ok, he's doing 'club' becausein Facebook Doorway method he tells you that putting it under 'Club' will keep your page alive basically. he says it's imperative in the video so this info probably got passed along into the forums. Fact of the matter is, it doesn't really matter - yes you might have a chance not to get deleted AS FAST with club but you can still get deleted. It all depends on what you're doing on the page, Facebook cracks down so hard on things involving facebook pages now so you have to be extremely careful with what you do, how you word the title. Hope this helps
edit: something i completely forgot and noticed scanning through this thread again was that you have to verify - i dont think it kills your page if you dont verify you just lose your publishing rights so it couldn't be that, but make sure you do this anyway so you can continue to make money from the page.