Which takes more effort NICHE EDITS or GUEST POSTING?

Sarah Mathews

Sarah Mathews

Senior Member
Jr. VIP
Joined
Sep 1, 2009
Messages
1,163
Reaction score
280
Good day guys,

Both niche edits and guest posts can be effective, but each comes with different challenges.

Niche edit difficulties:

Finding a highly relevant existing article
Getting the site owner to approve the link
Finding a natural place for the link
Dealing with high prices
Checking whether the existing page has real traffic and rankings

Guest post difficulties:

Finding quality websites that accept guest posts
Getting a response from site owners
Creating unique and relevant content
Negotiating price and requirements
Getting the article published and indexed

My question:

For those who have done both, which is harder to execute successfully niche edits or guest posts?
What part of the process causes you the most difficulty?
 
Advertise on BHW
Sarah Mathews said:
Good day guys,

Both niche edits and guest posts can be effective, but each comes with different challenges.

Niche edit difficulties:

Finding a highly relevant existing article
Getting the site owner to approve the link
Finding a natural place for the link
Dealing with high prices
Checking whether the existing page has real traffic and rankings

Guest post difficulties:

Finding quality websites that accept guest posts
Getting a response from site owners
Creating unique and relevant content
Negotiating price and requirements
Getting the article published and indexed

My question:

For those who have done both, which is harder to execute successfully niche edits or guest posts?
What part of the process causes you the most difficulty?
Click to expand...
Guest posts are harder in my opinion ,because you have to negotiate with a lot of website owners in order to be featured on their websites.
 
For me, guest posts take more overall effort simply because of the content creation. You've got to pitch the topic, wait for approval, write a solid piece, then make sure it actually gets published and indexed. It just eats up a lot of hours in the day.

Niche edits are faster to execute once you secure the spot, but finding an existing, high traffic page that perfectly matches your link is the hardest part of the whole process. Nailing that exact relevance is tough and site owners often overcharge for it.

Overall, guest posting is more heavy lifting on the creation side, while niche edits are purely a hunt and negotiate game.
 
For me niche edits take more effort because finding a genuinely relevant page with real traffic and a natural link placement can be difficult Guest posts are usually easier to scale once you have reliable sites and outreach contacts
 
Difficulty comes in when good of money is asked for a link placement. Guest posts and Niche edits which are free takes less efforts.
 
I'd say guest posting seems like it takes more effort overall finding a good website writing relevant content and waiting for approval feels like a longer process i am curious to hear which part others find the most challenging
 
For me, niche edits are more of a headache. Finding the right existing page and getting a natural placement can take way more digging than writing a guest post.
 
For me niche edits are harder because finding a relevant existing page with real traffic and getting a natural placement takes more time

Guest posting is easier to scale once you have good sites and outreach contacts
 
bro both are tough but guest posts win the difficulty award lol. niche edits are annoying but at least the content exists. guest posts? you gotta create everything from thin air. respect for doing both - you're a true link building warrior. keep grinding.
 
Usually, guest posting takes more effort.

Niche edit: Find a relevant existing page → negotiate placement → add the link naturally. Faster if you already have good sites.
Guest post: Find a site → outreach → topic approval → write/create content → edit → publish → add the link. More steps.
 
Andrew_w said:
bro both are tough but guest posts win the difficulty award lol. niche edits are annoying but at least the content exists. guest posts? you gotta create everything from thin air. respect for doing both - you're a true link building warrior. keep grinding.
Click to expand...
Haha, absolutely bro Link building definitely tests our patience, but we keep grinding.
BlackShield said:
Usually, guest posting takes more effort.

Niche edit: Find a relevant existing page → negotiate placement → add the link naturally. Faster if you already have good sites.
Guest post: Find a site → outreach → topic approval → write/create content → edit → publish → add the link. More steps.
Click to expand...
Yeah bro, I agree guest posting usually takes more effort overall. But I would say niche edits need more analyzing before you place the link
 
For me niche edits take more effort because finding a relevant page with real traffic and a natural placement is harder Guest posts are easier to scale once you have quality sites
 
Niche edits take less effort per link but more effort to find. Guest posts are the reverse, easy to find sites that accept them, hours to write something they will actually publish.

The thing nobody mentions is that niche edits on old articles often sit on pages that have not been crawled in months. The link exists but it takes ages to count. Guest posts get crawled on publish. Worth factoring in if you need the link to register quickly.
 
Sarah Mathews said:
Good day guys,

Both niche edits and guest posts can be effective, but each comes with different challenges.

Niche edit difficulties:

Finding a highly relevant existing article
Getting the site owner to approve the link
Finding a natural place for the link
Dealing with high prices
Checking whether the existing page has real traffic and rankings

Guest post difficulties:

Finding quality websites that accept guest posts
Getting a response from site owners
Creating unique and relevant content
Negotiating price and requirements
Getting the article published and indexed

My question:

For those who have done both, which is harder to execute successfully niche edits or guest posts?
What part of the process causes you the most difficulty?
Click to expand...
i think guest post is hard thing to do, for niche edit you are to just get a link but in guest post you will provie full article and you can spend money on article writing etc, so guest post is hard and time taking and also give you benefit to publisher website but at the same time very effective
 
Sarah Mathews said:
Good day guys,

Both niche edits and guest posts can be effective, but each comes with different challenges.

Niche edit difficulties:

Finding a highly relevant existing article
Getting the site owner to approve the link
Finding a natural place for the link
Dealing with high prices
Checking whether the existing page has real traffic and rankings

Guest post difficulties:

Finding quality websites that accept guest posts
Getting a response from site owners
Creating unique and relevant content
Negotiating price and requirements
Getting the article published and indexed

My question:

For those who have done both, which is harder to execute successfully niche edits or guest posts?
What part of the process causes you the most difficulty?
Click to expand...
I’d say niche edits take a little more effort since finding the right existing page can be tricky... guest posting feels more straightforward to me depending on the niche...
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top