Charly The Rabbit
Junior Member
- Feb 17, 2016
- 166
- 49
I love this forum, people are very creative finding ways to make money online. I would neve thought about this youtube comenting method 
Youtube commenting
- Thread starter blommas
- Start date
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Haha, a lot of people struggle to earn just $1Hes talking about how hes having trouble and people are still begging him for his method
ThanksI love this forum, people are very creative finding ways to make money online. I would neve thought about this youtube comenting method
And yeah, a lot of really creative people here.I'm actually on $2.75 today(really surprised as I only earned $1.96 yesterday and I haven't posted any more comments today). I expect more earnings and especially from US, because it's only 2 PM OGAds time. The problem is that I don't know which account is ghosted (got 3 accounts), so I won't waste time trying to figure it out. Got 2 accounts (PVA) that I'll try out later tonight. Still not sure whether I'm going to use a bot or not, because I want to play it safe
Last edited:
stallion45d
Power Member
- Oct 11, 2011
- 735
- 464
Long time ago I played the YT commenting game when It was profitable and easy. At the end of 2013 , YT changed the system and made quite harder. My suggestions are:
- Use live links and domains that are blacklisted (check them before setting the bot to spam)
- Post 2 comments per account
- Use proxies or your home dinamic ip ( this will save you money in proxies )
- Always clear cookies and flash cookies before using a new account.
To check if your comments are being ghosted, use a second PC or device WHICH IS CONNECTED BY A DIFFERENT IP than the one you are posting with.
A good way to reduce the account suspended rate is promoting a wide range of products or CPA Offers instead of focusing on a few ones. YT is able to detect if 100% of your comments are spam. Also post "empty " comments on dead videos to show the system a human behavior.
good luck
- Use live links and domains that are blacklisted (check them before setting the bot to spam)
- Post 2 comments per account
- Use proxies or your home dinamic ip ( this will save you money in proxies )
- Always clear cookies and flash cookies before using a new account.
To check if your comments are being ghosted, use a second PC or device WHICH IS CONNECTED BY A DIFFERENT IP than the one you are posting with.
A good way to reduce the account suspended rate is promoting a wide range of products or CPA Offers instead of focusing on a few ones. YT is able to detect if 100% of your comments are spam. Also post "empty " comments on dead videos to show the system a human behavior.
good luck
raylewis98
Regular Member
- Nov 21, 2012
- 351
- 171
once reported spam, youre account for sure is a candidate or automatically ghosted....
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Great tips. 2 comments per account seems too low though
Yeah.. I still get a bit of traffic from old comments, even though a lot have been ghosted
stallion45d
Power Member
- Oct 11, 2011
- 735
- 464
I don´t know exactly how the commenting systems works now. I can remember from the past, that one unique account could not maintain more than +/-10 lives comments once it´s flagged as " suspicious activity account " by YT. So once you post the 11th comment from the same account the first comment you posted yesterday/ before yesterday / a week ago will disappear . That´s why you need plenty of accounts to make this method profitable.
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Oh really? I'll keep that in mind
Maybe I have to buy loads of accounts then
jack_kuli
BANNED
- Aug 28, 2016
- 489
- 90
My idea : If you do not want the comments disappeared , Then , Per Account Just use to post 2-3 comments , Chang IP - Useragent - Browser when use another account ...
moonshine7000
Elite Member
- Mar 4, 2013
- 4,356
- 4,006
Is your comment in the make money niche?
How are you monetizing the comments ?
stallion45d
Power Member
- Oct 11, 2011
- 735
- 464
Oh really? I'll keep that in mind
As soon as I posted my previous reply, another thing came back to my mind:
YT algo does protect high traffic videos from spammers. The comment algo system is able to detect whether in a short period many live links have been posted on a video. It does matter if it´s you using many accounts or you and many of your competitors posting at the same time and trying to steal traffic from viral videos.
And I think is not necessary to say this as many of you already know it, but anyway : Always target the proper videos that match with the shit you promote. A weight loss offer will never make a sale on 50cents video even if it has 1.000.000 daily views.
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Seems like too much of a hassle, I'll try 10-20 comments per account and see how it turns out
no, CPA/content locking
Hm, that's a good anti-spam system..It's probably true as some of my comments are still alive. I think most comments stay for a day before they automatically remove them though
I target people who are looking for exactly what I offer
jack_kuli
BANNED
- Aug 28, 2016
- 489
- 90
Good luck !
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Thank you. I'll try it out in a few minutes
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Just posted a link on a new account on the video ranking 1st for a keyword in my niche, and I checked if it was there on another browser.. The comment wasn't there, and the video had over 1m views, so I guess I should just avoid the top 3 videos. Couldn't see any other spammy comments with links on the video either
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Maybe, but the traffic isn't very targeted.. Who would click a random link that looks so spammy..You're using malicious browser extensions to run your last project , right?
BTW what you would say that is the current main factor to rank a comment in the top? account age/subscribers/total views count of the comment poster or that doesn't care and the important factor are comment replies + thumb ups given to a comment?
P.S. Look at this guy:
I'm sure he's banking $$$.Code:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VmRM0IAm_qU&lc=z13xwf4quxrue1cjs04cjrrhuraxg5sxhyg0k
I don't understand how he can have 4+ of the same comment on 1 video with the same account without getting ghosted/banned
Automation247
Regular Member
- Jan 21, 2014
- 485
- 196
Are you sure that his traffic isn't very targeted?? look at the avatar of the latest comment and then look to the video uploader avatar... dumb persons will think that comment is posted from the original video uploader.
blommas
Senior Member
- Jun 14, 2014
- 904
- 158
Maybe, but I would be surprised if that many people were stupid