Youtube comments problem

Scorpion Ghost

Elite Member
Executive VIP
Jr. VIP
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
9,204
Reaction score
10,500
I did some comments on a Youtube video with some channels I have, and 2 comments didn't go through. They're visible to the channel that made the comment, but not to anyone else.

So I had a friend post the same comment, not visible. Had another friend post the comment with a little change in the text, not visible. Then again, not visible.

What the hell is Youtube's problem?
 
Comment is getting ghosted. Why? It could be a few different reasons, but do this to get a better success rate.

1. Use an active channel(Being used to watch videos, don't need to upload)
2. Watch min. 1 minute of the video before you comment
3. Don't post links(ofc)
4. Avoid spammy words

You can get away with a lot of shit as long as you do step 1 and 2.
 
If you don't watch at least 180 Seconds
Your comment won't show
This i noticed recently
 
Comment is getting ghosted. Why? It could be a few different reasons, but do this to get a better success rate.

1. Use an active channel(Being used to watch videos, don't need to upload)
2. Watch min. 1 minute of the video before you comment
3. Don't post links(ofc)
4. Avoid spammy words

You can get away with a lot of shit as long as you do step 1 and 2.

Good advice. But i tried all that and youtube just wont let it stick.

Anyway, good and valid info, thanks for looking out.
 
If you don't watch at least 180 Seconds
Your comment won't show
This i noticed recently

What if the video is shorter than 180 seconds? Do i need to watch it twice?

Haha no no. I did 8 comments successfully without even playing the video. All stuck.

But 2 comments didnt, and no matter what i try those 2 comments will not stick.

One of the comments is literally "hdhjsdbdhdisjdd"

Lol
 
Good advice. But i tried all that and youtube just wont let it stick.

Anyway, good and valid info, thanks for looking out.
Have you tried the same comment on a different channel? Some channels have added an insane amount of words to their spam filter. That's my last idea to solving the issue.. Good luck.

Edit: Saw your post above now, that's weird. Maybe too many comments in a short period if it's all from the same channel?
 
Have you tried the same comment on a different channel? Some channels have added an insane amount of words to their spam filter. That's my last idea to solving the issue.. Good luck.

Edit: Saw your post above now, that's weird. Maybe too many comments in a short period if it's all from the same channel?

Nah. I had people from different countried/IPs/channels post, and still Youtube hid them.

One of the people i had to it didnt obey me and posted a random comment, and it went through. But then i told them to edit the comment and make it what i wanted it to be, and next thing you know the comment was gone.

This specific comment had the word "subscribe" in it, so maybe that burned it. Not sure. But no link or any spam really.

Youtube should chill. Too strict.
 
Nah. I had people from different countried/IPs/channels post, and still Youtube hid them.

One of the people i had to it didnt obey me and posted a random comment, and it went through. But then i told them to edit the comment and make it what i wanted it to be, and next thing you know the comment was gone.

This specific comment had the word "subscribe" in it, so maybe that burned it. Not sure. But no link or any spam really.

Youtube should chill. Too strict.
You can try this way something like this
Me: This video is hot 0:20
ME: (Your random comment)
This works for me flawlessly
 
Happens many times some comments are visible get replies and likes, some comments gets ghosted

some comments are not visible to public - spent time on searching 1000+ comments from another account

Yt may have spam score for channel profiles :confused:
 
So just to say, it seems that success is higher if you like the video/subscribe to the channel/watch the video for a while and then do the comment.

Also, it seems there are certain keywords that are more likely to get you ghosted, such as "subscribe" and "like" and surely many others.
 
Likely moderation - I think like Facebook, you can enter certain words to be held for moderation - bigger Youtube creators have extended permissions.

If you look up James Charles - his youtube comments auto-mods anything containing keywords around the accusations that he's a kid diddler.
 
Bumping this cause been having the same issue.

I think y'all are onto something. I believe another factor that YT is implementing to restrict comments from "sus" accounts is due to the comment spam that's been going on in a lot of creators' videos where they pretend to be the creator and direct the user to contact them via Whatsapp in order to achieve "financial freedom".
 
Nah. I had people from different countried/IPs/channels post, and still Youtube hid them.

One of the people i had to it didnt obey me and posted a random comment, and it went through. But then i told them to edit the comment and make it what i wanted it to be, and next thing you know the comment was gone.

This specific comment had the word "subscribe" in it, so maybe that burned it. Not sure. But no link or any spam really.

Youtube should chill. Too strict.

lol, you should read the youtube TOS before doing business with youtube....The words like subscribe me, like me, follow me etc are black listed by youtube and mark as spam
 
lol, you should read the youtube TOS before doing business with youtube....The words like subscribe me, like me, follow me etc are black listed by youtube and mark as spam

Yeah, right, I'll read a billion words that were written in a way that no one can understand. I'll get right on that. I wouldn't read anyone's tos if they paid me for it.

Trial and error boys, trial and error does it.
 
It is necessary to watch the movie about 3 minutes if it is a long movie, it is best not to give links. For mass commenting on the video, use a YouTube account with a good cookie history
 
Back
Top