YouTube Comment Rater? (bot or service?)

PhilipZeplin · Jan 28, 2014

Hey there!

I was wondering if anyone knew of a working YouTube comment rater bot or service?
I used to use ViralSocials, but they've gone downhill, and seems to not function at all anymore.
I've searched around on good ol' Google, but found nothing of use. At best, I found a few (quite expensive) bots.

Anyone know of any working services or cheaper bots?

Tommy Lawrence · Jan 28, 2014

PhilipZeplin said:
I was wondering if anyone knew of a working YouTube comment rater bot or service?

What exactly do you mean by YouTube comment rater?

lexa500 · Jan 28, 2014

I think he meant some tool to promote spammy links comments on yt. This is not working anymore, right?

Posted via Topify using iPhone/iPad

PhilipZeplin · Jan 28, 2014

lexa500 said:
I think he meant some tool to promote spammy links comments on yt. This is not working anymore, right?

Well, yes and no. I tend to post a lot on YouTube, and with the new addition of G+, I could actually link relevant articles and posts in some cases.

I quite often reach highest comments on videos automatically, but certainly wouldn't mind a little extra boost now and then.

But yes, I am looking for a bot/service that can "Thumbs Up" specific comments on YouTube.

Tommy Lawrence · Jan 28, 2014

PhilipZeplin said:
I quite often reach highest comments on videos automatically, but certainly wouldn't mind a little extra boost now and then

Don't even bother giving thumbs up to your comments. It doesn't affect the ranking of a comment whatsoever, since the YouTube and Google+ integration.

Automation247 · Jan 28, 2014

"I found a few (quite expensive) bots."

Nobody will give you a WORKING bot for free.

PhilipZeplin · Jan 28, 2014

Tommy Lawrence said:
Don't even bother giving thumbs up to your comments. It doesn't affect the ranking of a comment whatsoever, since the YouTube and Google+ integration.

My personal experience is quite different

Automation247 said:
Nobody will give you a WORKING bot for free.

Good thing I never asked for free!

ORM · Jan 28, 2014

Are you really getting any traffic from those upvoted comments?

Tommy Lawrence · Jan 28, 2014

PhilipZeplin said:
My personal experience is quite different

You're speaking from a point of ignorance. Get your facts straight and accept good advice when it is given to you

PhilipZeplin · Jan 29, 2014

Tommy Lawrence said:
You're speaking from a point of ignorance. Get your facts straight and accept good advice when it is given to you

I'm sorry if I'll take personal experience over random unvalidated advice from someone I don't know.
I'm sure you would do the same.
(and for a little note: "good advice" usually entails more than someone just going "don't do it, won't work")

Arturas said:
Are you really getting any traffic from those upvoted comments?

As I noted in the start, I haven't really started adding a lot of links yet. Which is why I'm curious to test it out more. I usually have activity on about 15 replies/comments a day (either +1's, replies to mine, etc.), and many are on the top, so could be decent.

stharthjw6j · Jan 29, 2014

PhilipZeplin said:
I'm sorry if I'll take personal experience over random unvalidated advice from someone I don't know.
I'm sure you would do the same.
(and for a little note: "good advice" usually entails more than someone just going "don't do it, won't work")

Loooooooooool, we appreciate you Tommy

Tommy Lawrence · Jan 29, 2014

PhilipZeplin said:
I'm sorry if I'll take personal experience over random unvalidated advice from someone I don't know.

Does anyone else here agree with this user's strong belief that thumbs up to comments affect their ranking in the Top Comments section on YouTube?

donnyhue · Feb 12, 2014

bro. he is saying his experience. you lost the arguement. If someone has a personal experience then what ever someone says against that will lose. If i lost weight eating 3 noodles a day and someone says that wont work, but i have personal exerience backing it up my whole life. i'm right.

Tommy Lawrence · Feb 12, 2014

donnyhue said:
bro. he is saying his experience. you lost the arguement. If someone has a personal experience then what ever someone says against that will lose. If i lost weight eating 3 noodles a day and someone says that wont work, but i have personal exerience backing it up my whole life. i'm right.

WTF?! OK whatever.

achraf · Jun 15, 2014

i m sorry man but you are totally wrong , in my experience also thumbs up works , no offence but don t make yourself like u are a pro, you also need advices

itank27 · Aug 21, 2014

In my opinion (and experience) I do believe that thumbing up comments does affect your comment ranking. That being said, the effect it has was dramatically diminished with the G+ inegration, but that does NOT mean that it no longer contributes to the ranking, just to a lesser extent than before.

One of the main factors for YouTube comment ranking today includes your channel authority (i.e. how many subscribers you have/how popular your videos are), how often you comment, how many replies you get to your comments, number of G+ followers, possibly even the length of your comment and so on...

but no one really knows for sure so lets stop arguing now.

PistonV · Aug 22, 2014

Can anyone give me some links to working bot? I can't find them.

knuckles215 · Aug 24, 2014

Hello - can you please tell me which ones you've found? I have had no luck and really wanted to get my hands on some.

Automation247 said:
"I found a few (quite expensive) bots."

Nobody will give you a WORKING bot for free.

YouTube Comment Rater? (bot or service?)

Newbie

Senior Member

Registered Member

Newbie

Senior Member

Regular Member

Newbie

Power Member

Senior Member

Newbie

BANNED

Senior Member

Newbie

Senior Member

Newbie

Junior Member

Newbie

Newbie

Main Menu

Marketplace

Making Money

BlackHat World