Ooooookay...now we're speaking my language. I'm going to tell it like it is, so don't get offended. If you guys like a cologne and it works for you, great. However, let me offer a different perspective.
Out of this list, Tom Ford's are the best. I think you (and most guys) need to up your game in the fragrance department; this means, do not always buy your cologne at a department store because you'll end up spending your life smelling like every other new college grad with $100 in his pocket.
My $.02...find a rare scent that is your signature...brand yourself, be different. Start with Galimard or Fragonard, the oldest perfumiers on the planet, and from Grasse,FR, the mecca of scents. If you insist on buying stuff at a dept. store, head to Saks or Neimann Marcus or Barneys and check out Bond no.9 collection. Go to basenotes and read! Also, search for Subster here, he's a BHW donor, totally legit and BIG in fragrances...super nice dude too. Good luck mate...don't settle for normal!