To those doing replyguy on X care to comment about this

eunicemartinez_21 said:

I was gonna try the replyguy method shared here by members to grow my twitter account.
Including in my plan is reply at least 300 a day which I read in on one of the X threads

Then I see this while browsing X:

Spoiler: tweet by someone

reply guys it’s time to get a new job
the new december x algo just killed the reply-guy meta
the new algo is completely powered by grok. with advanced AI, grok now judges every post’s value, originality, and effort.
low-effort posts & replies, excessive emojis, offensive/abusive content, and copy-paste replies will tank your reach

Here are grok’s official do’s & don’ts for replies:

Don’ts
- don’t go over 15–20 total posts/replies per day
- don’t reply faster than every 3 minutes
- don’t send 4+ replies to the same person/thread daily
- don’t post emoji-only or one-word replies
- don’t put links in >15% of your posts
- don’t spam only viral threads
- don’t repeat phrases or copy-paste replies
- don’t stay active if your impressions suddenly crash

Do’s
- do 2–3 thoughtful replies max per thread/person
- do write 2+ real sentences or add memes
- do 60–70% original posts (threads, images)
- do reply to every comment on your own posts
- do space activity 3–5 minutes apart
- do mix topics and accounts daily
- do get Premium+ & get id verified
- do pause 48h if your reach drops hard

any insight for a newbie like?
is replyguy method working just fine and I should just ignore this larp?
or should I include his advices on my strategy meaning trying to reach 300 a day isn't my plan anymore

Click to expand...

wizdorf said:

That sorta version no longer works. The new AI-powered feed is much better at detecting low-effort replies. Repetitive, obvious growth-hack behavior can actually tank your account’s trust score.

With current algo you can get more reach from 5 good replies than from 200 generic ones.

Also current AI ranking system clusters users by topic identity and pushes posts to similar audiences. If you reply everywhere with random one-liners, you'll confuse the model and it won't be able to map your audience. Try to find your niche and reply within that sphere.

I'd suggest just replying early to medium accounts (20k-200k followers). Also, you can’t grow off replies alone anymore, so you need to post regularly.

Based on our observation, these are the sweet spots for follower count / reply amount:

0-1k followers - 20-40 posts/daily (Train AI on your niche + get early visibility)
1k-10k followers - 15-30 posts/daily (Become known in your circle)
10k+ followers - 5-15 posts/daily (Maintain presence without diluting quality)

Click to expand...

Martel_The_M said:

Just automate it using PowerIn (for comments), like 150/day generated with AI, they're just more human than human, and the posts commented are keywords-based - or use Commentions, it does the same, but it also subtly sell your product/service in the comment by mentioning your brand.

No need to pay someone, at this stage a human is less effective and cost more than the A.I

Click to expand...