Which backlinks is more valuable 2 PBN or 10 Profile backlinks

If PBN sites are high potent with good quality, then go with PBN backlinks. It's worthy

I have done many tests for the last 12-16 months. 2 websites in the same niche, different fresh domains, same wordpress setup, same articles (manually rewritten with 100% unique content). Every website has 25 articles.

First Website:
- 1 PBN link to root Domain
- 1 PBN link to an Article

Second Website:
- 5 high authority do-follow profile links to root Domain
- 5 high authority... links to an Article

Guess what? ;-) Second Website has a higher crawling rate, all 25 articles are indexed within 14 days and ranked good after 21 days. First website needed over 20 days for indexing, lower crawling rate, and only the article with PBN link is well ranked, other Articles are between serp position 60-90.

My conclusion: high authority do-follow links have a lot of impact when done right.

Please note: all my tests were done with very low competition keywords to see possible effects.

2 pbns would be better , because these days the profile links are hard to index and some are nofollow as well .

EmmaEdward said:

which backlinks has more importance in google

Click to expand...

PBN, if they are of good quality and have a clean link profile.

PBN

Sincerely,
The Data Scientist

WEB 2.0 and Guest post.

It would depend of what's the quality of the PBN. If it's well maintained, high-quality PBN then yes, PBN it is.

Between PBN and profile, PBN is more important than profile.

Linksinventor said:

Every backlink have their value but PBN is surely more valuable because it connect you with more people more traffic

Click to expand...

JMSSEOSERVICE said:

Between PBN and profile, PBN is more important than profile.

Click to expand...

Quite clearly by your choice of usernames you're going spam/waffle to 100 posts to upgrade to sell links, but you offer zero value here in these replies.

The majority of PBN link sellers have pure garbage from expired domains, hence the links cost 50c or $1 a link.

There are 2 or 3 PBN sellers who use auctioned domains, and their links are decent.

Read the replies above from @Steptoe and @ownz

ownz said:

when done right

Click to expand...

This is the most important

These links may not hold as much value as profile or PBN links, but Profile links could help improve your domain authority. Try other manual outreach links like guest posting, curated links, or expert roundup links.

It's like comparing apples and oranges.

There are PBN links that are toxic, you wouldn't want them pointed at you at all.

And there are some profile site links that can be incredibly strong... must-have social profiles come to mind here.

So it really just depends!

ownz said:

I have done many tests for the last 12-16 months. 2 websites in the same niche, different fresh domains, same wordpress setup, same articles (manually rewritten with 100% unique content). Every website has 25 articles.

First Website:
- 1 PBN link to root Domain
- 1 PBN link to an Article

Second Website:
- 5 high authority do-follow profile links to root Domain
- 5 high authority... links to an Article

Guess what? ;-) Second Website has a higher crawling rate, all 25 articles are indexed within 14 days and ranked good after 21 days. First website needed over 20 days for indexing, lower crawling rate, and only the article with PBN link is well ranked, other Articles are between serp position 60-90.

My conclusion: high authority do-follow links have a lot of impact when done right.

Please note: all my tests were done with very low competition keywords to see possible effects.

Click to expand...

what is the quality of the pbns? there is only 1 outgoing link on the pbns?
it is therefore also necessary to compare the price

In general, it's difficult to say which type of backlink is more valuable without more context. However, it's worth noting that both private blog network (PBN) backlinks and profile backlinks can be risky if not used correctly.

PBN backlinks are essentially links from a network of websites that are controlled by the same person or group, and are often used to manipulate search engine rankings. While PBN backlinks can be effective in boosting rankings, they can also result in penalties from search engines if they're detected.

On the other hand, profile backlinks are links that are created by creating profiles on various websites and adding links back to your site in the profile information. While profile backlinks are generally considered less risky than PBN backlinks, they can also be low-quality and may not provide much value in terms of search engine rankings.

Ultimately, the quality of backlinks matters more than the quantity. It's better to focus on building high-quality backlinks from authoritative websites rather than relying on PBN or profile backlinks. It's also important to diversify your backlink portfolio and avoid relying too heavily on any one type of link.

eko34 said:

what is the quality of the pbns? there is only 1 outgoing link on the pbns?

Click to expand...

$5-$8 per Link from some marketplace vendor. 9 different outgoing links from the whole pbn. Pbn has ~40 articles.