I'd atleast run it by a lawyer and see what they say, maybe they can make it worth your while with limited to nothing out of pocket if they feel they have a solid case even if he is a loon and getting money from the state.
He's not smarter - he's just obsessive and has no job or life and lives off of welfare so he can spend 8 or 12 hours a day online harassing his invented enemies and building links to his attack pages. I'm not screaming, I'm looking for some practical advice (and thanks to those who have given it) and possibly some assistance from someone who has some knowledge on how to deal with situations like this. The police here don't really understand the internet or care about online harassment or cyberbullying unless someone actually threatens physical harm - he doesn't actually utter threats. As for suing - yeah, if someone is seriously defaming you and trying to hurt your reputation and your livelihood why wouldn't I want to sue him?
In such a case it should be very easy to outrank him. Your name is a low competition keyword in the terms of SEO. Since I don't know your name I'll use John Dow as an example. Register yourself on the following networks, with 'johndow' as username:
- wordpress
- naymz
- identi.ca
- tumblr
- livejournal
- digg
- blogger
If the username is taken use 'johndow1/2/3/4/etc' Interlink everything, e.q. put links from wordpress to the rest of sites with your variations of your name as anchor text. For example 'Follow John Dow on Twitter'. Write some content that is relevant to you wherever is needed (may be resume).
If in 2 weeks you do not rank above your bad review, add more sites to the network. The bad review should fall off pretty quick.
I'm not in the SEO or online business - that's why I'm here.
This is a very good idea... also, how about blasting him with AA blog comments all with anchor texts as names -- that should bring him down after the latest penguin update. You will however have to create the social pages above with the same name (anchor text) he's targeting ... you blast him with AA, he can blast your profiles all he wants but not even a million spammy backlinks can really hurt FB ranking.
I like all of the suggestions here but I'd beat the fuck out of this guy. Literally these kind of tax sucking asswipes need to be put down for the long nap.