Hi, yes, it would look strange which is why we built in a feature of the plugin that allows you to choose the percentage of your traffic that gets jacked by the plugin which means you can control how many of your visitors get Follow Jacked.
In the
user guide for the plugin I cover this topic with examples of how choosing the right percentage will allow you to control the number of Followers that you get from the plugin. In fact it is vitally important to read that section and make sure it's fully understood before using the plugin.
If in doubt then ask me and I'll try to provide advice that is relative to your own circumstances.
Thanks,
Shez