you have half baked information.
.org does suspends domains for copyright/DMCA. https://www.blackhatworld.com/seo/domain-extension-that-ignore-dmca-complain.1332175/.
only some cctlds ignore DMCA including .to, .so, .su, .ru etc. and some european cctlds like Luxembourg's etc.
easydns can do nothing if I contact the .com registry and ask them to suspend domain "serverhold status" and it gets suspended at registry. No need to go to Ontario court to get a written order. I've already taken down many such domains across many registrar asking my clients to file DMCA with registry or directly send them subpoena through a lawyer. In said circumstances the registry puts hold on the domain. And your registrar easydns is of no help in this situation.
IF a copyright holder sends DMCA to easydns and according to their TOS, they actively act upon DMCA complaint (though they are Canadian) and forward your the DMCA and you have to take down the content. Too many DMCA piling up for your domain, easydns will ask you to move out. (this is as per their TOS clauses). Please read them. So they are not safe or reliable domain registrar at all.
I would recommend to avoid easydns.
Namesilo is quite reliable than easydns. They don't act upon DMCA unless you use their web hosting. If you only have domain, they ask the copyright holder to go to hosting provider. As suggested by
@brownsofts here. Even
the-online.com,
nicenic.net,
ourdomain.com,
gandi.net (europe) etc follow policies like namesilo. But when they too will receive notification from domain registry, like Verisign for .com/.net, that the copyright holder has filed DMCA/subpoena with at Registry level, the registry will keep the domain on "hold".
For nicenic.net, one has to send registered copyright certificate from any Government authority. So if someone copies your image, text, blogpost, logo, etc and you don't have registered it that is you don't have physical copyright certificate that shows your are the sole owner of that piece of content, then nicenic will not act on DMCA/copyright complaints at all. I've first hand experience with them too!
Yes, I know that registries like .org supercedes registrars like easyDNS. I was under the impression that .org was DMCA ignored until presented with a US court order, but I guess I was wrong. My bad.
Yes, I know that certain ccTLDs are way better, but I didn't mention them since easyDNS doesn't register any DMCA ignored ccTLDs on their own, they just resell Tucows for those.
.to is DMCA ignored until they get served a US court order since Tonic is based in the US. I know of a piracy forum that got their .to domain suspended and I've read on BlackHatWorld about someone else getting their .to domain suspended for copyright infringement.
.so is not DMCA ignored: https://torrentfreak.com/so-registry-bans-more-kickasstorrents-domains-150304/
I assumed that part of their ToS was mostly to cover their own ass since most DMCA ignored domain registrars and hosting providers say that copyright infringement is not allowed. My bad again.
I'd like to find something outside of the US, so NameSilo is not for me.
I think I've read on LowEndTalk that Gandi is not DMCA ignored, but sensible about it. I could be wrong though. The only piracy site I know that used Gandi was a private tracker and they don't have the same DMCA issues that public sites have.
NiceNIC sounds nice (lol), but the Chinese Communist Party really does not like online piracy to the point that they have state-sponsored hackers go after Chinese piracy sites. I know of a Chinese-run private tracker for anime that has to go into lockdown mode whenever Chinese government crackdowns are happening, so you can't log in unless you've exported your cookies for that site. Then there was this case: https://torrentfreak.com/china-shuts-down-major-manga-piracy-site-following-complaint-from-japan-230329/
My guess is that the CCP is pissed that they don't get any sales tax from people who just download stuff for free. I'm guessing NiceNIC is really run out of China with a Hong Kong front company like a lot of other international Chinese businesses. At least the phone number they have on ICANN's website is a Chinese phone number: https://www.icann.org/en/accredited-registrars?page=1&iana-number=3765&view-all=true
I've registered my domains with these non-US offshore domain registrars since years.
Best one's:
- http://nicenic.net/ (HK)
- https://the-online.com/ (NL)
- ourdomains (HK)
- shinjiru (MY) though they seem to discontinue domain registrations now.
- gransy / subreg (CZ)
- eranet / todaynic .com
- hexonet / 1API (DE)
Bad one's: (they suspend domains)
- njal.la
- ownregistrar (India)
- easydns (Canada)
- onlinenic.com (not safe anymore)
OurDomains seems to be run out of China as well according to ICANN: https://www.icann.org/en/accredited-registrars?page=1&iana-number=1654&view-all=true
I've seen evidence of Subreg being DMCA ignored, but I've also seen evidence of Subreg suspending piracy domains. Either way it does not seem competent nor reliable:
Locked ExtraTorrent out of Subreg's control panel + either Subreg or the registries stripped the domains of their A records, turning them useless: https://torrentfreak.com/extratorrent-loses-three-mirror-domain-names-161109/
Blindly following an obviously fake report + their WHOIS contact system rejecting emails sent using Gmail from reaching the contact email: https://blog.archive.today/tagged/domain
It took Subreg eight days to forward an abuse notice from the registry, at which point the registry had already suspended the domain: https://www.namepros.com/threads/incels-me-gets-its-domain-suspended-by-me-registry-over-hate-speech.1108366/page-2#post-6986961
The-Online is based in the US, not in the Netherlands.
Shinjuru sometimes ignores DMCA, sometimes not from what I've read on hosting forums. It also seems like Malaysia is starting to really crack down on piracy: https://torrentfreak.com/malaysia-passes-bill-to-imprison-illegal-streaming-pirates-for-up-to-20-years-211218/
Regarding HEXONET / 1API, I'm not sure how much I'd trust a German company with a piracy domain. They tend to be extremely strict about piracy in Germany.
Do you have any experience with R01, Reg.com / Reg.ru, or Webnames.ru / Regtime?
PDR is shit. I had just send 3 DMCA to them for copying my content, they took down the whole domain (server hold). And same is their Radix registry. they too did the same. They don't even investigate. So if you are registering domains like .shop, .store, .online, .pw, and many more operated by Radix registry, then one DMCA to them and your domain is locked! So avoid them.
Radix is even worse than that, they have automated systems determine if your domain is likely to be used for abuse and legitimate companies have gotten their domains suspended because of this: https://webmasters.stackexchange.com/questions/128197/our-domain-was-suspended-by-registry-due-to-potential-abuse
More incompetency: https://support.google.com/webmasters/thread/16247048?hl=en&msgid=16248743
They also voluntarily co-operate with the MPAA: https://torrentfreak.com/mpaa-signs-anti-piracy-deal-with-large-domain-registry-160413/
NameSilo - Netherlands, Gandi, OVH-French these are trusted
NameSilo is a US-registered company that is mostly run out of Canada, not the Netherlands.
OVH does not ignore DMCA. Their abuse report system just sucks so much that they don't get the abuse reports for their hosting side from what I've heard.