• Please take a moment to look over the Suggestions & Feedback rules before making a post: READ RULES HERE

Suggestion: Disable new thread function for new members

That might discourage serious new users too from joining the forum. Probably moderation of new threads from new users under 30 days old accounts would do alot better or maybe a limiting the number of threads they can create.
 
Or maybe a report button and if the thread gets more than x reports it is automatically deleted
 
Some forums have a thing where you have to for make 5+ posts before you can create a thread. Perhaps something like that could be implemented here.
 
Make rules, new member must have 50 post before can create thread..
 
Its not..I've been on forum with this requirement

It took me months to get above 50 posts. I would get turned off from a forum like that. It also encourages spamming and pointless posts so people can boost up their postcount. 10-15 is a perfect amount IMO.
 
This will alert mod or other user to report him..simple
There are enough reported posts already, which keeps the mods busy

That might discourage serious new users too from joining the forum. Probably moderation of new threads from new users under 30 days old accounts would do alot better or maybe a limiting the number of threads they can create.
The staff are already behind on BSTs and reported posts, so I don't know how adding more will help in that matter
 
It took me months to get above 50 posts. I would get turned off from a forum like that. It also encourages spamming and pointless posts so people can boost up their postcount. 10-15 is a perfect amount IMO.

If you like the forum, I guess that's not the problem ;)
 
You could set more rules for newcomers.
Like, can create a thread once at 2 hours.

Since most newcomers are looking to ask questions here it isn't fair to make them wait x hours or post y replies until they can create a thread.
They register, ask one question and need to wait 2 hours until they can create a new thread.

That way you avoid excessive spam and don't force users to spam more in order to create threads.

Cheers.
 
It’s a good idea in theory but the problem is there will be lots of people signing up for help and if they can’t start a thread I think it would be very off putting for genuine members.
 
That might discourage serious new users too from joining the forum. Probably moderation of new threads from new users under 30 days old accounts would do alot better or maybe a limiting the number of threads they can create.

Yes, I agree with this. Suppose any software user or business person searching for a solution and bumped in to this forum through google search or heard that he would find solution over here and wanted to post his query for immediate assistance, then can't and have to wait all the 30 days which he wouldn't and at the end he leave this forum.
Threads from newbies should be monitored.

What useless answer is this...
I like a lot of guys but I don't talk with all of them whole time.

It's not about talking. Everyone know's it's just to increase post count by making meaningless and boring posts.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Suggestion: Limit the new users access to 'one thread' a day for the first 30 days after signup.
This should cut down spam by bots to one thread(which can be reported and deleted asap) and if someone really has a question, they can ask it freely as well.

And if they have too many questions, this will encourage them to use the search button.
 
Back
Top