[METHOD] How to rank your comment on the new youtube system!
- Thread starter kojakfull
- Start date
sibivfl
Regular Member
- Oct 21, 2013
- 429
- 122
easy piece of cake
just tried with more natural comments and get 7 likes and 8 comments, but still can see only newest comments at the top, not sure if i'm looking at it right. should i clean cookies or something?
greenmusic
Regular Member
- Dec 15, 2012
- 415
- 175
Nope it doesn't work anymore. YouTube is about to change then game again.
easy piece of cake
Checkmate
BANNED
- Aug 9, 2010
- 1,658
- 687
There is no outranking anymore. All Top Comments are just New Comments. Look at the timestamps.
stallion45d
Power Member
- Oct 11, 2011
- 735
- 464
YouTube spamming will never be dead. As long as comments are on, there always will be a way to drive traffic from them. It can become into something less profitable or harder to spam, but that is another thing.
At the moment is a total waste of time to spend long hours creating a bot until the decide the new algo and conditions for the comment section.
dome.d0nkss
BANNED
- Jul 4, 2013
- 331
- 78
I read this thread and I have only question/problem.
I can easily rank my comment but if I get more reports, can I rank my comments again on the top?
Thanks,
I can easily rank my comment but if I get more reports, can I rank my comments again on the top?
Thanks,
- Dec 1, 2011
- 3,027
- 1,921
This is a big change for YouTube. They are still playing with results. I'd wait a week or so until they figure out what's best for them and what they are going to keep and then we can all figure out the best way to rank. In the long run, once they keep one thing, we w ill be able to rank spam comments way easier that before.
stegejaaaarn
Junior Member
- Mar 15, 2011
- 194
- 45
on some videos newest comments are NOT the same as top comments, on some other videos they are...
on one video I got a comment with 12 thumbs up, and 4 replies (all mine) with just as many thumbs up, still another guy made a post with just the word "excellent", no replies, no thumbs, no nothing, and still he is outranking my thumbed comments and replies... hmmpf.... and his comment is older than mine, not newer...
so... seems comments, thumbs and content doesn't matter on some videos... on some videos it's just chance which comment gets to be on top...
on one video I got a comment with 12 thumbs up, and 4 replies (all mine) with just as many thumbs up, still another guy made a post with just the word "excellent", no replies, no thumbs, no nothing, and still he is outranking my thumbed comments and replies... hmmpf.... and his comment is older than mine, not newer...
so... seems comments, thumbs and content doesn't matter on some videos... on some videos it's just chance which comment gets to be on top...
same for me to :|
Rabbitman111
Regular Member
- Jun 22, 2013
- 415
- 39
Yep, as of Wednesday this method no longer works. Top comments are no longer top comments, they are just randomly chosen comments from the new ones. If you try ranking your comment now, by the time you even do 10 upvotes (manually) your comment will already be on the 4th page of top comments...
somethingclever
Newbie
- Nov 26, 2008
- 26
- 4
The trend you'll see right now as of this reply is bob replies i.e.
* Bob has decided that nuclear
☻/ / \ warheads are the only way to fix youtube.
/▌ | ☢ | Copy and Paste(ctrl+v) this all over youtube
/ \ // | | \\ to completely obliterate Google+
* Bob has decided that nuclear
☻/ / \ warheads are the only way to fix youtube.
/▌ | ☢ | Copy and Paste(ctrl+v) this all over youtube
/ \ // | | \\ to completely obliterate Google+
kojakfull
Senior Member
- Jan 13, 2008
- 852
- 1,055
They are updating their system again. I cant even comment from my main account on some videos.
Always have this error "There was a problem saving your comment. Please try again." http://productforums.google.com/forum/#!topic/youtube/HCWx7p5Yzhw