{SPLIT TEST} Indexing service INSTANTLINKINDEXER vs.

robibrk

robibrk

Regular Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2009
Messages
321
Reaction score
121
Guys i am sad of this bad preforming indexing services and lets do a split test between INSTANTLINKINDEXER and ONE HOUR INDEXING. This two sames to be best on the market.

TEST SETUP:

For the purpose of this test i have created 2 same projects on GSA (selected only 2 platforms that i mostly use and from my experience these links are pretty hard to index).


GSA PROJECT DETAILS:

I have set as well the limit: minimum PR n/a+ for the posting domain and both platforms are DF contextual. There will be total of 2000-3000 links for each project. Links created from project A will be submitted to INSTANTLINKINDEXER and from project B to ONE HOUR INDEXING.

For checking the indexed pages will be used SB.

I will update this thread soon as my links are submitted and as well after some period, final results will be posted in 3 weeks.


My quote from the instantlinkindexer sales thread:

I have subscribed to a monthly play 2 days ago to test this service. Till now i have tried almost all of them except this one and one hour indexing (i plan to test them as well) service. The true is i have there some rude (hard to index) 3 tiered links.

T1...Web 2.0
T2...Only DF Joomla platforms with spun article with PR3+
T3...Any kind of DF links with PR1+

I have as well some profile links, that will be put to the indexing service.

Till now i am a bit disappointed (i know google patched the instant indexing), none of the submitted links got indexed, but i wait some more like a week to make a final opinion. All together i had no special hopes, just hoped still a little bit for more.

Anyway the platform is top noch easy to use and really hope for some positive results in a week.
Click to expand...



NOTE: I am not affiliated with any of the indexing providers and i am posting real results as they will be.
 
Last edited:
Advertise on BHW
Subbed , having problems indexing links since months ago , let's see how this goes
 
Nice test.
@3lt0n1 - Big blog comments blasts and/or Xrumer blasts and i have 30-40% index rate on joomla k2 without any PR filters.

T3...Any kind of DF links with PR1+
Click to expand...
You are limiting yourself using filters at tier 2&3. If you want to be extra safe use additional web 2.0 tier but pr3+ filter in tier 2 wont help you alot. This websites have already tons of posts, no matter what PR this websites have.

Everything thats ******** in tier3 with pr1+ is simply wrong linking structure. You are missing tons of links. With better link structure your t2 links would be indexed without any indexers (ofc not fully indexed because thats not possible due to nature of these links).
 
satyr85 said:
Nice test.
@3lt0n1 - Big blog comments blasts and/or Xrumer blasts and i have 30-40% index rate on joomla k2 without any PR filters.


You are limiting yourself using filters at tier 2&3. If you want to be extra safe use additional web 2.0 tier but pr3+ filter in tier 2 wont help you alot. This websites have already tons of posts, no matter what PR this websites have.

Everything thats ******** in tier3 with pr1+ is simply wrong linking structure. You are missing tons of links. With better link structure your t2 links would be indexed without any indexers (ofc not fully indexed because thats not possible due to nature of these links).
Click to expand...

Thanks for your input. This is was the setup of my old project i am blasting with other kind of links the web 2.0 as i can. Now lets focus on this split test.

I have limited the links for this project because (but i am removing the filter now to PR n/a):
- higher domain PR links may indexing faster (not confirmed)
- want limited submits so that both campaign links are as much as possible similar

Do you use any indexing service?
At what time you get that 30-40% after you submit the links?
 
Last edited:
Following this case study, it should be interesting to see the final results.
Also, don't do any tiers to those links and don't build any other backlinks of course as that will ruin the testing and we will have no idea if it was those links or the indexing service that did the job.
 
I have split tested several indexing services last year and "onehourindexing" was the best at that time. Good luck with your split test! Will be waiting for the results.
 
higher domain PR links may indexing faster (not confirmed)
Click to expand...
I have tons of PR 0 and n/a contextual links indexed so PR is not a factor when it comes to indexing. 90% of my indexed contextuals have PR up to 1, 80% have PR n/a and 0.

Do you use any indexing service?
Click to expand...
I dont use any indexing service.

At what time you get that 30-40% after you submit the links?
Click to expand...
Tbh i dont measure time. Probably around 7-10 days. I see first results after 24 hours.
 
THUNDERELVI said:
Following this case study, it should be interesting to see the final results.
Also, don't do any tiers to those links and don't build any other backlinks of course as that will ruin the testing and we will have no idea if it was those links or the indexing service that did the job.
Click to expand...

I am not doing anything else with the links as i send them to the indexing service when done. I have decided that i randomize the links at the end and submit 1k of each of them, since i have the basic accounts.

satyr85 said:
I am not doing anything else with the links as i send them to the indexing service when done. I have decided that i randomize the links at the end and submit 1k of each of them, since i have the basic accounts.
Click to expand...

That's interesting, not even 20% of my links get indexed without doing anything with them. I am not a big fan of the indexing services, but sames they are needed to maximize the results, but lets wait first for the data.
 
Last edited:
I have done a little less as 5k links with both projects on GSA and now i am submitting 500 random url's for both projects to the indexing service.

Stats before i submitting are:

InstantLinkIndexer 500/2 indexed links
OneHourIndexing 500/0 links indexed

I check tomorrow again and will post the results.
 
As promised there is the first update after a bit more as 24 hours from the finished posting.


InstantLinkIndexer 500/2 indexed links
OneHourIndexing 500/0 links indexed

Stats are same as when i did finished with posting, so there after 24h is still NO benefit from any of the services. I was skeptical before i even started this comparison due to the fact, that none of the indexing providers bring the promised results. Sure i am testing on hard indexable platforms but hey, do we need indexing services for the "easy platforms", that index from self?
 
New update!

That results are disappointing and i am even more at the point, that indexing services are waste of resources and money.

Tools: SB, GSA.

Indexing services: InstantLinkIndexer, OneHourIndexing.

Methodology: Created 2 GSA campaigns with identical setup, selected only hard indexable platforms (all DF). After each of the projects hit 4500 submitted links exported them and randomized them with SB for each campaign and picked the first 500 to submit to indexing service.

Indexing test: SB.



[TABLE="width: 500, align: left"]
[TR]
[TD]Service
[/TD]
[TD]July 10. 2015
[/TD]
[TD]July 14. 2015
[/TD]
[TD]July 17. 2015[/TD]
[TD]July 20. 2015[/TD]
[TD]July 27. 2015[/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]InstantLinkIndexer[/TD]
[TD]500/2[/TD]
[TD]500/3[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[/TR]
[TR]
[TD]OneHourIndexing[/TD]
[TD]500/0[/TD]
[TD]500/0[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD]?[/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[TD][/TD]
[/TR]
[/TABLE]
 
Last edited:
This is very strange. I've used both instantlinkindexer and onehourindexing in the past and both had stellar results for me (instantlinkindexer was more value for money though). I haven't used both for a few months and I think its time to check and see what's up with the indexers.
 
Mikaelo said:
Wow - Interesting and disappointing.
Click to expand...

Till now a big disappointing, but i keep track results for minimum 1 month.

Chintoo said:
This is very strange. I've used both instantlinkindexer and onehourindexing in the past and both had stellar results for me (instantlinkindexer was more value for money though). I haven't used both for a few months and I think its time to check and see what's up with the indexers.
Click to expand...

It is really time to test them, especially now after the 1.st July when google patched some methods, that the indexing services used.
 
goldnote said:
I'm not having any success with instantlinkindexer either.
Click to expand...

The results are just as i expected, but i don't want to pull my final opinion till the test is running. I am sure, that 99% of the users not test how efficient are such services, just pay for nothing...
 
hi. I tested all indexing services : backlinksindexer.com , Link processor, Express Indexer, Link Centaur, Link Huggers, One Hour Indexing, instant link indexer . I'm a bit disappointed because the backlinks refuse to get indexed, even after a month. This indexing services worked excelent in the past (especially One Hour Indexing) , but starting from june 2015, they are all affected by some google changes.. I hope they will find solutions..
 
Advertise on BHW
You must log in or register to reply here.
Sign up now!

Main Menu

Home Main Forum List Black Hat SEO White Hat SEO BHW Newbie Guide Blogging Black Hat Tools Social Media Downloads

Marketplace

Account Selling Content / Copywriting EBooks / Methods Hosting Misc Proxies For Sale SEO - Link building SEO - Packages Social Media Social Media - Panels Web Design More

Making Money

Affiliate Programs Hire a Freelancer IM Journeys Making Money Pay Per Click Site Flipping Want to Buy

BlackHat World

Dispute Resolution Forum Suggestions & Feedback Introductions Lounge
Back
Top