Ok guys, you have run with the fantasy a bit withme destroyimg someones life etc.
Here is how it was:
I was #1 for this keyword for lets say 3 years now. Its a high authroiity site with lots of daily users, not a single black hat technique was used on it and the deisgn is pixel perfect.
In august my site was pushed to position #2 because some wordpress makeshift blog became the top one. It's just a standart MFA site with lots of ads above the fold and a lot of keyword stuffing at the bottom.
This is the case where no content quality etc will help you because your site is 1000 times better anyway. this was just a google bug. And what should I be doing? Wait and hope that another update fixes this?
As for the "he is now broke, his kids are starving" etc:
a) this keywrd didnt bring more money then like 20$ a day
b) its not like this site was #1 for some time and became his main business (it was #1 for just 2 months now)
Yes, this is what people that lack talent and work ethic do to get ahead. good for you.
I was actually the one who had the talent and did the hardwork. This guy got lucky
Are you still thinking its unethical?