Scrapebox = gets you lots of links that are 98% no follow or 98% PR 0.
Xrumer = gets you lots of links that wont get indexed or are PR N/A.
Conclusion?
Matt Cutts wins.
lol... I tend to agree with this.
I see both tools as essential to BH SEO, particularly Scrapebox, in its harvesting abilities and many, many other uses, e.g. mass PR check, blog analyzer, and so forth. But these are just raw tools. It's like complaining that your house hasn't been built automatically, because you've got the world's best drill but it still takes a lot of work on your part to do the building. You've got to figure out where to put things, how to position things, how to integrate things. Basically use all the functions of the tools to your advantage, often in quite a complex and elaborate way, to finally reach your goals.
I think more than anyone else on the internet, Sweetfunny has single handedly spammed the entire internet full of nofollow links and rendered the few BlogEngine or (gulp) Do-F0llow wordpress blogs, completely spammed and useless. What is the answer to this problem, if the auto blog posting of Scrapebox is rendered practically useless except for very low competition keywords or just a 'blast and hope' effort on your link network, after all you just press a button and it does it automatically, 20,000 comments no problem. (Precisely the reason, incidentally, it has been rendered useless.) Well, the answer in this new decade is becoming apparent.
DO SOMETHING DIFFERENT. SPAM SMART. Blasting nofollow comments with Scrapebox is like firing off a shotgun at a deer 300 meters away. F*king useless. But if you carefully plan, plan your route, select your target...
BE A SNIPER. Otherwise Matt Cutts will always hold your balls in his grimey hands. He will always have the power with his little glasses and gay ass beard. He has probably never touched a vagina in his life apart from his mother's, yet he wields power over our lives which makes us angry.
We need to channel that anger and spam smart. Be a sniper, not a retarded oaf with buck teeth blasting his shotgun at thin air hoping to hit something. My rules:
1. SPAM SMART
2. BE A SNIPER, NOT A SHOTGUN MANIAC
3. MOVE WITH THE TIMES. SEO IS EVER CHANGING, FULLY DYNAMIC
4. INDEX YOUR LINKS. XRUMER IS EFFECTIVE WHEN YOU INDEX THOSE F*KING LINKS. GET BACKLINK ENERGIZER, BOOKMARK / PING / SCRAPEBOX BLAST YOUR WEB 2.0'S AND THEY WILL GET INDEXED. USE SCRAPEBOX SHITTY NOFOLLOW LINKS TO INDEX YOUR PROFILE LINKS.
5. LOOK AT MY AVATAR. IT IS EMMA WATSON'S BUSH.
AND FINALLY,
F*K MATT CUNTS. F*K HIM TO HELL. LOVE, BHW.