asking/offering freebies - if the moderator tested it and it's kosher that should be good enough.

And have all the marketplace thread owners have samples and reports in their threads when they open them up.

That way a person can see two things Reviews and Questions/Answers.

Disagree.

The thing is I have bought several services are quite poor / crap on here.
The quality wasn't as good as the samples provided, no way were they the same quality as the ones supplied to a Mod for approval.

As much as a Mod can say a service is good, I want to see samples for myself.
I've bought sites that have been delivered weeks / months late ( Mod approved was on time ). Sites with zero onpage seo , hackproof MNS which were hacked within a week of delivery....

I've bought content that was approved as good, but what I got wasn't fit for buffer sites.... Almost wondered if it had been outsourced.

Links that vanished within a month of delivery...

I could go on.
 
I think they should ban freebies and asking for samples/reports. You could cut at least 50% of all the marketplace threads if you banned asking/offering freebies - if the moderator tested it and it's kosher that should be good enough.

And have all the marketplace thread owners have samples and reports in their threads when they open them up.

That way a person can see two things Reviews and Questions/Answers.

Disagree.

The thing is I have bought several services are quite poor / crap on here.
The quality wasn't as good as the samples provided, no way were they the same quality as the ones supplied to a Mod for approval.

As much as a Mod can say a service is good, I want to see samples for myself.
I've bought sites that have been delivered weeks / months late ( Mod approved was on time ). Sites with zero onpage seo , hackproof MNS which were hacked within a week of delivery....

I've bought content that was approved as good, but what I got wasn't fit for buffer sites.... Almost wondered if it had been outsourced.

Links that vanished within a month of delivery...

I could go on.

Can't the member PM the thread owners asking for the samples instead of asking I'm the thread and bumping it? All I see on the homepage is marketplace threads being bumped, bumped, and bumped because of people asking for samples when they can just PM the thread owner asking for it.
 
Introduction replies:

Although I'm most definitely still a new member here, I can't actually remember what happened when I signed up. As far as I can remember, new members are automatically sent a welcome PM - like most forums - however, these are often overlooked (At least when I signup to places I never read them)

My idea is to have a system that automatically replies to all new threads in the "Introductions" section. By reiterating the rules that are most commonly broken (Selling outside of the marketplace and spamming). I think it would also be good if the reply contained some useful links like @Zwielicht 's post about Staying safe BHW and this post by @PHPInjected .

Fixing watched threads:

I've seen this discussed before and I remember @Zwielicht (Once again) giving an awesome an in-depth reply as to the problem, although it's still not been resolved.

By looking at the "Watched Threads" page I can see that there are a dozen-or-so threads that I watch that have been replied to today, however, NONE of them showed up on my alerts page. I'm not sure if this is intentional or not, but I really don't like it. I miss out on a lot of good shares this way and I'm sure others do too.

Two-step verification for old accounts:

I'm not sure if you've seen, but @Neon and I always tag each other when we see really suspicious, old accounts that have posted their first ever post in three years or something (We suspect that they are bought accounts). I've raised this issue before and accounts are always quickly dealt with, however, I think that it would be a good idea to require people who log in on new devices to verify access through their email.

Exec VIPs having more power:

Now, there is no denying that @Asif WILSON Khan is an incredible member, who offers a lot of helpful insight and often uncovers double accounts, scammers and so on; However, it really pains me to see him going to all this trouble of reporting spammers etc. When he could simply have the power to ban them, or at least temporarily block their access until a fully-fledged moderator/ admin comes along.

Theme fixes:

As @Sherbert Hoover pointed out, there are quite a few floors with the white theme that makes it less desirable. I'm sure that there are some members here who have the know-how to be able to fix this quickly.

BSTs closed upon SL:

If a member has an open and active Shitlist thread against them, I think that automatically closing their BST (And possibly restricting posts in the Hire a freelancer section) would a) encourage them to resolve the situation a lot, lot faster and b) help other users stay safe.

Banned member colour:

This is another thing that I have seen mentioned before, but never acted upon. Having the same colour name as Mods, especially when they have the Jr.VIP badge underneath is incredibly confusing.

  • BSTs closed upon SL: BTB already answered this one.
  • Introduction replies: Maybe, but the members who come here to spam and sell outside the marketplace usually don't care to read about any rules here, and they almost never post in the introductions section.
  • Fixing watched threads: You already know my thoughts on this one.
  • Exec VIPs having more power: Wilson will apply if/when he's ready to become a moderator.
  • Banned member colour: This doesn't bother me as much as it used to, but I thought the colours for "Mod & Banned" would look better.
 
Can't the member PM the thread owners asking for the samples instead of asking I'm the thread and bumping it? All I see on the homepage is marketplace threads being bumped, bumped, and bumped because of people asking for samples when they can just PM the thread owner asking for it.
Not everyone can PM. Some people just come here to buy stuff, and they shouldn't be penalised for that.

  • Introduction replies: Maybe, but the members who come here to spam and sell outside the marketplace usually don't care to read about any rules here, and they almost never post in the introductions section.
  • Exec VIPs having more power: Wilson will apply if/when he's ready to become a moderator.

The introduction thing can only do good. Even if it only deters one person, that's still one less person you guys have to deal with.

And I know Asif could apply to be a Mod, but I don't see why he shouldn't at least be able to temporarily halt accounts or flag them, instead of watching the spam go on for an hour when he was there after five minutes.

Without that privilege, what really is the difference between Jr.Exec and Exec?
 
Most sellers do have alternative ways to be reached though
I guess so. But if people didn't ask for samples in the thread, what would be the point of allowing replies at all? Old threads would be overtaken by newer ones.

After all, people enquiring about a service is a sign that it's popular and appealing
 
im not necessarily against people being able to ask for samples in sales thread, but it definitely leaves an opportunity for some sellers to create fake accounts for thread bumps. regardless, sellers will find a way to bump their thread, like maybe forcing people to post their transaction ID in order to start the work
 
So does Ste, so who gives a fuck.

Yeah but mine are supposed to be there.

i had a lady friend when i was in school that was into watching me scarf down food

I'm not into watching people eat, but for you I'd make an exception. ;)

Re thread topic: I do think the colors of banned members and mods should be changed. Every time I see @BassTrackerBoats post I go "Omg. When was he banned?!"

So maybe a darker red for the mods like @Zwielicht suggested.
 
I would like to see a feature called *GROUPS* when users can create some groups related to a specific niche or topic, instead of SKYPE,
 
You can already do that in PMs?

ya, but we need something powerful, like users restrictions, pre-approval...there is a lot of addons you can add
and the most important thing BHW will keep that traffic inside
 
ya, but we need something powerful, like users restrictions, pre-approval...there is a lot of addons you can add
and the most important thing BHW will keep that traffic inside
I mean when you PM someone on BHW, you are able to create groups:

Capture.PNG
 
Just a quick update with some more suggestions.

Notifications:

While this is hardly a big issue, I think the option to enable desktop notifications and/or notification sounds would be great (Maybe there is a way already, I'm not sure) As this would definitely save a lot of time wasted when people close the page for a while and don't come back until they remember.

I guess it would be possible just to setup Gmail notifications to the desktop, and have PM's sent to your inbox, but a direct option would be nice.

Decreased Reporting time/ PM time limits:

I'm not sure if I've mentioned this already - I've had the idea for a while - but I was reminded of it today while sending a number of PM's. I think that the reporting limits should be based on the number of successful reports (Action taken as a result of your report) or maybe that:total reports ratio. This would allow more trustworthy users to be able to report posts more efficiently, as it can get quite annoying to wait between posts.

The same goes with PM's. I've had to send a number of identical PM's out a number of times now, and it gets quite frustrating when I have to wait 5-10 minutes to send them all, especially when I come back and send one every 5 minutes, instead of all at once.

Let me know what you think.
 
Back
Top