The Ugly Truth About Instagram Growth (What No One Admits)

alex_biz_dev

Junior Member
Premium Member
Joined
Feb 20, 2024
Messages
175
Reaction score
94
Aight dudes, real talk. I’ve grown multiple IG accounts to 100k+, and 90% of the "advice" out there is either outdated or just plain wrong.
Here’s the raw, unfiltered truth based on my experience:
1) Organic reach is dead (unless you do this)
Instagram wants you to pay for ads. Period.
But engagement groups (real ones, not those spammy Telegram ones) still work.
I joined a 5-person DM group where we’d like/comment within 5 mins of each post.
Result: Posts hit explore 70% more often.
2)Hashtags are useless now (Unless…)
Big hashtags = waste of time. Small, niche-specific ones (under 50k posts) still pull.
I used 3 broad + 4 niche + 3 branded hashtags per post.
Also, hashtags in comments >> captions (weird, but my reach improved).
3) The "Shadowban" myth (and what actually happens)
Instagram doesn’t "shadowban" you- it just stops pushing your content if it’s trash.
To fix it, delete low-performing posts (yes, even if they’re old). My reach bounced back in 2 weeks.
4) Buying followers? Here’s the catch…
I tested buying 5k followers. Big mistake.
Engagement tanked because my real followers got buried.
Instead, I bought high-retention bot comments (sounds shady, but it tricks IG’s algo into thinking my posts were popping).
Bottom Line: Stop following "rules." Test, adapt, and exploit the loopholes before they’re patched.
 
Solid breakdown, I agree on removing dead posts. IG’s algo seems to penalize overall profile engagement, not just per post.
 
Solid breakdown, I agree on removing dead posts. IG’s algo seems to penalize overall profile engagement, not just per post.
Totally. IG’s algo judges your entire profile’s "vibe". If you’ve got deadweight posts dragging down your avg engagement, it’s like showing up to a race with a flat tire. Deleting them is like an instant CTR boost for your newer content.

Side note: I’ve even seen accounts pivot niches faster after purging old posts vs starting fresh. The algo "forgets" your past performance quicker than people think.
 
M/S method is king imo, that would be my main takeaway from IG over last couple of years

It's scalable and will always lead to organic followers if you're targeting is good
 
M/S method is king imo, that would be my main takeaway from IG over last couple of years

It's scalable and will always lead to organic followers if you're targeting is good
M/S is definitely a beast when done right—especially for scaling. But most people screw it up by using trash proxies, running bot-like behavior on the slaves, or targeting too broad. The key is making the slaves look fully organic (story posts, random DMs, even reels) before funneling to the main. That said, it’s a long-game strategy. For quick algo wins, I still swear by nuking dead posts + micro-engagement groups.
 
Aight dudes, real talk. I’ve grown multiple IG accounts to 100k+, and 90% of the "advice" out there is either outdated or just plain wrong.
Here’s the raw, unfiltered truth based on my experience:
1) Organic reach is dead (unless you do this)
Instagram wants you to pay for ads. Period.
But engagement groups (real ones, not those spammy Telegram ones) still work.
I joined a 5-person DM group where we’d like/comment within 5 mins of each post.
Result: Posts hit explore 70% more often.
2)Hashtags are useless now (Unless…)
Big hashtags = waste of time. Small, niche-specific ones (under 50k posts) still pull.
I used 3 broad + 4 niche + 3 branded hashtags per post.
Also, hashtags in comments >> captions (weird, but my reach improved).
3) The "Shadowban" myth (and what actually happens)
Instagram doesn’t "shadowban" you- it just stops pushing your content if it’s trash.
To fix it, delete low-performing posts (yes, even if they’re old). My reach bounced back in 2 weeks.
4) Buying followers? Here’s the catch…
I tested buying 5k followers. Big mistake.
Engagement tanked because my real followers got buried.
Instead, I bought high-retention bot comments (sounds shady, but it tricks IG’s algo into thinking my posts were popping).
Bottom Line: Stop following "rules." Test, adapt, and exploit the loopholes before they’re patched.
Good Insights OP
 
M/S is definitely a beast when done right—especially for scaling. But most people screw it up by using trash proxies, running bot-like behavior on the slaves, or targeting too broad. The key is making the slaves look fully organic (story posts, random DMs, even reels) before funneling to the main. That said, it’s a long-game strategy. For quick algo wins, I still swear by nuking dead posts + micro-engagement groups.
Never tried the nuking dead posts part, what does that exactly look like?
 
Never tried the nuking dead posts part, what does that exactly look like?
Good question!
Nuking dead posts means deleting or archiving old content that’s dragging down your account’s overall engagement rate. Here’s exactly how I do it:
1) Identify dead posts
Go to your insights > Content > Sort by least engaged.
Flag any posts with:
Below-average likes/comments (e.g., 50% lower than your usual engagement).
High impressions but low engagement (means IG pushed it, but users ignored it- algorithm sees this as ‘bad content’).
2) Delete vs. Archive
Delete permanently if: The post is irrelevant to your current niche.
Engagement was abnormally low (e.g., 10 likes on a 100k-follower account).
Archive if: The post has sentimental/value but performed poorly (archiving hides it without hurting your "grid").
3) Re-upload winners
Take high-performing dead posts (good engagement but buried by time), tweak captions/hashtags, and repost them. Pro tip: Space these out to avoid spam flags.
Instagram’s algo judges your account’s ‘quality’ based on average engagement. Dead posts tank that average. After nuking 15–20% of my worst posts, one account’s reach jumped 37% in around 2 weeks because the algo recalculated my "engagement score". Don’t go nuclear- keep some older posts for social proof. Just prune the obvious duds.
 
Hey man, appreciate you sharing these insights! It’s wild how much things change on IG, and I’m definitely going to tweak my strategy based on your tips. Thanks for keeping it real!
 
That dm group hack is sneaky but smart
Any specific niche hashtags you swear by?
 
That dm group hack is sneaky but smart
Any specific niche hashtags you swear by?
Glad you found it useful!

Since hashtags are super niche-dependent, here’s how I find the right ones:
1) Reverse-Engineer Competitors
Check top posts from 3–5 competitors in your niche (accounts with 10k–100k followers).
Look for repeating small hashtags (under 50k posts) in their captions/comments.

2) Use Instagram’s Search
Type a broad keyword (e.g., “streetphotography”) > switch to "Tags" tab > filter by "Recent" (not "Top").
Target hashtags with 5k–50k posts- these are active but not oversaturated.

3) Test & Track
I use a 3-4-3 mix per post:
3 broad (200k–1M posts)
4 niche-specific (5k–50k posts)
3 branded (your own or community tags)

Track reach in Insights > if a small hashtag consistently brings reach, keep it.

Let's take a Fitness Niche as an example.
Instead of #Fitness (500M+ posts), I’d use:

#FunctionalFitness (48k posts)
#HomeGymMotivation (32k posts)
#TrainLikeAnAthlete (18k posts)

Avoid banned/spammy hashtags- check by searching the tag and seeing if "Recent’ posts are suppressed."
 
Back
Top