Also I should mention since I have got sick it rocks cause fiverr can do drip feed,and all you have to do is get packets and start working with it. If you have any issues with the software support is there to help unlike BMD although they are improving.
Not sure why you compare Sick with BMD. I have both, and they do entirely different things for me.
Sick (was) my directory, forum and article tool. BMD does my 22,000 pligg and scuttle sites.
End of the day, both tools work well, but Sick has people regularly updating the packets, so If you can't be bothered to scrape your own, Sick has the advantage of community updates for bookmarking.
But for ease of use I used to use BMD with my own scraped sites. Very similar success, the advantage of scraping your own sites is fresh lists that no-one else is using. The disadvantage is the time it takes.
I find sicks GUI a pain in the ass though. Everything is so granular inside. If you are time rich and cash poor though, I would get it - and a couple of good packets.
If you know how to scrape and update your own lists, I'd move on to another product and Sick's interface and work flow is about the worst I've come across. Every packet needs to hgave instructions read "fill this in" "leave this blank" "Set IE on" "Enable Java".."Don't enable Java" and all that crap.
I prefer a tool that already KNOWS that simply by the footprint it's working with. You press "Go" and it makes the right choices for you.
Being a programmer by trade for years, and like many people educated and employed in a field for decades, I now tire of doing simple checking and code tasks that I think subscription software should just "do" for you.
I save my pregramming vigour for my own projects, not for pissing about with penny-ante linking tools.
All that said, sick is a good choice for budget IMers and those with the patience to code their own packets (not just find sites for existing - but use "sick builder") but Ubot and Zenno do this a hell of a lot better and quicker.
Scritty